Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Reservoirs (Enforcement etc) (Scotland) Order 2016 [Draft]

Wednesday 24 February 2016 Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee About 10:30 Subordinate legislation 20 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

20 contributions
Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Item 4 is subordinate legislation. We welcome once again the Minister for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform, Dr Aileen McLeod, and Scottish Government official Neil Ritchie. They are joined by Claire Dodd, reservoirs policy officer, Scottish Government.

Aileen McLeod SNP South Scotland
link

I am pleased to still be with the committee to support the committee’s consideration of the draft Reservoirs (Enforcement etc) (Scotland) Order 2016.

From 1 April this year, reservoirs in Scotland with a capacity of 25,000m3 or more will be regulated by SEPA under a new regime that is provided for in part 1 of the Reservoirs (Scotland) Act 2011. Under the new regime, SEPA will regulate each reservoir, taking into account the risk that it poses to public safety. In particular, SEPA will be responsible for ensuring that reservoir managers comply with the duties that are imposed on them under the new regime.

A number of sections in the 2011 act have already been commenced and regulations have been brought into force that create the detailed framework for implementation of the 2011 act. This order is part of that framework and makes provision for a number of new enforcement measures for SEPA. Those enforcement measures will provide SEPA with a better range of interventions so that it can enforce part 1 of the act effectively and proportionately.

The order will give SEPA the power to serve, first, a stop notice to prohibit a reservoir manager from carrying out certain activities until specified steps have been taken; secondly, a restraint notice to ensure that non-compliant acts do not continue or recur; or, lastly, a restoration notice to require steps to be taken to restore the position to what it would have been if previous non-compliant acts had not been committed.

Those measures are part of a wider framework of enforcement measures open to SEPA and they will not be used in isolation. By virtue of separate legislation that has been made under the Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Act 2014, SEPA also has the option of imposing monetary penalties or of accepting enforcement undertakings in relation to specified offences under part 1 of the 2011 act.

SEPA will also continue to refer significant, persistent and deliberate offending to the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service for consideration of whether to prosecute.

SEPA is well aware of the significance of the additional powers and responsibilities that we propose to give it and it is committed to ensuring that the measures are used responsibly. There are safeguards in the order, such as the right of individuals to make written representations and to appeal against enforcement decisions. In particular, SEPA is also required to publish guidance about the use of the powers conferred on it by the order. We do not expect that enforcement measures will be frequently used. They are intended to support prevention and proportionate risk management.

I ask the committee to support the instrument.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Thank you. Various members wish to respond to that—Michael Russell, first of all.

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

I am very supportive of the legislation and the order, but I want to probe the situation a little with regard to the reservoirs that are affected and the costs.

The business and regulatory impact assessment states that there are 690 controlled reservoirs of the size under regulation, which is 25,000m3 or more. Of those, 250 are owned by a variety of private estates, individuals, trusts and community groups. Those are the ones that I am most concerned about, in particular those under individual ownership. There is the potential for very considerable necessary expenditure, particularly as it is an open secret that the Reservoirs Act 1975 was more honoured in the breach than in the observance. We know from incidents that took place in 2008 and 2009, if I am right, that those reservoirs were not well maintained.

Is there an estimate of how many of those reservoirs require work to be done; of what the cost will be; and of what SEPA will have to do to make that happen? I find it difficult to believe that there will not be a significant cost, and some of the cost will fall on bodies that probably do not have the assets to undertake those repairs. The situation is more complex than it appears. The work will have to be done, but I fear that the Government may in the end have to step in.

Claire Dodd Scottish Government
link

I do not have the details. The BRIA was carried out for the order. All the reservoirs come under the 1975 act. Not that many changes are being made—a high-risk reservoir must still have a supervising engineer in place at all times and must have a 10-yearly inspection report, as under the 1975 act. I am not aware that there are outstanding issues with regard to what Mr Russell describes.

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

I am happy to have a conversation about the matter. I seem to recall that an incident near Johnstone, or somewhere in Renfrewshire, resulted in the discovery that there was no supervising engineer who could be contacted. It was recognised that among the lower category of reservoirs—those with a capacity between 10,000m3 and 25,000m3—there were likely to be a number where a supervising engineer might exist but not have been involved for a very long period of time.

My worry does not concern the legislation or the order but the likelihood that significant numbers of reservoirs will be discovered where the resources are not great enough to do the work that is required. I am simply raising the issue because I think that it will require attention from the Government at some stage. By definition, we do not know about these things until something happens.

Secondly, there are likely to be some burdens on reservoirs that are part of properties for sale. I know of one case in my constituency in which the sale has been considerably delayed because of worry about the legislation and what it might mean. I think that legislating is the right thing to do, but we should consider issues such as the fact that some reservoirs may continue to deteriorate because they cannot be sold as burdens are now being applied that cannot be met. Again, because it is a matter of public safety, that would require intervention from the Scottish Government, because local authorities would be very reluctant get involved. The legislation does not sideline local authorities, but it takes them away from the centre of attention.

Aileen McLeod SNP South Scotland
link

I am certainly happy to bear that in mind. Mr Russell makes a number of very good points for us to consider further.

Neil Ritchie
link

Further to that, I, like Claire Dodd, am not aware of any significant problems, but we are happy to have a discussion with Mr Russell. It would probably be helpful to involve SEPA in any such discussion, given its operational engagement.

We are in effect talking about the costs of maintaining and running reservoirs, which should be done irrespective of the legislation in place. We are discussing today the order that helps us to deliver and enforce that and avoid problems emerging. We are conscious that there are a number of problems that are not specific to reservoirs in which SEPA gets involved where there can be on-going liability issues associated with abandoned sites. We are actively working, as part of our better environmental regulation, to avoid that happening in the first place.

10:30

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

There is no point fining people who cannot afford to do the basic maintenance work. That just makes the situation worse. However, I would be grateful for a conversation with SEPA and the Scottish Government to ensure that there is a recognition that some of these problems exist.

Graeme Dey SNP Angus South
link

This is on a point of information. If we accept Mike Russell’s point about the resources that may be available at the smaller reservoirs, it strikes me that the greater risk might lie there. Why are things being done in a staged way, with the reservoirs of between 10,000m3 and 25,000m3 coming into the regime at some point in the future? When will that happen?

Aileen McLeod SNP South Scotland
link

Under the old regime, all the reservoirs with a capacity of 25,000m3 of water or more were regulated in a similar way. Under the new regime, SEPA will assess the risk that each reservoir poses. Those that pose a greater risk will be inspected more frequently and will be more closely regulated. We have said that, from 1 April this year, SEPA will assume full responsibility for the regulation of reservoirs with capacities greater than 25,000m3. At some point in the future—Neil Ritchie can perhaps clarify this—the regime may be extended to regulate reservoirs with a capacity of between 10,000m3 and 25,000m3 for the first time.

Neil Ritchie
link

When we introduced the bill that became the Reservoirs (Scotland) Act 2011, we were clear that we were focusing on the existing regulatory regime for reservoirs of 25,000m3, which we thought represented the greater opportunity and potential risk. Once we have that regime in place, we will be looking to extend it. I cannot give a precise timing at this point, because we will need to have that discussion with wider stakeholders including individual operators of the smaller reservoirs, but there is an intention to expand the measures.

A further issue that we need to take into account is the resourcing that is required to do that. It has been quite an extended process to do all the required mapping to understand the risks and to identify which category the 25,000m3 reservoirs fit within.

Graeme Dey SNP Angus South
link

Do we know roughly how many of the smaller reservoirs currently exist in Scotland?

Neil Ritchie
link

No, we do not have a firm figure. We did not have a firm figure for the 25,000m3 ones until last year and until the registration process had been undertaken. If I recall correctly, when we went through the Reservoirs (Scotland) Bill, our initial estimate was around 500 to 600 reservoirs. At that point, we thought that 600 was at the upper end of the spectrum.

Claudia Beamish Lab South Scotland
link

Has there been or is there likely to be any assessment of the relationship between more extreme weather events and these reservoirs? I ask mainly because constituents have raised issues with me about reservoirs in South Scotland. I understand from SEPA that those arose from misinformation—rumours rather than fact—and the matter has been clarified for my constituents. However, there is an issue there. I suspect that it does not fit specifically within the order on enforcement, but the issue of risk obviously fits somewhere.

Aileen McLeod SNP South Scotland
link

I will answer your question in two parts. The 2011 act requires SEPA to

“establish and maintain”

a public

“controlled reservoirs register”,

which includes flood maps. Those reservoir flood maps show the area of land that is likely to be flooded in the event of an uncontrolled release of water from a reservoir. That relates to the very low-likelihood situation of a structure or structures completely failing. The main purpose of the maps was to assist SEPA in assigning a risk designation to each reservoir, as required by the 2011 act. Obviously, the risk of water escaping from a reservoir is extremely low, and there have been no major dam failures in the UK since the advent of the first reservoir safety legislation in 1930.

We know that reservoirs can be used for flood storage purposes. St Mary’s Loch, in the Scottish Borders, is an example of that. It is part of the Selkirk flood protection scheme and can be used to store water during a flood event. Last December, the works at St Mary’s Loch helped Selkirk to avoid the worst of the flooding damage that was caused by storm Desmond.

Taking water out of a reservoir can be a complex matter. In general, reservoirs are not managed as flood defences.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

We move on to the Croft House Grant (Scotland) Regulations 2016.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

As there are no further questions, we will move to item 5, which is to consider motion S4M-15450 and ask the committee to recommend approval of the Reservoirs (Enforcement etc) (Scotland) Order 2016 draft.

Motion moved,

That the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee recommends that the Reservoirs (Enforcement etc) (Scotland) Order 2016 draft be approved.—Aileen McLeod.

Motion agreed to.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I thank the minister and her officials.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 28
  3. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 20
  4. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  5. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  6. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  7. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  8. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  9. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
  10. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 5

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.