Yes.
Official Report · Committee
Information and Communication Technology
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Chief Superintendent Macpherson 56
- Martin Leven Police Scotland 54
- Christine Grahame SNP 51
- Kevin Stewart SNP 34
- John Finnie Ind 17
- Graeme Pearson Lab 15
- Elaine Murray Lab 9
- Chief Superintendent Hamish Macpherson Police Scotland 1
The record
237 contributions · showing 201–237Surely Accenture would have done that before the system left the factory, if I can use that metaphor.
We had no sight of the internal quality testing that it did. That is the way in which such projects work. We get the system handed over to us, we play with it and we find out how it is working. My honest opinion is that the senior managers in Accenture, who are the people we face up against, were probably not aware of the issues until we highlighted them to them.
Crumbs—I would not have them fix my pipes and radiators; they would be telling me that they were all right when I still had leaks.
It would seem that there has been a breach of trust. At the very least, people do not appear to have acted in good faith. I am not necessarily asking you to comment on that.
The report that we have mentions
“the findings of the Root Cause Analysis Assessment”,
which we are told
“were presented to Police Scotland on 12 November 2015.”
It says that the assessment
“was carried out by an independent Accenture team”.
Presumably that was an in-house team.
14:15
Indeed.
The team was independent in as much as it was unconnected with the initial project. Is that the level of independence?
That is correct. It was an Accenture team, but no one on it was involved in i6. I have had an update from the team of people who carried out the assessment. I have no doubt of their professionalism in carrying out the review. We got back an honest review. I am not in a position to share that because it was given to me without prejudice.
This may not be a good parallel, but in the update you told us that, on Storm Unity, Cambridgeshire Constabulary undertook
“an assurance review of our readiness”.
Was there anyone else representing the police interest that could have looked at this?
With regard to?
I think that I understand your question, Mr Finnie. We asked Cambridgeshire Constabulary, as an independent third party that has already delivered a product that we are trying to deliver, to have a look and tell us where we were going right and where we were going wrong. That was different from the independent root cause analysis test, which was an internal Accenture model. We cannot influence that—we cannot ask Accenture to get in its rivals to look at its own analysis.
No, no. I understand that. However, just as you used Cambridgeshire to look at the project, was there any opportunity to have anyone unconnected with the immediate team that had been involved for Police Scotland to look at it?
Are you suggesting that we should have got an external team to look at the supplier product that we were already very critical of at that stage?
Yes, indeed—to have a fresh look at it. I am not saying that to be critical of Police Scotland but, sometimes, you can be so immersed in something that—
The root cause analysis was sent to my team internally and presented to Martin Leven’s team. That was the opportunity for Martin’s team or Police Scotland’s technical people to have a look at that independently and coldly and ask the same questions that I did of the assessment and then, on the back of that, look at the remediation plan for how Accenture was going to fix the issues that were found. To be fair to the Accenture team, I found its review to be honest and independent.
Right. Will the remediation plan be published?
We are discussing the remediation plan. As it stands, the numbers do not work out—it is too long for me. Therefore, we are looking for a modular approach. That has been put on the table, and we will be looking at that over the next eight weeks. As a result, we will, I hope, end up with a plan that we can work to that would get out the modules to our officers as quickly as possible. That is the goal for me.
Obviously, the modules have to go out to your officers. What is the consequence for the training of staff and officers? People may already have been trained on some aspects of the system.
We had not commenced the training. We updated you on that last time we were at the sub-committee. After the hard-disk issue, we cancelled the training. It was shortly after that meeting that we identified the issues. If we go for a modular training plan, that will require modular training, obviously. Over the next few weeks, we will be working through the detail of that.
What happens if Accenture does not get it sorted? What are your contingency plans?
I have undertaken to the SPA to provide an options appraisal, which will include continuing the journey in various guises. There are two options in the paper—the one presented by Accenture and the one that we now have, which is the alternative roll-out plan. I have also looked at other contingencies, including having other frameworks or rolling out interim solutions across the country. We are doing that hand in hand with Martin Leven’s team.
To a certain extent, there must be lessons for the public sector. Every IT project that is commissioned by the public sector seems to run into trouble, whether it is to do with common agricultural policy payments or whatever.
If I can say anything to reassure you, it is that as identified in the Audit Scotland’s reviews and in the gateway reviews, the project—this has nothing to do with me; most of it pre-dates me—has been managed contractually very well from the onset. We have used external expertise and, as a result of that, we have a robust contract. That one thing that you definitely want to take from this is that the contract is robust. There has been no other cost for Police Scotland. I think that there will be no other cost for Police Scotland. That is an absolute positive to take.
Can we always engineer a position where we will never end up in a similar position? My suspicion is that such things happen not just in the public sector but all the time in the private sector—we just do not see it as overtly.
I think that it is a problem in the industry.
This goes back to the point that Mr Pearson made about the platform project and the lessons learned from it. We looked at every major public sector IT project. We looked at the high-profile failures that members will be very aware of, not just in Scotland but across the UK. At the heart of every single one of those public sector IT failures was a private sector company delivering it. That is why we went into the contract discussions very robustly, and we think that we have a watertight contract that protects Police Scotland and its interests.
I think that it is a problem in the industry.
Everything that we have discussed so far is very important. I want to come back to a quote from two years ago, when the chief constable said:
“It is worth emphasising that i6 will cover 80 per cent of the current operational police activity, so it is absolutely massive as far as the organisation is concerned.”—Official Report, Justice Sub-Committee on Policing, 27 June 2013; c 144.
Operational officers are waiting for i6 to be delivered. We have heard a lot about governance and all the rest of it, and I am satisfied that there are a lot of good checks and balances. When will we deliver to the officers the radical changes that are required? Elaine Murray mentioned options. If there is a plan for the journey ahead, when do you anticipate that we will deliver the system for officers so that they can do their work better?
You are right that i6 covers 80 per cent of the data flow in operational policing. Since Police Scotland launched, we have successfully launched 23 national policing systems that have significantly changed the day-to-day working environment for officers across the country. We are in the middle of a roll-out of a brand new desktop environment and a brand new network across the country, involving desktop collaboration. We have not just stopped because of i6. Although i6 covers 80 per cent of operational policing data, it is not the be-all and end-all and it is not the case that the police force cannot operate without it.
My concern about i6 being delayed, which is where Mr Pearson is probably going on this, is that, because of the delay, we have some legacy systems that are past the end of their scheduled life cycle. We are working through remedial plans to replace some of those systems in the very short term with systems that we already have in other parts of the country and that are more up to date.
I presume that those remedial plans to deal with the threat that you mentioned of systems failure will have a cost for the service. Will those additional costs be borne in mind when it comes to dealing with whatever the future is for i6?
Yes.
I think that I raised that when I asked about indirect costs, and whether things will have to be written off or moderated.
I am going to stop there because, as the witnesses will know, we cannot sit after 2.30 and we have other business. Unless you have anything further to say to the committee off your own bat, we will move on to our next item.
I would absolutely like the sub-committee to be aware that this has been a difficult session for us, as I am sure members can imagine. The focus of the sub-committee appears to be on i6, but the session was originally going to be about the progression of IT systems, and i6 is one of several hundred IT systems that currently operate in Police Scotland. I produced an update for members, which you all have.
We have read it.
It shows the tremendous success that we have had with the other IT systems. I came to the meeting in 2013 that Mr Pearson has referred to and discussed the blueprint with members. I can absolutely confirm that we have a tremendous track record of delivering the key commitments that we put into that blueprint.
We have launched 23 national systems and we retain our IT staff. We have done that against a challenging background of difficulty with retaining the skill set in the IT department. There is an inability to recruit in the public sector in Scotland because of the salaries that we attribute to some of the key skill sets.
I appreciate all that, but you will understand why the committee wishes to focus on what is a very large project that has had very large problems.
I absolutely understand.
The session has been helpful, but I am afraid that I will have to cut short your pitch on behalf of Police Scotland.
I will suspend for a minute to let the witnesses leave.
14:24 Meeting suspended.
14:24 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 25 Feb 2016 →- 13:15 Information and Communication Technology Committee business · 237
- 14:15 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.