To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-03229)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 11
- Tricia Marwick 9
- Kezia Dugdale Lab 6
- Neil Findlay Lab 1
The record
27 contributionsI understand that Jeremy Hunt will shortly announce in the House of Commons that the United Kingdom Government intends to impose a new contract on junior doctors. I want to make it clear to the chamber that that will not apply in Scotland. This is not in my view the way to treat health professionals, so we will not be imposing a contract. Instead, we will continue to work with our junior doctors and other national health service staff in the best interests of patients.
Later today, I will have engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Labour will protect education spending in real terms for the whole of the next session of Parliament. Will the First Minister do the same if she is re-elected?
We will set out our full plans for education and other matters in our manifesto, but I just point out to Kezia Dugdale the record of this Government so far. According to the most recent published statistics, average spend per primary pupil has increased by 11 per cent or £496 since 2006; average spend per secondary school pupil has increased by 10 per cent or £618 since 2006-07; and total revenue spending on schools has risen by £208 million. That is the record of this Scottish National Party Government, and we will continue to act to protect the numbers of teachers in our schools and to address the attainment gap. I am happy to ask the people of Scotland in a few weeks’ time to judge us on that record.
Here is the record of the SNP Government: 4,000 fewer teachers; 152,000 fewer college students; and the gap between the richest and the rest as wide as it has ever been. I listened very carefully to the First Minister, and there was no commitment to protect education spending in real terms for the next five years. We can therefore take from that response that education spending will be cut again, with even more severe consequences.
This afternoon, SNP-controlled Perth and Kinross Council will hold a special budget meeting to discuss the cuts that it is being forced to make because of the choice that the First Minister has made. Perth and Kinross is the SNP-controlled council in John Swinney’s backyard. I have here the planned cuts—186 pages of them—and they include cuts to childcare, cuts to help for those with additional support needs, cuts to early years teachers and maths and cuts to English teachers. Page after page contains a warning of SNP cuts that will harm our children’s future. That is the reality from one of the First Minister’s own councils. When will she stop pretending that her budget will not harm our children’s future?
As Kezia Dugdale is aware, we have put forward a settlement for local authorities that—yes—involves a 2 per cent reduction in their total revenue spending, but that reduction is offset by the £250 million that we are investing from the national health service into social care. That settlement, which has now been accepted by all of the local authorities in Scotland, enables us to protect households by freezing the council tax; to protect the number of teachers in our schools; to invest in and expand social care; and, from October this year, to ensure that all social care workers are paid a living wage.
That is the reality of the Government’s position. It should be seen, of course, in the context of a budget cut from Westminster that has been imposed on this Government—a budget cut that Labour, when it campaigned so vigorously with the Conservatives, was quite happy to see imposed on this Parliament.
That ship sailed the moment Nicola Sturgeon stood side by side with the Tories last week to impose cuts on our community. [Interruption.]
Order.
Let us be clear about what these cuts really mean. The document that I am holding from Perth and Kinross Council—an SNP council—says that the council is cutting the entire budget for supply teachers. I quote from the SNP council paper directly on the consequences of that cut:
“classes may have to be sent home and possibly schools closed”.
That is the scale of the cuts that the First Minister is forcing on schools.
Today, the Scottish Parliament will have to set the Scottish rate of income tax for the very first time. The First Minister will have another chance to keep the anti-austerity promise that she made to stop the cuts to schools and other vital public services. For years, she has argued that more powers would mean fewer cuts. Today the First Minister will have the chance to use those powers to stop those cuts. Will she finally take it?
In the interests of accuracy, the ship of Labour campaigning hand in hand with the Tories has not sailed but has been sunk—and it has sunk Scottish Labour completely.
Let us turn to Labour’s policy of raising tax—[Interruption.]
Order. Stop heckling the First Minister.
Let us turn to Labour’s policy of raising the basic rate of income tax for every worker in our country earning £11,000 and above.
Liar. [Interruption.]
Order.
Members: Withdraw.
Presiding Officer, we know how desperate the Labour Party is by the volume of the insults that Labour members like to sling across the chamber. [Interruption.]
Order.
There is a debate to be had in Scotland about tax, but it should be a proper, grown-up debate about tax. Labour’s policy is written on the back of a fag packet. The lack of detail is embarrassing, but then it is a policy put forward by a party that knows that it is 100 million miles away from being a credible Opposition, let alone a credible alternative Government. It is a dishonest policy, because Labour knows that it would hit the low paid, which is why Labour is suggesting a rebate but has not been able to answer a single question about how that would work in practice. It is also a policy that, in its presentation by Labour, is out of touch and callous.
Kezia Dugdale stands there as someone who, like me—[Interruption.]
Order.
Like all of us, Kezia Dugdale has a decent salary, yet she suggests that increasing the tax bill of the low paid by 5 per cent somehow does not matter. I say to her that she should tell that to someone who is struggling to make ends meet or to someone who has suffered years of pay freezes and is counting every penny. It is not fair and it is not progressive to shift the burden of Tory austerity on to the shoulders of the low paid. That is probably why less than one in three voters backs Labour’s policy.
Kezia Dugdale rose—
One moment, Ms Dugdale, please sit down. I already warned the chamber about heckling the First Minister or anyone else who is speaking. A remark came across the chamber. I did not quite hear it but, from the reaction in the chamber, a word was used that is clearly unparliamentary. I will review the Official Report. If the member who used that word wishes to admit it and withdraw it now, that would be helpful. If not, I will take action this afternoon. [Interruption.]
Members: Withdraw.
It is very clear from the evidence from the Institute for Public Policy Research, the Resolution Foundation, the Scottish Parliament information centre, the House of Commons library, Professor David Eiser and Professor David Bell that Labour’s proposals are fair and workable. That is why council leader after council leader has backed our proposals and why union leader after union leader has said that they are fair. That is the truth that the First Minister cannot escape.
The First Minister and I have something in common—we both oppose George Osborne’s austerity and we both want the best for our country. Where we part is that Labour has a fair plan that will ask some of us to pay a bit more and the wealthiest few to pay a lot more. In so doing, we can stop these cuts—cuts that would damage our economy and stop young people achieving their potential; cuts that would see councils across the country slash spending on our schools; and cuts to childcare that would hold back working families. Faced with the choice between using the powers of this Parliament to invest and cutting schools, why does the First Minister choose cuts?
Kezia Dugdale and Labour do not oppose George Osborne’s austerity; they campaigned with the Tories to keep us subject to George Osborne’s austerity. What Labour wants to do is not to end austerity but to shift the burden of that austerity on to the shoulders of low-paid workers. Kezia Dugdale mentioned the Resolution Foundation. The Resolution Foundation said that, on Labour’s policy, there will be “hard cases” and poor families will lose out. Kezia Dugdale mentioned David Bell and David Eiser from the University of Stirling. Here is what they said about Labour’s rebate:
“This part of the proposal would require a comprehensive data sharing arrangement between HMRC and local authorities in Scotland, and it would impose a substantial administrative burden on local authorities. There are also questions as to whether such an arrangement would be possible under the Scotland Act 2012.”
Labour is perpetrating a con trick on the lowest-paid workers in our society. The truth of the matter is that my tax bill would rise by 2.7 per cent if Labour’s proposal was implemented but the tax bill of a teacher or a nurse would go up by 5 per cent. That is not fair.
However, I want to give Kezia Dugdale an opportunity to explain. She wants to see this tax rise implemented in seven weeks’ time so, if she wants to be taken seriously, let her answer these questions about her rebate: how much will it cost to administer? [Interruption.] How will eligibility be assessed?
First Minister—
How many of the half million pensioners who will pay a tax rise—
First Minister—
—will even get the rebate?
First Minister, the Opposition puts questions to you. You do not put questions to the Opposition.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 11 Feb 2016 →- Cromarty Firth (Ship-to-ship Oil Transfer) Questions · 6
- General Practitioners (Reported Shortage in Rural Areas) Questions · 4
- “Personal Footcare Guidance” (Review) Questions · 4
- European Union Membership (Referendum) Questions · 4
- NHS Lanarkshire (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Climate Change Budget (Reduction) Questions · 4
- Train Services (Edinburgh to Glasgow) Questions · 4
- Mental Health Issues (Awareness) Questions · 4
- Glasgow Queen Street Tunnel (Closure) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 27
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Housing Benefit (Supported Accommodation and Women’s Aid Refuges) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- North Sea Decommissioning (Forecast until 2040) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Purchasing Managers Index First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Local Newspapers Members’ business · 13
- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Community Justice (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 42
- Community Justice (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 14
- Burial and Cremation (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 21
- Scottish Rate of Income Tax: Resolution Debate · 126
- Burial and Cremation (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 2
- Point of Order Procedure · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.