To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-03244)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Kezia Dugdale Lab 9
- Tricia Marwick 7
- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 6
- Ruth Davidson Con 1
The record
23 contributionsI have planned engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Yesterday, the Deputy First Minister said that claims by trade unions about the number of job losses that will result from the Scottish National Party’s budget cuts were “utterly exaggerated.” Does the First Minister agree with her deputy?
I am glad that we are on the issue of claims. First, I say that any job losses in any sector are a matter of regret; that is why this Government has a policy of no compulsory redundancies.
John Swinney got something wrong in the chamber yesterday. He said that, based on the most recent figures, employment in the devolved public sector had gone down by 500. I have to tell the Deputy First Minister that that was a misreading of the statistics. Employment in the devolved public sector, according to the most recent statistics, has gone up by 500.
The reason why it is important to treat these issues seriously and not to be irresponsible in exaggerating is illustrated by something that Kezia Dugdale said in the chamber yesterday, which was repeated by Jackie Baillie. She said that Clackmannanshire Council was going to reduce the number of its jobs by 350. That is a puzzling claim, because Clackmannanshire Council’s budget was set the day before yesterday and the actual number is less than a third of the one that Kezia Dugdale cited. [Interruption.]
Order. Let us hear the First Minister.
These are important matters. This is not an easy time for councils or the public sector, and it is not helped by Labour’s wild scaremongering, which is more about its desperate fight for survival than it is about anything else.
The First Minister calls it “wild scaremongering”. Here are the words of Willie McGonigle from Unite:
“We’ve lost 40,000 local government jobs since 2010 and over the next year we will likely lose a further 15,000 as a result of the Scottish Government’s cuts ... To suggest the Budget cuts will have ‘a minimal impact on jobs or services’ is frankly astounding.”
Those are not my words but the words of the leading trade union in this country.
The casual disregard with which John Swinney dismissed those who are losing their jobs left many workers sick to their stomach yesterday. To hear the First Minister back him up today is even worse, because despite the pretence from the Government, the reality is that cuts are happening all across the country because of a choice that the SNP made.
SNP-controlled councils just this week passed plans to cut the number of staff in their schools. Now the First Minister disagrees with the trade unions and workers about the number of job losses. Will she tell us how many jobs she thinks will be lost as a result of the SNP budget?
I have just said that yesterday in this chamber, Kezia Dugdale exaggerated the impact in one council by a factor of three. The figures that she just quoted are not borne out by the reality of council budgets. In Aberdeenshire Council, where Labour is part of the administration, there will be a “minimal impact on jobs”. Argyll and Bute Council says that it is “doing all possible” to keep the impact on jobs to a minimum. Aberdeen City Council, where there is a Labour administration, says:
“we are not looking at job cuts.”
Kezia Dugdale has been caught red-handed exaggerating the position in Clackmannanshire Council. This is important, because these issues are serious and they deserve to be treated seriously. At the last First Minister’s question time, Kezia Dugdale stood up and said that Perth and Kinross Council was going to cut childcare, help for those with additional support needs, early years teachers and maths and English teachers. Perth and Kinross Council set its budget later that same day. It agreed a budget for 2016-17 that has no reduction in early years teachers and no reduction in childcare, that maintains teacher numbers and that does not cut the additional support needs budget—it increases it by 6 per cent.
There is a gulf here between what Labour says in the chamber and the reality of what is happening across the country. Before we go any further with any more claims from Labour, I wonder whether Kezia Dugdale will take the opportunity to retract what she said yesterday about Clackmannanshire and what she said two weeks ago about Perth and Kinross. Both claims were flatly wrong.
The First Minister is trying to deny that there are cuts in education. We have seen 4,000—[Interruption.]
Order. Let us hear Ms Dugdale.
We have seen 4,000 fewer teachers in this country since she came into office. She cannot reprofile that away.
The First Minister did not like hearing the truth from Unite, so let us see what she has to say about the GMB. [Interruption.]
Order.
Gary Smith of the GMB in Scotland, which represents public sector workers—don’t forget that, First Minister—has said:
“Government ministers need to take their heads out of the sand about the devastating impact of the cuts they are making on essential local services right across Scotland.”
That is the reality.
Nicola Sturgeon is the first to line up to set up task forces and summits when jobs disappear in the private sector, but when teachers, classroom assistants and office staff find themselves out of work because of choices that she has made, she is nowhere to be seen. This afternoon, SNP-controlled Dundee City Council will vote on plans to cut the budget for supply teachers, on plans to close the high school and on plans to cut the budget for classroom materials. [Interruption.]
Order.
For a decade, the First Minister has told us that more powers will mean fewer cuts, but when she had the chance to use the powers of this Parliament to stop cuts to schools and save jobs, she bottled it with her austerity budget. How many jobs need to be lost and how many cuts need to be made before this First Minister will finally use the powers that she has? [Applause.]
Order.
Given that I have already demonstrated that what Kezia Dugdale said two weeks ago about Perth and Kinross was wrong and that what she said yesterday about Clackmannanshire was wrong, I think that people should take what she is saying today about Dundee with a pinch of salt.
It is interesting that Kezia Dugdale stands here and complains about a reduction in the number of teachers when yesterday in this chamber she joined forces with the Conservatives against a budget that expressly maintains the number of teachers. That is the blatant hypocrisy of Labour in the chamber.
Kezia Dugdale likes to quote people—well, let me quote a couple of her own colleagues. How about the Labour leader of East Lothian Council, who should be familiar to Iain Gray? Earlier this month, he said:
“Our budget will enable us to invest in the ... future through increased provision for education and promoting the local economy.”
Or we could have the Labour leader of West Lothian Council, who said:
“we have a budget that focuses on and meets the needs of local people whilst protecting services that ... impact on the most vulnerable”.
Or we could go to Aberdeen. The Labour leader in Aberdeen has today joined forces with the Conservatives to issue a letter to every council tax payer there. That letter says that John Swinney’s budget is so dreadful that it has enabled Aberdeen City Council to
“protect frontline services and jobs for the people of Aberdeen”
and progress an
“ambitious”
and
“comprehensive plan which supports Education, new Infrastructure, roads, culture and prevention against flooding.”
Terrible John Swinney, enabling a council to do all of that. [Applause.]
Order. Ms Dugdale.
The First Minister might like to remember that the Green Party—those notable right wingers at the back of the chamber—also voted against her budget yesterday. I will tell her what I voted against—[Interruption.]
Order.
I voted against cuts to jobs, cuts to schools and cuts to local services.
Presiding Officer,
“no politician can be taken seriously about wanting to tackle poverty and inequality, unless they are also prepared to challenge the current Westminster model of austerity.”
Those are not my words; they are Nicola Sturgeon’s words. However, her budget yesterday used this Parliament as a conveyor belt for Westminster austerity. We were faced with a choice between using the powers of this Parliament to invest in the future or imposing more cuts on vital public services. When the First Minister knows that thousands of jobs will be lost and the impact that that will have on generations of young people, why on earth did she choose more cuts?
Not only do Kezia Dugdale’s claims bear no relation to reality, but I have debunked most of the claims that she has made through a reference to the reality in Perth and Kinross, Clackmannanshire and Aberdeen.
I will outline to Kezia Dugdale exactly what she joined with the Conservatives to vote against yesterday. She and her colleagues—arm in arm and shoulder to shoulder with the Tories—voted against the record funding for the national health service; the doubling of the education attainment fund; the increased funding for social care services; the protection of the police budget in real terms; and the protection of apprenticeships. Perhaps most gallingly of all, given everything that the Labour Party has had to say on the issue over the past couple of years, Labour MSPs joined with the Conservatives to vote against a living wage for care workers.
A lot of quotes have been thrown around this chamber today, and I will end with one from Kezia Dugdale herself. When asked this week whether she will come second in the Scottish Parliament elections, Kezia Dugdale said, “Yes”, and I think that we have just seen why.
And I think that even that might be in doubt.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 25 Feb 2016 →- Decommissioning Jobs (Dundee) Questions · 5
- Medical and Humanitarian Aid (Syria) Questions · 4
- Planning System Review (Consultation) Questions · 8
- Orkney Islands Council (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Prostate Cancer (Treatment) Questions · 4
- Clydesdale Bank Flotation (Economic Impact) Questions · 4
- Renewables Sector (Support) Questions · 6
- Childhood Obesity Questions · 7
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 23
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Fiscal Framework First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Accident and Emergency Waiting Times First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Nursery Education First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Prestwick Airport First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Israel (Cultural Engagement) Members’ business · 18
- Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2016 [Draft] Debate · 30
- Child Protection Statement · 22
- Scottish Elections (Dates) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 17
- Criminal Verdicts (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 20
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 8
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.