First, I thank the colleagues who signed my motion, which has allowed us to have this members’ business debate on Marischal Square. I also welcome the reject Marischal Square development campaigners to the public gallery.
It would be fair to say that almost every Aberdonian was pleased to hear that the former council headquarters, St Nicholas house, was to be demolished. It was regarded as a monstrosity, an eyesore, and a blot on the landscape. Many hoped that its demise would lead to a sensitive development of the site and the construction of a city square to complement the iconic Marischal college and the historic Provost Skene’s house, which had been hidden from view for decades. Alas, that was not to be and the Labour-led council has pushed on with a scheme that is about as popular as a visit by King Herod to the Bethlehem nursery.
Dave Urquhart, a contributor to the reject Marischal Square development campaign Facebook site, talks for many when he says:
“When the old St Nicholas house was demolished we could finally see Provost Skene’s House and Marischal College in their glory. The people of Aberdeen are crying out for this to be an open space, a civic square but those who are meant to represent them are not listening.”
He goes on to say:
“Why could this be? What financial millstone have these councillors draped around the people who live in Aberdeen, who work in Aberdeen and are proud of Aberdeen?”
Fellow objector David McLeod says that the scheme is
“An architectural disaster, perpetuating its predecessor, and imposing a financial burden on Council Tax payers for many years to come.”
Many feel that the planning process was flawed and that the full impact of the scheme did not become apparent until 3D imagery of the development was produced by Pinnacle Visualisation. It would be fair to say that folk were extremely disappointed that the Scottish Government did not call in the application. However, I do not want to concentrate on the planning aspects. Instead, I want to focus on the perceived lack of openness and transparency around the financial deal that Aberdeen City Council has entered into with Muse Developments and Aviva.
The reject Marischal Square development campaign group has been assiduous in trying to get to the truth about the deal and Mr Bill Skidmore has been at the forefront of those investigations. In a freedom of information letter to the council, Mr Skidmore asked for a copy of the business plan for the scheme and received a reply from the council that said,
“there is no business plan at this time”.
There is no business plan at this time and yet, according to the campaigners, in the worst-case scenario,
“Aberdeen tax payers will be underwriting the risk of under-occupancy of the development by guaranteeing £175 million to Aviva shareholders over 35 years.”
It has been said by a great number of folk that it is somewhat ironic that Aberdeen City Council is willing to take on a risk that a multinational insurance company is not prepared to underwrite.
In recent days, campaigners have managed to acquire two pages of the summary of the bids for the Marischal Square development and I will hand a copy of those pages to the minister after the debate this evening. I will also send those documents to Audit Scotland for its perusal.
Yesterday, Mr Skidmore wrote to all Aberdeen city councillors about the content of those documents. In his letter, he said:
“I got the impression when reading the Summary Bid information that the author was trying to steer Councillors away from Muse. Too many unquantifiable risks, the need for a full life costing, a ‘risk’ fund and a ‘sinking’ fund to limit the damage of unquantifiable void periods over the full life of the lease. Instead, Councillors were taken in by the prospect of £2.6M income from the property or nearly £100M over the 35-year lease period—for a FULLY LET SCHEME!”
He also said:
“This is undeniably a bad investment decision, one that represents ‘Worst Value’ for the city when compared with the other bid proposals.”
Of course, all these grand plans, schemes and strategies were drawn up at a time when the oil price was high, when Aberdeen was booming and property was at a premium. Sadly, the outlook has changed, but has Aberdeen City Council’s Labour-led administration changed its business plan to manage the new risks that have appeared over the horizon? No, because, as we have already established, it does not have a business plan.
There is no business plan but, according to the summary bid information, the council is required to upkeep, manage and maintain the building. The document says that those costs can generally be recovered from tenants, but what if there are only a few tenants? The document goes on to point out a number of other pitfalls that, unfortunately, I do not have time to go over today.