Before I move the motion, I declare an interest, as I have already done, as the honorary president of the Clyde Fishermen’s Association. The main job for me in the association is not to take part in any policy decisions that are made—indeed, I have never actually been to one of its proper meetings—but to turn up at the annual lunch, which I have been doing for 15 years.
I have to say that at the annual lunch I have heard politicians from pretty much every party in this Parliament extolling the virtues of artisanal fishing for nephrops and scallops, which underpins many jobs, many livelihoods and many families in Tarbert, Campbeltown and the Ayrshire coast. I have heard politicians from all parties singing the praises of the Clyde fishermen and extolling their virtues. It is important that, in their hour of need, those fishermen get the same support from politicians that they get at the annual lunch.
10:00
MPAs must have specific objectives that are supported by the best available evidence. It is self-evident that they should meet their conservation objectives and, where possible, contribute to the maintenance of existing sustainable activity—in this context, fishing.
There is an issue to do with the Scottish Government’s introduction of a tranche of MPAs for the protection of specific features. A logical process, which was agreed by all stakeholders, including the Scottish Fishermen’s Federation, was run by Marine Scotland over four years. The features to be protected were agreed, locations were selected and a series of workshops were held over the final 18-month period, which verified the process and examined in detail the potential management measures that would meet the policy’s aims and objectives.
Scottish Natural Heritage, the statutory nature adviser, participated throughout and made recommendations on optimum measures to meet the conservation objectives. I talked about that earlier in the meeting.
The process was meant to be an exemplar of how to plan a network of MPAs, which would demonstrate Scottish leadership to other areas. I think that the network is actually a UK network, not a Scottish one. In mid-2015, 20 areas were formally designated. However, when ministers announced the accompanying management measures on which they had decided, the approach was as expected in 16 areas, but for four areas in the west of Scotland there were departures into measures that were more severe than would be required to meet the conservation objectives.
The problem with that is the potential damage to the sustainable fishing activities that the MPAs are meant to maintain. The central point is that the extra measures are not required to meet the conservation objectives. I am talking about conservation, not restoration—they are two different things. The Scottish Government underplayed the damage to established sustainable fishing that would result; it used broad figures that indicated little damage to fishing overall in percentage terms. Although that is correct, the localised impact on the delicate communities about which Dave Thompson talked is enormous. That point was made to the cabinet secretary, and an additional economic assessment was rapidly provided at the correct level of detail to illuminate the practical effects of what was proposed.
I emphasise that the measures in 16 of the 20 proposed areas were accepted by the Scottish Fishermen’s Federation—I am talking about not the CFA but the SFF. The Scottish Government reacted to protests about three of the four disputed MPAs by embarking on further consultation—the cabinet secretary’s decisions are awaited. For one area, the south Arran MPA, there has been no further discussion or consultation, and the unmodified execution of the statutory instrument in that regard—the South Arran Marine Conservation Order 2015—is being considered by this committee today. In effect, this is the consultation on that proposal.
For all the MPAs, management measures are zonal. That is a logical approach; where features exist they are delineated and suitable protection measures are applied. Existing sustainable activity within the MPA is permitted on a zonal basis, where that is possible without compromising the conservation objectives.
If members will bear with me for a moment, I will talk about some of the areas. I am not talking about south Arran; I am talking about Loch Sween, Loch Goil and Loch Fyne. It will be noted that all forms of mobile fishing are prohibited in Loch Sween. A much restricted fishery is permitted at the mouth of Loch Sween, which is the hatched area on the map that I am looking at. In the two approaches to management that Marine Scotland proposed, the maerl beds at the head of the loch and at the side of Linne Mhuirich were to be fully protected. That position was supported by the Clyde Fishermen’s Association. There are no maerl beds in the centre of the loch, although it contains a small area of burrowed mud that harbours the mud volcano worm, which is a terrifying sounding thing, although I am told that it is not. That feature might be of interest, but it does not meet the criteria for protection in OSPAR—the Convention for the Protection of the Marine Environment of the North-East Atlantic—region III, which is the European Atlantic coast, given that other substantial areas of burrowed mud have been offered protection.
More importantly, the area was in fact opened up to being a multi-species environment from being a completely dead acidic environment by the operation of small trawlers; it was actually improved by the trawling. The acidity was introduced by the downwash of sitka spruce needles from the surrounding forestry plantations. The Nature Conservancy Council, SNH’s predecessor, did not argue against that case when it attempted to have Loch Sween closed to mobile fishing.
The Clyde Fishermen’s Association is prepared to compromise in order to safeguard the very small but important artisanal summer fishery in the loch. Neither Marine Scotland nor SNH suggests that the burrowed mud feature requires mobile fishing to be prohibited. The compromise that is offered is that a summer fishery, with dates to be agreed by Marine Scotland, would be allowed, with the same class of vessel that is permitted to fish at the mouth of the loch, which I believe is anything under 75 tonnes. In management terms, given that there is no restriction on the size of vessel that can fish in the loch, that compromise represents a more than satisfactory reduction in effort.
I am trying to go through the points on the different lochs. On Loch Fyne, for many years, to meet conservation requests from third parties, the CFA has given an undertaking that mobile vessels in its membership will not operate in certain areas. On the map that I am looking at, those areas are to the north of the line marked A to B and to the north-west of the line marked C to A. The CFA is prepared for that voluntary arrangement to be made statutory, as is proposed. However, it does not accept that a complete prohibition on mobile fishing gear to the south of the line C to A to B has been justified on any scientific basis. It proposes that the restricted mobile fishing that is allowed in the black cross-hatched area be extended north to the line C to A to B.
To the south of that, lying immediately to the north-west of the flame shell protected area, is a large rectangular area in which all forms of mobile fishing are prohibited. The CFA is not making a fuss about the fact that flame shells do not actually merit OSPAR protection; its point is that the flame shell bed is already protected by a separate part of the order and is given a buffer zone that is already more than adequate for protection. The further protection that will be given by the prohibition of fishing in the rectangular area is therefore disproportionate. In any event, it does not contain any feature justifying OSPAR or Marine (Scotland) Act 2010 protection. Mobile fishing on the proposed restricted basis should therefore still be allowed in that rectangular area.
That brings me to the end of what I have to say on the first motion.
I move,
That the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee recommends that the Inshore Fishing (Prohibition of Fishing and Fishing Methods) (Scotland) Order 2015 (SSI 2015/435) be annulled.