I thank colleagues whose support for the motion has enabled us to have this debate today. The fact that 38 MSPs from across the political spectrum have supported it does, I suggest, endorse the motion’s title, “The Importance of Local Newspapers”. That expression of concern over the threat to the future existence or, at the very least, the future direction of a sizeable number of Scottish weekly titles stretching from east Fife to Ellon, Carrick to Carnoustie and Galloway to Glenrothes reflects the value that we all place on the history and traditions of the papers in question.
The Arbroath Herald in my constituency can trace its roots back to 1838. Just last week, with the passing of Arthur Binnie, we were reminded of the contribution that those papers have made to journalism not just in Scotland and the United Kingdom, but far wider. Arthur Binnie’s main claim to fame may have been that he was the man who got the scoop on the discovery of the stone of destiny at Arbroath abbey following its liberation from Westminster abbey in 1951, but in a distinguished career he went on to be instrumental in the founding in Wales of a training centre for journalists from third-world countries.
Local newspapers have done much to nurture journalistic talent down the years, so we permit their demise at our peril. Although circulation may be declining across the Johnston Press titles that are highlighted in the motion—declining, in part, as a consequence of cuts—the communities that are served by those papers still care about them, as is evidenced by events in Lanark. The Carluke Gazette and the Lanark Gazette used to have offices in both Carluke and Lanark. The former was closed last year, followed more recently by the closure of the office in Lanark. I understand that the depleted ranks of journalists are having to work from home. A local petition has been raised to get the Lanark decision reversed.
In signing the motion and debating the issue today, we are speaking for our constituents and sending a message to Johnston Press that we want our papers to survive, and that we will work with it to try to achieve that. Of course, that requires the company to be willing to engage and not to become defensive following coverage of its infamous labelling of a number of titles in the stable as “sub-core”, which is giving rise to concerns being expressed about what exactly that means for the future of those papers. We need clarity on just how many titles are affected and we need detailed information on reported plans to split the Scottish titles into four geographical groupings. We also want to understand why, while that doubt has been cast over the future of those titles and a reported 20 redundancies are being sought from the weeklies portfolio, the group is in advanced talks about buying i newspaper for a reputed £24 million.
Having aired the issue at First Minister’s questions on 22 January, I wrote to Johnston Press seeking a meeting to discuss the future of the titles that are located in my constituency. In doing so, I raised the status of Carnoustie’s Guide & Gazette and the Kirriemuir Herald because, although neither title had been listed as being “sub-core”, they are produced in conjunction with the Arbroath Herald and Forfar Dispatch using shared staff. That approach has been met with deafening silence, but I can tell Parliament that both are indeed on the sub-core list, which means that it now amounts to at least 23 Scottish titles. I say “at least 23” because, if the company forgot about the Guide & Gazette and Kirriemuir Herald or viewed them simply as editions of the named titles, who is to say that other Scots papers are not looked upon as sub-core, whatever that means and whatever implications it might have? Indeed, I understand that a similar situation may exist not far from Parliament: the Linlithgow Journal and Gazette is on the list, but no reference is made to the Queensferry Gazette or Bo’ness Journal, which come from the same stable.
If we, looking in from the outside, have concerns about where this is headed, how must the journalists and other staff feel? It says everything about where the employees of the company are at that, on the back of highlighting the situation at First Minister’s question time, I was contacted by two sets of staff who thanked me for what they saw as a welcome supportive gesture. One long-serving editorial staff member told me that he and his colleagues feared that his newspaper might be allowed to wither to the point at which the doors would be closed. One former editor of a number of titles within the group revealed to me that such had been the level of cost cutting that members of the public had wandered into the office just to check whether it was still open. The ending of window cleaning to save a bit of cash had left the outside of the building looking as if had been closed.
Up my way, we have seen the full gamut of scaling back. Photographers have been done away with and reporters have had taking pictures added to the demands that are made on them, along with feeding the web presence and videoing interviews. The unique identities of titles that reflected the communities that they served have been diminished by increasing components of the papers becoming common in design and content, which leaves a reduced proportion of editions carrying genuinely local content—the lifeblood of local papers.
I will sympathise with Johnston Press for a second. Regardless of the wisdom of some of the acquisition decisions that it has taken—most notably the Scotsman Publications group—times are tough for print media. Johnston Press is not alone in making the kind of cutbacks that it has made. Papers are trapped in a vicious circle in which circulation and advertising revenues drop, so they cut costs, which leads to a diminished product, so circulation and advertising revenue fall further—and on it goes.
That problem is industry wide and is not confined to the Johnston Press group, but the focus of the debate is on a stable of papers that, in my experience, continue to try and practise local journalism in the right way in the face of shrinking staff numbers, increasing demands being made of them and rock-bottom morale. The thing is, I like the kind of stuff that we get in such papers. I want to read about the good that is going on in our communities rather than the unrelenting negativity that seems to characterise much of the daily press. I am with the community organisations that look forward to seeing a pic or wee story about them appear in print.
Moreover, in the midst of all the challenges that they face, such papers continue to give youngsters a start and to train them properly. If there is a threat to the continuing existence of those titles, how diminished will the opportunities be for youngsters to forge a career in journalism? That matters. If the print media are to have a future and those papers are to survive in some form, we need young journalists coming through, especially when titles such as those that operate under the Angus County Press umbrella train their staff to do the job in the traditional way—as an old hack, I say that it is the right way. We must do whatever is possible to protect that.
My purpose in securing the debate was not to give Johnston Press a kicking, but to highlight the importance of local newspapers—a subject about which I have spoken previously in the chamber. The fact that the company has—it is claimed—shed around 50 per cent of the editorial posts that it had seven years ago makes it little different to many others, as, it is sad to say, does the reputed prospect of further job losses. The debate is about the big picture: the future of local papers that matter to their communities.
12:39