Agenda item 3 is consideration of continued petitions. We will consider two petitions together: PE1480, by Amanda Kopel on behalf of the Frank Kopel Alzheimer's awareness campaign, on Alzheimer’s and dementia awareness; and PE1533, by Jeff Adamson on behalf of Scotland against the care tax, on abolition of non-residential social care charges for older and disabled people. Members have a note from the clerk on the committee’s previous consideration of the petitions and submissions from the Scottish Government and both petitioners.
With regard to the Government’s response, I see what it is saying about Professor Bell’s work, but there is other work out there on the care tax and the charges. I am sure that Professor Bell did not pick that £300 million figure out of thin air, but I am not entirely sure that it relates exactly to the issue that we are talking about. It is not necessarily the case that information that you collect on one subject is relevant to the specifics of another.
I would like to get back if not directly to Professor Bell then certainly to the Government to ask about the basis of that figure, because there are questions that need to be asked about it. We have seen information from Scotland against the care tax in particular, and I have spoken to that organisation regularly, and I think that the figures that we are talking about here are quite wide of the mark compared with what that organisation is specifically asking for.
As I have said, I am not querying Professor Bell’s £300 million figure. I am just not entirely sure that it relates specifically to this issue and therefore using it as the basis on which to respond to the petition is questionable. Do colleagues have other comments on the information that we have?
