Under agenda item 2, the committee will take evidence on the draft Air Quality (Scotland) (Amendment) Regulations 2016. We welcome Dr Aileen McLeod, Minister for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform; Neil Ritchie, branch head for natural assets and flooding; and Andrew Taylor, air-quality policy manager. Good morning, minister. Do you wish to speak to the draft regulations?
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Air Quality (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2016 [Draft]
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Aileen McLeod SNP 7
- Rob Gibson SNP 6
- Andrew Taylor Scottish Government 5
- Sarah Boyack Lab 2
- Angus MacDonald SNP 2
- Claudia Beamish Lab 2
- Graeme Dey SNP 2
- Neil Ritchie Scottish Government 1
- Dave Thompson SNP 1
The record
28 contributionsThank you, convener. I am delighted to be here this morning as the committee considers the draft regulations, which I hope will make an important contribution to our continuing efforts to tackle air pollution.
We have made significant progress in improving air quality over recent decades. Emissions from our industrial and domestic sources have been reduced through tighter controls, as have emissions from transport, through increasingly stringent fuel and exhaust emissions standards.
However, pockets of poorer air quality remain in many of Scotland’s towns and cities. In almost all cases, transport is the cause, as the increasing number of vehicles on our roads continues to outpace technological improvements.
Unlike the dark smoke belching from factory chimneys and houses in previous times, pollutants including fine particulate matter and nitrogen oxides are largely invisible, but they are no less significant in terms of their impact on human health.
Although poor air quality affects all of us, vulnerable groups of people in society are disproportionately affected: the very young, the elderly and those with existing respiratory and cardiovascular conditions. The Scottish Government is therefore determined to build on our achievements to date and to drive down pollution levels still further.
In November last year we launched “Cleaner Air for Scotland—The Road to a Healthier Future”, Scotland’s first distinct air-quality strategy, which sets out a long-term vision for us to have the best air quality in Europe.
One of the long list of actions in the strategy is a commitment to introduce a mandatory objective for the fine particulate matter known as PM2.5. That is the subject of the draft regulations that we are considering this morning. An increasing body of scientific evidence shows that PM2.5 is one of the most significant air pollutants in terms of its impact on human health.
Based on that evidence, we have decided to adopt the World Health Organization’s guideline value for PM2.5 in Scottish legislation, making us the first country in Europe to do so. Achieving that objective will be challenging, but it underlines our commitment to continue delivering improvements to air quality in Scotland.
I ask the committee to support the draft regulations.
A report out yesterday said that 40,000 people across the United Kingdom will die early deaths because of air pollution. Could you spell out for us the particular impact of PM2.5, how it affects people’s health and what difference the regulations will make in practice regarding cars, lorries, buses and other vehicles, particularly in our cities, where there are failures regarding air-quality management areas? I want to understand what difference the regulations will make in practice and how they will impact on the logistics industry and people using cars in their day-to-day lives.
The data that Public Health England published in 2014 covering the whole of the United Kingdom suggested that around 2,000 premature deaths each year in Scotland might be associated with PM2.5 pollution, so the new objective will provide a focus for addressing that issue. There will obviously be a need to increase the number of PM2.5 monitoring stations as well.
Consultation on the proposals generated overwhelming support for and recognition of the Scottish Government’s commitment to deliver further improvements in air quality. At that, I will hand over to Andrew Taylor.
The important thing about PM2.5 in health terms is that the particles are obviously very small. They penetrate deeply into the lung and cause respiratory and cardiovascular problems. The larger particles tend to be filtered out before they get to that stage. There is an overwhelming body of evidence that shows that PM2.5 has significant health impacts.
As the minister said, introducing the new objective will give us a focus on tackling that pollutant in the future. Until now, Scotland has not had a legal objective for addressing PM2.5. Bringing the objective into regulations gives us an impetus for taking action and puts a responsibility on local authorities to monitor for the pollutant and to try to assess levels of PM2.5 pollution in their areas. Once those figures are available, they will provide the focus for taking action and introducing measures into local air-quality action plans to tackle that important pollutant.
If PM2.5 is similar to other the pollutants that we are tackling at the moment, which it is likely to be, its major source is likely to be transport, so a lot of the focus of the actions that are taken will be to try to reduce pollutant levels from transport emissions.
The cleaner air for Scotland strategy sets out a series of actions for the short, medium and long term. In relation to health, we are including in legislation and Scottish objectives the World Health Organization guideline values for PM10 and PM2.5. We will also require our national health service boards and their local authority partners to include reference to air quality and health in the next revision of their joint health protection plans, which should identify and address specific local priority issues. We obviously also have a long list of actions that we will take in the transport sector.
I have some air-quality management areas in my constituency and I have a technical question. How easy will it be, practically, to upgrade the AQMA monitors in local areas to check for PM2.5? Is that a fairly straightforward task?
We are considering that issue at the moment. We already have a fairly extensive network of monitors for PM10, which is a slightly larger size particle. We have a good spread of them throughout Scotland and many of them can be directly modified to introduce a PM2.5 monitoring element as well. We are in the process of reviewing the network at the moment to find out how many of those existing monitors can be modified in that way and, after that, to identify gaps in the network where we need to introduce completely new monitors.
Do you have a timeline for that?
That review should be complete in the next two or three months. After that, we will draw up a programme for rolling out the new PM2.5 monitoring network.
There was recently news in the press about local authorities failing to monitor the effects in particular streets. A lot of this work ties up with the nature and use of the monitoring equipment. Are you confident that local authorities will be able to cope with those tasks and are ready to do so?
All local authorities have air-quality management areas, so they have in place plans that contain a wide range of actions that are designed to improve local air quality. The Scottish Government is working closely with local authorities and other partners to help them to implement their plans.
Good morning to you and your officials, minister. My question partly follows on from the convener’s question. No business and regulatory impact assessment has been carried out, and committee paper 1 states that the draft regulations have no financial consequences. Will there be costs to local authorities in developing further monitoring? If such costs do not fall to local authorities, where will they fall? Although I appreciate that a lot of research is still to be done into fine particles, I note that Andrew Taylor said that transport was likely to be the cause. To what degree can those dangerous particles be identified? What would happen if the limit were exceeded? What action would be taken?
I will let Andrew Taylor answer the second part of your question. On the financial implications of the new objective, as I have said, there is a need to increase the number of PM2.5 monitoring stations. However, the aim is not to add an additional financial burden to our local authorities, so we will utilise central Government’s budgets for that purpose. Where possible, we will modify existing monitoring equipment to reduce costs.
On the action that local authorities might take, as the minister has said, many local authorities have in place air-quality action plans that contain a wide range of measures based on monitoring of existing pollutants of concern, such as PM10, nitrogen dioxide and sulphur dioxide. By introducing the monitoring of a new pollutant, PM2.5, we are simply adapting a well-established process rather than introducing a new requirement for local authorities. However, any local authority that identifies PM2.5 issues in its local area following monitoring will be expected to develop further action plan measures that focus on that pollutant. In many cases, a lot of the causes and solutions in relation to PM10 and PM2.5 will be the same. In practice, a lot of local authorities are taking action that will reduce PM2.5 anyway. As has been said, having the objective in regulations provides a specific focus for addressing that pollutant.
I am still not clear about this. It would be helpful not only for me but for the committee and others more generally to understand what action a local authority can take. What are we likely to see in the action plans if there are fine particles or other health-affecting particles that come from transport?
Local authorities can take a range of measures, and what measures they decide to take will depend on local circumstances. An example would be to clean up vehicles. Local authorities may choose to make emissions improvements to their vehicle fleets, and they may liaise with bus companies to improve the bus fleet and hauliers to improve the heavy goods vehicle fleet. They may consider measures that improve traffic flow or restrict vehicle access to particular areas at particular times. Obviously, each local authority will have a different set of problems.
I will follow-up Claudia Beamish’s point. I want a bit of clarity. It strikes me that there may be a far bigger picture that goes beyond local and national Government. Where does this issue sit in relation to the World Health Organization report of about three years ago, which identified a problem with the filters in modern diesel vehicles? It emerged that the filters had been tested in long-distance scenarios rather than in vehicles sitting idling in cities. Those idling vehicles spit out particles to a far greater degree than the vehicles with the older-style diesel filters. If the two matters are related, the picture is far bigger than could be addressed by a council or a national Government. Is there any tie up between the two issues?
10:15
A number of actions can be taken. I do not recall the report of two or three years ago that you refer to, but there is work at European Union level on vehicle standards and specifying what is allowed to be manufactured and placed on the roads in the single market. In the past nine months, there has been a high-profile discussion about real-world emissions levels. The minister will hear an update on that at next week’s environment council.
We can also do work at the Scotland level. A lot of Andrew Taylor’s work with colleagues in Transport Scotland and elsewhere in the Government is about providing support and tools to local authorities to deliver real-world benefits on the ground, rather than replicating that 32 times. As we move forward to deliver the cleaner air for Scotland strategy, we are working with the Scottish Environment Protection Agency on how it can provide further technical support to deliver those targeted local actions.
Just to be clear, I am not in any way against the measures—we absolutely need to do this. I just wanted information on where we think the issue sits. That World Health Organization report was maybe three or four years ago.
Of course, electric vehicles have zero emissions, which is one way to ensure that there is no PM2.5—or anything else, for that matter. However, there still seems to be an awful lot of misinformation or misunderstanding out there. As the minister will know, I recently got an electric vehicle—a Nissan Leaf—and I know that electric vehicles are being used effectively on the island of Mull. I saw a lady from Mull quoted as saying that an electric vehicle would be very good in the city and on the island but, for longer distances, fossil fuel vehicles are better. However, that is not actually true. I have used my vehicle to drive down from Inverness to Edinburgh two or three times now. Just over a week ago, I went via Fort William. The only hindrance is the number of rapid charging points, which restricts you a little. You have to plan well in advance, but the situation is improving.
Local authorities and other public bodies could move more rapidly towards electric vehicles. The batteries are improving all the time. If we put more effort into that, that might help to resolve many of the air-quality issues. I am interested in your view on that, minister.
You are absolutely right. The Government has invested £11 million in the development of the chargeplace Scotland network of electric vehicle charging points. There are now more than 400 units, which equates to more than 800 public charging bays, with many more being commissioned in the coming months. Work to provide high-powered rapid charging points on strategic routes connecting Scotland’s towns and cities is also continuing. There have probably been more sales of electric vehicles in the past year than there were in the previous five years put together.
Never let it be said that the RACCE Committee fails to look at the minutiae of particulates as well as the minutiae of secondary legislation. It is all very interesting.
As there are no further questions for the minister, we move to agenda item 3, which is consideration of motion S4M-15453.
Motion moved,
That the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee recommends that the Air Quality (Scotland) Amendment Regulations draft be approved.—Aileen McLeod.
Does any member wish to speak?
I will just briefly say that I strongly support the measure. However, as has been teased out in the questions from members, although it looks like a really boring statutory instrument, it is potentially quite radical in that it adds to the monitoring process in local authority areas. Before Christmas, I had a members’ business debate on air quality, and we have had discussions about bus fleets, lorries, council vehicles and cars. We will need to make fairly radical changes once we get more monitoring in our communities. In my patch, we have several areas that regularly fail the air-quality management targets.
I do not think that anyone expected us to ask lots of questions about the draft regulations, but this needs to be a trigger for wider change in our transport strategies and in support for our local authorities in cleaning up our air.
Minister, do you wish to wind up?
I am happy not to do so.
Motion agreed to.
We will take a short break to allow the officials to change.
10:20 Meeting suspended.
10:21 On resuming—
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportNo recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.
In this meeting
Everything on 24 Feb 2016 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 28
- 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 20
- 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
- 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 5
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.