To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-03068)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 7
- Kezia Dugdale Lab 6
- Tricia Marwick 3
- Dr Richard Simpson Lab 1
The record
17 contributionsEngagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Today marks one year since the First Minister took office. She has also been a senior Government minister for more than eight years, including five in charge of the national health service. The First Minister wants us to judge the Scottish National Party Government on its record, and today of all days we should do exactly that.
Everybody in this chamber knows somebody who has been affected by cancer. It is a horrible disease, and perhaps the most common perception is that money is no defence against it. New statistics published this week show that that is not the case. Can the First Minister tell me whether someone living in Scotland is more likely to get cancer if they are richer or poorer?
It has been a long-standing situation that people in our most deprived communities are more likely to die younger from illnesses such as cancer, from stroke and from heart disease. That did not start when the SNP came to Government; it has been true for generations.
What is equally true is that this Government has been working hard—as, I think that it is fair to say, previous Governments did—to close that gap, to see rates of cancer decrease and to see survival rates from cancer increase.
That is why we have policies not just about getting people access to the best cancer treatment. One of the things that we have done in the past year, since I have been First Minister, is to double the fund for new cancer medicines—a step in the right direction—but we have also put a great priority on innovative and ambitious public health measures: to improve people’s diets, to cut the incidence of alcohol misuse and to reduce smoking.
Those are the kinds of policy that, frankly, should not involve party politics. Every single member of this chamber should get behind those things so that far, far fewer people in all parts of our country die from cancer.
Nicola Sturgeon has been responsible for our NHS in one way or another for six out of the last eight years. The reality is that, in Scotland today, the likelihood of someone getting cancer too often depends on how much money they have. The new statistics show that people living in the poorest areas are 32 per cent more likely to have cancer than those from the wealthier areas, and they are 68 per cent more likely to die from it. That is just not right; this is 21st century Scotland, not the Victorian times.
I have never doubted the First Minister’s sincerity, but the job needs a bit more than that. The Government’s cancer strategy was due to be published at the start of this year, but it has been repeatedly delayed. Can the First Minister confirm when her Government’s cancer strategy will be published?
The cancer strategy will be published in the spring of next year. We are working with stakeholders across the NHS, including some of the best cancer clinicians in the world, who we are lucky to have here in Scotland, to make sure that we get that strategy right, such is the importance of the issue.
Kezia Dugdale said that the fact that people in our poorest communities are more likely to die from cancer is not right—I absolutely agree. It was not right when Labour was in office; it is not right now. That is why we are working so hard to reduce deaths from cancer. We saw figures published this week that show that, overall, cancer death rates have dropped by 11 per cent in the past 10 years. Overall, cancer mortality in 2014 was the lowest, and rates for breast, lung, stomach and colorectal cancer are dropping as well. Those are things that all of us should take great optimism from, but the job is not done.
That is why we are working to lower cancer waiting times. Interestingly, it was Labour that set some of the current cancer waiting times—they were never once met when Labour was in Government. We are working to reduce cancer waiting times, and we are working to make sure that we get more people into screening programmes. That is why we are investing £30 million in detect cancer early programmes, so that people come forward earlier when they have symptoms and they are diagnosed earlier. The earlier people are diagnosed, of course, the more chance they have of surviving.
I say to Kezia Dugdale in all seriousness that this is far too important for party political arguments. Let all of us unite to say that we want to see an end to the situation in which the people in our most deprived communities are more likely to die of cancer. I think that that is something worth uniting around.
There is no doubt that we welcome that progress, but the reality is that it is largely in the richer parts of Scotland.
That is why we need a cancer strategy. The English NHS has a widely recognised and welcome plan to fight the disease; we need the same here. In Scotland the system is failing those who are most in need. Some 66 per cent of eligible people in the wealthiest areas are taking up bowel cancer screening, but the rate is just 45 per cent in the poorest areas. The most recent figures show a decline in the number of women in poorer communities who get screened for breast cancer. Those lower rates of screening are a key reason why people from the poorest backgrounds are more likely to die from cancer.
Does the First Minister agree that without dramatic Government action we could be in danger of seeing cancer as a deprivation disease in Scotland?
I agree that serious Government action is needed to improve early diagnosis of cancer. That is important for anyone who has cancer, and given the statistics that Kezia Dugdale quoted it is even more important that we get people from our most deprived communities into a diagnosis as quickly as possible.
That is why this Government is investing £39 million in our detect cancer early programme, which has already resulted in a 4.7 per cent increase in early-stage diagnosis of cancer, alongside a 50 per cent increase in women consulting their general practitioner with breast symptoms and increased uptake of the national bowel screening programme. That is the kind of serious, concerted action that we need from Government.
Over the year that I have been First Minister, I have said on many occasions that, if any member has suggestions to make about things that they think this Government should be doing to further improve, I am happy to listen. However, in all of what I have just heard from Kezia Dugdale, I have heard not one specific suggestion about what she thinks this Government should do—
Nonsense!
Mr Simpson!
We will continue to do the work to get people diagnosed early, to encourage people to come forward, to ensure that we are giving people access to the best technologies and the best drugs, to ensure that we are lowering cancer waiting times and to ensure that we are doing all the things we need to do to improve the public health of people in Scotland in every single part of our country.
With respect, Presiding Officer, Dr Richard Simpson has been coming into this chamber for years to push this Government to be more ambitious when it comes to the cancer strategy.
We need an NHS that is fit for the future. That means an NHS that is ready to tackle the challenges of the 2040s, not the 1940s. We need bold action, but that is just not happening.
Let us look at the First Minister’s record. She has spent 16 years as a member of the Scottish Parliament, eight years as a minister, seven years as Deputy First Minister and five years in charge of our NHS, and this morning she had the cheek to say that she is only just getting started. [Interruption.]
Order.
Week after week, whatever the issue and whatever the failings of her Government, the First Minister always tells me about her opinion poll ratings. Clearly she thinks that that answers the question, but I think that it leads us to pose a question: given her opinion poll ratings, her majority and all her power, what exactly is she waiting for?
I am not sure that opinion polls are the strongest suit for a party that is now in a scrap with the Conservative Party for second place in Scotland. However, given that Kezia Dugdale raised the issue, I will say that opinion polls show that people trust the Scottish National Party more with the national health service than they trust the Labour Party or any other party in Scotland with the national health service.
We will continue to get on with the job—[Interruption.]
Order.
We have seen cancer death rates fall by 11 per cent. We have seen an increase in early-stage diagnosis of cancer, as I said. We are seeing an increase in the number of people who come forward for diagnosis by their GP and for screening. We are working hard to ensure that we have the best cancer centres—we have five state-of-the-art cancer centres in Scotland, and we are investing in state-of-the-art radiotherapy equipment in every single one of them.
We will continue, with the consent of the Scottish people, to get on with the job, and we will leave Labour to do what it has been doing for so many years now—carping on the sidelines and slowly but surely getting beaten in Scotland, not by the SNP but by the Tories.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 19 Nov 2015 →- Racial Discrimination Questions · 4
- Whitehill Incinerator (Planning) Questions · 6
- Gender Discrimination (Workplace) Questions · 7
- Fife College (Halbeath Campus) Questions · 5
- Tenant Farming Law Questions · 4
- Type 26 Frigates (Funding) Questions · 4
- Tenant Support (Lorne) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 17
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- HIV Testing First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Welfare Powers (Devolution) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- NHS 24 (Winter Resilience) First Minister’s Questions · 7
- National Third Sector GIRFEC Project Members’ business · 7
- Community Justice (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 41
- Community Justice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.