I was not on the committee during the passage of the Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill. However, my colleague Liz Smith was, and at the time, she raised some concerns about the implementation of the part of the bill under discussion.
We cannot ignore the SPSO’s concerns. The previous pieces of subordinate legislation will be implemented in 30 days; however, as the Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014 (Part 4 and Part 5 Complaints) Order 2016 will be implemented in August, we seem to have a six-month window of opportunity that I hope can be used to make changes that deal with the ombudsman’s concerns.
I am sure that the minister is familiar with the ombudsman’s concerns. He asks for a “simpler approach”—the approach that is currently being used to modernise social work complaints—to be adopted, and he says that if the order were to go through, it could take up to eight years for it to be changed by Parliament, which is something that he probably knows from previous experience. It is therefore obviously better to try to change it within the next six months.
I note, too, that the ombudsman says:
“it would be remiss of me not to note that this particular legislative approach of creating the detail of complaints processes through regulations is now out of line with other areas”.
He also emphasises his
“support for the Government’s aim of aligning the complaints procedure in this order with the model CHP in operation across the public sector.”
I am simply asking the minister to take into account the concerns that the ombudsman has raised in his letter of 23 February to the convener. Given that we have six months until the order will be implemented, such a request does not seem unreasonable. The ombudsman also suggests bringing the procedures in line with other procedures that are already out there, which seems a very sensible approach. Can the order be delayed so that we can look at it again and use the time prior to implementation to take on board what appears to be a very reasonable request by the ombudsman, who has more experience of complaints procedures than anyone around this table?
12:45