Thank you, Deputy Presiding Officer. As you rightly said, the motion is in the name of Bob Doris, but he is unfortunately unable to be here due to a family bereavement. I am sure that the thoughts of all of us are with him and his family.
Recently, along with my colleagues Bill Kidd and Bob Doris, I had the pleasure of meeting a joint trade union group to discuss their concerns about the future of City Building and RSBI. I welcome to the gallery the trade union officials whom we met, and others including Ronnie Regan, Frank Wallace from the Union of Construction, Allied Trades and Technicians, Dave King from Unite, James Bradley from Unison, and Steven McGurk and Robert Mooney from Community. I thank them for their attendance.
Before I turn to their considerable concerns, which we discussed that day, I want to draw members’ attention to the success that the workforce has created since RSBI was brought under the aegis of City Building. Prior to 2007, RSBI was the responsibility of Glasgow City Council’s social work department. Many of us will remember Royal Strathclyde Blindcraft Industries as an organisation that was dedicated to making a difference in the community, with its roots as a supported facility for visually impaired people—an ethos that continues to this day.
Even with a motivated and dedicated workforce, RSBI was making a loss of £2 million on a £4 million turnover. That was due mainly to four factors: there was no clear business plan, there was no tangible business strategy, there was a nebulous marketing strategy that was totally unconnected to the incoherent sales plan, and products were being made that ultimately gathered dust due to low sales. The only outcome was an expanding inventory that was going unsold.
Let us compare that with the current position. RSBI contributes £5 million a year to the city coffers. It is included in the Scottish Government framework for supported businesses. The business combines commercial success with socially inclusive policies—50 per cent of the 260 employees have disabilities. Other employees come from closed former Remploy sites and others have armed forces backgrounds—six positions are ring fenced for returning disabled ex-servicemen and women. With 400 apprentices, it is the largest employer of apprentices in Scotland.
I want to draw attention to a newspaper article about a young lady. One of the things that RSBI does in relation to apprenticeships is that, out of the 2200 employees, 98 are female apprentices. In March this year, an article in the Evening Times discussed that, and mentioned Tracey Jefferson from Battlefield who is studying for a higher national certificate in construction management. Tracey is a constituent of mine, and I want to congratulate her and wish her well for her future with the company.
The Scottish Government also recognises RSBI as one of Scotland’s most successful factories when it is measured against three criteria: turnover, employment and the diversity of the work that it undertakes. RSBI has a range of contracts from across the United Kingdom, including the University of Aberdeen and the University of Cambridge, a number of local authorities and housing departments, and it is providing clients with the largest range of products in the organisation's history.
Those of us who visited RSBI at Springburn were struck by the calibre and professionalism of the workforce. The business adheres to a socially responsible model while being aware of the need for clear commercial objectives. Everyone we spoke to had the same aims; they all want to grow the business to continue to provide sustainable employment for some of the most vulnerable people in our communities.
The socially inclusive ethos manifests itself through their social enterprise model, which not only provides employment for people with disabilities, but provides vocational training to schools. It offers training in furniture manufacturing to 35 school pupils from additional support for learning schools every week during term time, and it ring fences job opportunities. It is not only schools that RSBI engages with; it also collaborates with the myriad community organisations across the city that give opportunities to disabled adults.
It is not unreasonable to ask why the workforce is having to endure so much anxiety when we look at the commercial and social success they have made of RSBI. There has been talk of a possible joint venture between City Building and RSBI and Glasgow Housing Association. That proposal brings both opportunities and concerns. The leadership of Glasgow City Council, which plays a pivotal role in the situation, is yet to be forthcoming with answers to a number of questions that RSBI and City Building employees have. They include unanswered questions about the suggestion that a third of the City Building workforce, which is 600 to 900 people, will transfer to the repairs and maintenance team of GHA’s parent organisation, the Wheatley Group, and about major concerns about Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations 2006 obligations because there has been no clarification of how or by whom the process will be managed.
There is also a fear that there could be a significant impact on the skills profile of the remaining staff, which would potentially reduce City Building’s ability to maintain a diverse range of profitable services and possibly compromise the organisation’s future resilience. The flexibility of the workforce could be undermined, which could lead to a detrimental impact on training and provision of the high-quality apprenticeships programme that is operating with a guaranteed 12-month-minimum job on qualifying.
There are unanswered questions regarding the potential for competition between City Building and GHA for future repair and maintenance contracts with housing associations, and there are risks to City Building’s cash flow. Repair and maintenance contracts are lucrative and generally have quick turnaround times.
There are also a number of unanswered questions about City Building’s supply chain. Would there be job losses throughout the supply chain and therefore a loss of money? What impact would that have on apprenticeships and other training programmes?
City Building has contributed £50 million to the city since 2006, yet it has been suggested that it is unprofitable and that it operates at a loss. What of the remainder of City Building? Will it all be transferred? Should it be sold?
When the Labour administration in Glasgow established arm’s-length external organisations, the SNP group in Glasgow City Council was opposed to it from the start. I was there and nobody was more vocal than me, but the one ALEO that I thought had a case to be made for it was City Building, and I think that time has proved me right.