Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Human Papillomavirus Vaccine (Safety) (PE1574)

Tuesday 27 October 2015 Public Petitions Committee About 10:45–11:30 Petitions 59 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

59 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

The next petition is PE1574, by Freda Birrell on behalf of the UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters on human papillomavirus vaccine safety. Members have received briefings, and I welcome to the meeting Chic Brodie MSP, who has indicated an interest in this petition.

I welcome the petitioner, Freda Birrell. She was to be accompanied by Steve Hinks from AHVID, but as far as I understand it, he is unfortunately unwell and is not able to join Mrs Birrell this morning.

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

His daughter has had a relapse.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

I am sorry to hear that. Please pass on our regards.

I will hand over to you, Mrs Birrell. You have five minutes or so to introduce the subject, and then we will interrogate it a bit further.

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

Thank you. On the off-chance, convener, I have brought a one-page summary relating to Lucy Hinks, copies of which are available if members would like to take them and read them at their leisure.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Thank you. We will have a look at that.

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

I thank the committee for allowing me to provide additional information relating to my request for a round-table discussion to be held in Edinburgh between scientists and medical professionals from both sides of the HPV vaccine safety debate.

I speak today on behalf of not only the UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters, whose lives have been turned upside down after HPV vaccine administration, but each of the 2,019 people from 55 countries who have signed the petition because they are having similar experiences and support open scientific discussion. Our association, which was organised at the beginning of this year when it became apparent that we needed to co-ordinate everyone’s individual efforts as a group, represents families from Scotland, England, Wales and Northern Ireland and operates under the banner of the UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters.

As a group, we have been able to receive greater publicity, and increased awareness has caused our membership to grow by leaps and bounds. Our initial group of 60 members has expanded to 208 and rising. Despite the fact that Scotland accounts for only 8 per cent of the UK population, 15 per cent of the association’s members come from it. We do not know how many others are out there, but for now there appears to be no end in sight. A senior politician in Ireland, Paschal Mooney, recently made an impassioned plea to Irish Government officials regarding the Irish HPV vaccination programme, the lack of informed consent and the devastating effects on young girls around the country. Specifically, he mentioned Irish girls being admitted to psychiatric hospitals following HPV vaccinations.

Japan has rescinded the Government recommendations for HPV vaccines and has initiated studies to determine whether there is a causal relationship between HPV vaccines and adverse outcomes as well as a 21-year study to determine whether HPV vaccines have an impact on cervical cancer diagnosis rates. On 31 October, the national association of HPV-adverse sufferers in Denmark is hosting an HPV vaccine information symposium to bring families together with medical professionals, health authorities and legal professionals to explore treatment options and potential legal remedies. Denmark has recently made the decision to change from Gardasil to Cervarix as the HPV vaccine of choice. In the past week, at the urging of Liselott Blixt, a Danish politician with a Gardasil-injured daughter, the Danish Government has set aside 7 million krone to conduct an independent investigation into the HPV vaccine and its side effects.

Our association is in the process of compiling information for the European Medicines Agency’s consideration in its safety assessment of HPV vaccines. Of the 88 family reports analysed to date, 68 per cent reported that their daughters experienced health problems serious enough to interfere with their education; 24 per cent reported symptoms so severe that their daughters could no longer participate in educational activities; 70 per cent required help with daily care; and a full 91 per cent reported being told that their daughters’ medical conditions were psychological in origin.

On that last point, it is interesting to note that national health authorities in Denmark, Norway, Japan, France, Spain and many other countries have led doctors and other vaccine administrators to believe that any new medical conditions experienced after HPV vaccine administration are most likely psychosomatic. Consequently, as many UK families have experienced, the average medical health professional faced with a patient exhibiting symptoms that they have never seen before and which do not fit neatly into any current diagnostic criteria naturally assumes that they are psychological problems.

I put forward the following facts for the committee’s consideration. According to the insert in the package for Merck’s Gardasil 9, which is the new vaccine that is coming in, 3.3 per cent of participants who were given Gardasil, which was used as the control during the most recent clinical trials, experienced new medical conditions potentially indicative of auto-immune disorders. That works out at 3,300 per 100,000 recipients. According to a press release from Sanofi Pasteur MSD dated 17 June 2015, 183 million doses of Gardasil have been distributed worldwide. If we use Merck’s own clinical trial percentage, we see that there could be as many as 6,000,039 girls around the world suffering autoimmune conditions, which could very well influence their health for the rest of their lives.

According to the World Cancer Research Foundation, 528,000 cases of cervical cancer were diagnosed worldwide in 2012. Is this worth the risk? I am very much aware that HPV vaccines are controversial and that this information puts Scotland at a crossroads with a very difficult decision to make. Do we accept what the manufacturer and its list of experts are saying and assume that HPV vaccines are safe and effective and that there just happens to be an epidemic of psychosomatic disorders spreading around the world, affecting certain young people who have one thing in common: they were injected with the HPV vaccine? Do we listen to experts from both sides, try to discover exactly what the situation is and make every effort we can to get the problem solved? Do we sweep all these families under the proverbial psychological disorder carpet and ignore their misery, or do we treat them with the dignity and respect that they deserve by using every means at our disposal to identify those at risk of serious adverse reactions and to develop successful treatment protocols for those who are already suffering?

Please demonstrate to the world that Scotland is still a country that does not ignore the suffering of innocents, and show the world Scotland is not afraid to hold open and honest scientific discussions, no matter how controversial the subject might be.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Thank you very much. Chic, do you want to come in at this point?

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Thank you, convener. In the past two-and-a-half years since I initially met Freda Birrell and others who are involved, I have done some personal research on this matter, and I ask the committee to ask the appropriate questions, given the ramifications that it has beyond Scotland. Clearly there is an issue here that needs to be resolved and, on that basis, I ask the committee to interrogate the petition thoroughly but, I hope, decide on the appropriate recommendation to allow us to take a further step on this journey.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Thanks very much.

I want to ask a direct question, Mrs Birrell. Who should call the round-table together? Whose responsibility should it be to invite people to sit around that table?

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

I would like to think that, after listening to what I have said and perhaps asking many more questions and getting more evidence, the committee will be influenced enough to conclude that this is a very serious problem. It is neither a Scottish problem nor an English problem; it is a worldwide problem, and it is happening in those countries where the vaccines are being administered. We certainly have many medical professionals and scientists who would be willing to come and debate with scientists and medical professionals from the pharmaceutical companies, Government or wherever, and we also have witnesses who would be able to say, “This is what has happened to our children.”

In the end, these girls need to be healed. After all, they are still very ill. Given that these things have been happening since 2008 or 2009, something has to be done to get someone to look at and find out what has happened, why these girls are so ill and why they have had such a serious adverse reaction to either Gardasil or Cervarix. The two sides need to get together, sit down and say genuinely, openly and honestly, “These children need help—let’s look at this seriously.” We need to try to find a way forward, come to some solution to get these girls healed and discuss the matter in an open debate.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

When I had the privilege of being a member of this committee, we dealt more widely with the issue of mesh implants. After what Freda Birrell has said, it might behove the Health and Sport Committee to encourage the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing to embrace the notion that we in Scotland can lead in this discussion and facilitate such a gathering of experts.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Good morning, Mrs Birrell. The committee quite recently considered a petition from Jamie Rae on behalf of the Throat Cancer Foundation that called on the Scottish Government to extend the HPV immunisation programme to include boys in Scotland. Your petition deals specifically with girls, but are you aware of specific research on adverse outcomes in countries where boys have been routinely included in an HPV immunisation programme?

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

In Australia and America, boys are included on the programme. I am not quite sure, but there is a possibility of it happening in New Zealand, and I am aware that the proposal has been discussed here in Scotland as well as down south. Boys, too, have become sick or have died following HPV vaccination. I cannot say whether the vaccination caused their death, but they died suddenly shortly afterwards. Boys are being vaccinated overseas and it is causing problems for them just as it is for girls. However, there are not as many boys getting vaccinated overseas as there are girls.

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

Yes. I know of one particular family in America whose twin son and daughter were vaccinated at the same time. Both of them were taken seriously ill and developed seizures. I know that family personally and I could talk about what happened if you wished, but there are other families where boys have been harmed.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

Good morning. Mrs Birrell and I have met on a number of occasions over the years, and I applaud her for the focus that she has brought to this issue.

It is fair to say that, over that period, you have through your own perseverance had a very considerable opportunity to meet politicians and ministers in the UK Department of Health, in Scotland and, indeed, internationally. You have been very persistent in the case that you have made, and it is not one that has not been brought to the attention of politicians along that path. Ultimately, however, ministers have responded that they do not take political decisions on these issues; instead, their decisions are based on the recommendations of the chief medical officer and the scientists who advise the Government on the value and merits of the various vaccinations programmes that are employed.

Cervical cancer has been one of the most common killers of young women under the age of 35 in the UK. According to the briefing that we have received, mortality rates have declined some 44 per cent, coincident with the vaccine having been introduced, which is a very considerable reduction. Interruption. Well, from the figures that I have, it looks as if there has been a significant reduction in the number of women dying of cervical cancer, and it seems to coincide with the period that the vaccine has been there. I imagine that that is what is informing the advice that Government ministers are considering.

11:15

You ask that a round-table discussion be convened between those who are knowingly opposed to the vaccine and those who are knowingly for it, whose debate, I imagine, is already informing the decision that ministers will ultimately take. I want to understand the purpose of the round-table discussion that you would like to see convened. What do you imagine it would contribute to ministers’ understanding that has not already—given the considerable representations that have been made and the concerns that have been expressed—been factored into the thinking that has led them to continue to recommend that the vaccine be offered?

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

In February 2014, Japan held a round-table discussion over two-and-a-half days. There was a symposium to begin with and then scientists and doctors from both sides met in the Japanese Parliament and had an open, honest debate on the subject. Our Dr Lee, who I know has sent in representations on my behalf, was there. At that time, Japan was seeing what was happening to young Japanese girls as psychosomatic. That word was used.

Dr Lee, who has been a pathologist for more than 50 years, had carried out an analysis of the post-mortem results for a young New Zealand girl who died six months after she was last vaccinated, and what he discovered in her blood and spleen tissues was the HPV DNA. He said, “You are all saying that this is psychosomatic. Will all of you who regard these results as being psychosomatic put up your hands?” Not one hand could go up.

In Japan, the politicians who were for the vaccine and those who were very concerned about it discussed it at length, and they put the young Japanese girls first. Scientific papers have come out on what they believe to be a neurological condition that has come from the vaccine, and they have set up the 21-year study. That is their way of trying to find out the truth. That is what came from Tokyo.

In France the following May, there was a similar open discussion, and the people there concentrated a lot on aluminium. There is a difference between aluminium being eaten, which can happen through the use of pots and through the environment, and aluminium being injected into the body. Professor Chris Exley, who has also given me support, is the top expert on aluminium in the United Kingdom. In France, they discussed having vaccines that contain no aluminium.

Something has to happen. We now have an Irish politician who is very concerned. He has met Irish families and heard their stories, and he has spoken out and said that something has to be done. The families want to meet the Irish health minister—that is their request.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

Sorry, but may I interrupt? I think that I get the drift. Presumably, however, the fact that those discussions have taken place in those other legislatures will be part of the review that the Scottish Government will undertake in relation to the recommendations to ministers.

It seems to me that you would hope that the outcome of a round-table discussion would be that a compelling argument would arise from it for a change of policy in Scotland. If such a round-table discussion took place and the outcome was contrary to that, would you be content with that decision?

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

I would not be happy if there was no progress. The reason why I say that is that somebody has to realise that young girls worldwide—in Scotland as well—are ill, and they became ill following the vaccine. Prior to vaccination, their medical records were perfect, or almost perfect. They were normal young girls with no serious medical issues, and certainly no psychological issues. That does not come in straight away; there is a progression to it. I would be disappointed if nobody was asking, “What has happened to these girls?” or “What has happened to the boys overseas who are becoming sick?”

If I may quote,

“Professor Yehuda Schoenfeld, director of the Zabludowicz Centre for autoimmune diseases and international specialist on immunity, pointed out that certain individuals have a genetic predisposition to much greater and more serious reaction to immune system stimulation in the form of aluminium salt-containing vaccines.”

He also informed the meeting that he was speaking to that we already have

“genetic ‘tests’ which can determine, before any vaccine is administered, whether an individual’s genetic makeup is such that he may be susceptible in the long term to a potentially very serious auto-immune reaction.”

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I understand the perseverance with which you have approached the issue, Ms Birrell. You are convinced, from the body of evidence to which you have been exposed or which you have been involved in unearthing, that the vaccine is unsafe and that there should be a change of policy in Scotland as to its application. Essentially, that is what you want. You see a round-table discussion as a means to that end, but that is what you want to get to. Is that correct?

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

Yes.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

So the issue at hand is really the Scottish Government’s attitude to the vaccine.

David Birrell
link

The real issue is to get these girls properly treated.

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

Yes—I have said that. As David says, my main issue is to get these girls properly treated. One of the things that I and many of my colleagues have discovered is that girls who are very active and are into sports, dance and so on seem to be the ones who get hit very hard. I am not saying that that is the case 100 per cent, but it is true of a good 90 per cent, and the same with boys.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

As I recall, you had the father of one of these girls present in the Parliament at a cross-party round-table discussion that took place.

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

That is correct.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

So that is the secondary thing. Your concern is the attitude to the vaccine and also the appropriate treatment of those people who have been adversely affected by it.

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

It is, and it is to ask why this is happening. It may not be happening to all, but why is this happening to a good portion of the young people in this country? Unfortunately, the medical professionals do not seem to recognise what is happening, what the symptoms are or what is being developed, and that is when they go down the road of saying that it is a psychological problem.

Many of the young people are eventually diagnosed with medical conditions such as postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome. The EMA is looking at that. These young girls may originally be diagnosed with chronic fatigue syndrome and then, because of their mother’s perseverance, they will carry on down the road until they find out about POTS. They go and get a tilt table test and they get an official diagnosis.

The doctor might say to the young person and the family, “It’s all in your daughter’s head.” Once they have used that expression, the damage has been done to that young person. She believes that her doctor knows more than she does, so is the doctor right? They then find out that she does have a medical condition.

May I pick up on one little point? I might have picked this up incorrectly, but I think that you commented that the vaccine has prevented a number of cases of cervical cancer since its introduction.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

No. I said that, coincident with the time since the vaccine was introduced, there has been a fall in the number of people who have cervical cancer. I was not necessarily attributing that to the vaccine.

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

Right. Our young girls were vaccinated at 12, and in Scotland papillomavirus screening is done from the age of 20, so I do not think that many of these young girls will have gone to be screened to see whether the vaccine has prevented a problem. In America, which started earlier than us in 2006, Gardasil-vaccinated girls are now displaying HPV infection or cervical dysplasia or cervical cancer. That comes through the American vaccine adverse event reporting system, which is similar to our Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency.

David Birrell
link

May I add some figures to the percentages that were mentioned, to make sense of the figures? According to Cancer Research UK, about three deaths per 100,000 are due to cervical cancer and there are about eight or nine new cases of cervical cancer a year. In 1970, the rate of deaths due to cervical cancer was about eight per 100,000, but that dropped before the programme started to just under three per 100,000.

If we are talking about 44 per cent of three, we are talking about one per 100,000, yet if we look at the data from the pharmaceuticals on the serious adverse events, they quote 2.5 per cent, or 2,500 serious adverse events per 100,000. Those are the figures that we are talking about. We know that the girls are there, but we are just starting to find them.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Good morning, Ms Birrell. Like Jackson Carlaw, I want to get to the point of the petition that you have submitted to us. You are asking the Scottish Government to convene a round-table discussion between those who are in favour of continuing with the vaccination and those who are opposed to it or have reservations about it. Will you clarify exactly what you are looking for? Are you looking for the proper support to be put in place for those who have suffered an adverse effect from the vaccination or for a moratorium or a ban on the HPV vaccine programme?

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

I have never asked, to the best of my knowledge, for a ban on the HPV vaccines. I know that that would be a huge thing. I am asking, if possible, for a moratorium so that a proper investigation can take place to determine why certain young people are having serious adverse reactions that are lasting for many years. We are not talking about something that is there for a month or six weeks and then goes away. That is the opposite of what the MHRA says, which is usually that the side effects do not last long but go away in a matter of weeks. That is not the case.

I know every single one of the families in the UK association. I have spoken and written to them, and we have been on the telephone or Skype or whatever, so I know their background. I know exactly what is going on and what has happened to them. The one thing that I always say to them, because MPs are not the first place that they would naturally go to, is, “Please go and discuss what’s happening in your house with your member of Parliament, because that’s the only way to raise awareness.”

11:30

Somebody somewhere has to say, “This is not right.” Somebody has to ask why all these young people are becoming sick and point out that the thing that links them together is the HPV vaccine. Somebody has to ask why this is happening to these young people. They cannot be ignored and swept under the carpet. I have heard many times that it is just a coincidence. Well, that word means “by chance” but, when we have thousands of cases around the world, that is not by chance. There is something unusual and something not good happening, which is why I submitted the petition. I have worked on the issue since 2008, but I felt that this is the time to raise the petition, as Denmark is looking seriously at the issue and is putting money into investigating it and having an independent study.

I urge the committee to make contact with the Danish politician—I have her details—and the Irish senator who I have mentioned. I urge you to speak with others who are at your level and on your wavelength and ask them what they think. I urge you to find out the facts and information from others, and not just from me, about what is happening in Ireland, Denmark, Colombia and many other countries. I believe that the vaccine has harmed these girls, and boys overseas. I have been involved for too long now not to realise that that is what is happening. Something is not right and, I hope, somebody has to recognise that.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Thank you for your response. You mentioned the MHRA, and my colleague Mr Brodie raised the issue of mesh implants. The committee certainly has experience of dealing with the MHRA decision-making process in allowing things to go forward.

Are you aware of any research that has been carried out by the chief medical officer or any Government department regarding the effects of the vaccine on the females who receive it? From what I am picking up from you, we know that some adverse effects have occurred but, apart from the reporting mechanisms that are in place at present, are you aware of any follow-up research being carried out to determine the long-term impact? You said that we do not know how long term the impact may be on females who have received the vaccination. Are you aware of any follow-through research being done in the UK?

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

Dr Lee discovered the contamination in the Gardasil vaccine, and work was done by Dr Lucija Tomljenovic from the University of British Columbia in Canada. She analysed brain samples of three young girls who died following HPV vaccination with Gardasil and discovered that the antigen 16, which is part of Gardasil, had crossed the blood-brain barrier. There is scientific evidence of that. I believe that it was sent to the Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation, the MHRA and the Government departments down south, but they all just dismissed it. We asked for specific scientific articles and evidence from the pharmaceutical company Merck, the Department of Health or anyone who could show that what we were saying on, for example, the contamination in the Gardasil vaccine, was incorrect.

To begin with, when the information came out, the pharmaceuticals and the Department of Health always said that there was no virus in the vaccine but, when we discovered that there was contamination, they accepted that—they did not deny it. Then we asked them for the evidence that they had to show that it will not harm any of the girls. We were talking about a serious contamination in the Gardasil vaccine, and GlaxoSmithKline has now had to say that there is the possibility of insect residue in the Cervarix vaccine. We have asked for the evidence that proves that that will not harm any of the girls and we have never got it. We never ever get any science. We provide science all the time from respected scientists and professionals, but we never get any science back.

Hanzala Malik Lab Glasgow
link

You clearly have a strong and passionate view on the issue. I am surprised about the NHS’s position on the issue. I would have thought that chief executives in the NHS are looking to save money and that, if there was any danger or if any vaccination was harmful, they would be keen to take it off the list rather than keep it on that list. Perhaps we could ask the chief executives in the various regions in Scotland to advise us on what action, if any, they have taken to look into the matter. That would help us to determine why they are continuing to use the vaccination given the evidence that has been provided. We should also ask whether they have any evidence to prove that in fact the vaccination is safe. Unless we get professionals giving us advice, it will be difficult for us as laypeople to come to a decision.

That is important because, although you have collected evidence internationally, we have professionals in the UK who could look into the matter for us. It might be quicker for them to come back to us with the relevant evidence and, of course, it would be strongly backed by professionals. It would be helpful to have that evidence before we go into a round-table discussion. Before we take the issue any further, it is important to get the NHS to clarify its position on the evidence that you have collated and any evidence that it has that perhaps counterbalances that.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

As usual, Mr Wilson asks a very pertinent question on the analysis. I think that Freda Birrell has made it clear that what is being sought is not a moratorium on the drugs. We can write to the experts all day long and, at the end of the day, they may or may not have a view; certainly, the drug companies that are involved will have a view. The issue is that one death or one serious illness is one too many. We should look at the process of prescribing through which girls and boys who apparently have had no major illness or who have nothing wrong with them are then injected. We need to know what check takes place before that happens and what the medical implications are. Therefore, we need to create a forum by which we can at least have a meaningful look at the processes, the prescriptive method of inoculation injection and indeed the consequences. Drawing on international information is essential. As I say, one death or one serious illness is one too many.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

The European Medicines Agency is carrying out a review of the HPV vaccine, which started in July this year and will report back to the European Commission. The agency’s decisions will be legally binding on all European member states. Is it not better to wait for the EMA’s findings on the safety of the vaccine?

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

A good proportion of the members of the committee that is advising the EMA are very pro-vaccine—it is not an independent group. One of them is Professor Pollard, who is connected with the Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation. Our association has been getting families to complete questionnaires, and we have been sending that information to the EMA, but what is disturbing—I spoke to my MEP about this because he is on the European Parliament’s health committee—is that, if the review is open, honest and genuine, we should not be hearing from the EMA or from the Department of Health at Westminster that the vaccine is safe and effective. It was Denmark that originally brought the issue to the attention of the EMA. If the EMA is looking at individual illnesses that are affecting girls, it should be taking it from the base and saying zero. It should look at the issue objectively and consider what it gets from Spain, Denmark and other countries in Europe, including the United Kingdom, and then assess whether there are serious side effects following vaccination.

However, that is not what we are hearing—we are hearing the opposite. Sadly, we are hearing from the minister at Westminster that the vaccine is safe and effective and that they do not see that there will be any problem. We should not have to listen to that when we are genuinely trying to help the EMA to come to a resolution. David Torrance is right that, whatever the EMA comes up with, that will be it—it will be law. However, it is not fair on those who are trying their best to help the EMA when they hear such comments. That is wrong and it should be stopped. The people involved should say, “We’re going to do this properly and professionally and, if there’s something wrong, let’s look at it.” They should not say, “This vaccine is okay.”

There possibly will not be any serious issues with the two health conditions that are being investigated, but more than two need to be investigated. There are many auto-immune disorders that young girls suddenly develop and other health conditions. That is my greatest worry. David Torrance is correct that the EMA’s answer will be definitive, but is it right for it to express an opposite view and not to start from the status quo and look at the issue objectively and honestly? I am not sure that it is doing that, although I would like to think that it is.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

The committee will now discuss what we do with the petition.

I have to be honest and say that I am genuinely concerned about whether there is any merit in doing what the petition asks for. It is very specific in asking for a round-table discussion, but I am puzzled as to what that would achieve. The petitioner has raised a lot of very important issues and I am sure that they are being discussed in the scientific and medical establishments, but I do not know how they would be resolved by a round-table discussion.

I have spoken to clinicians and experts in the field of cancer and the majority of them argue strongly that screening for breast cancer, prostate cancer or bowel cancer is effective and that there is merit and value in that but, equally, I have spoken to clinicians who do not believe that that makes an impact on the treatment of the conditions. If we got people from both sides of that argument round a table, we could pretty much establish before we went in what the outcome would be: they would each come out saying, “We think it’s good,” or, “We think it’s bad.”

I am not sure how we can take forward the petition on the basis that all that we are asking for is a round-table discussion, because I do not know that that would achieve anything. At the same time, I am really concerned by the evidence that you have produced about the impact on girls and women and the fact that there is not a consensus on whether there is a causal link with certain medical conditions. Those things have to be investigated. However, that is not what the petition asks for, so I am in a bind as to what we do with it.

Do members have any considerations on how we can take this forward?

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

We should certainly ask the Scottish Government about its attitude to the petition. However, given that the issues raised by the petition have come before ministers and that they will have responded previously, it might be interesting to explore some of the evidentiary issues that were raised in any on-going review that the Scottish—Interruption.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

The fire alarm that we are hearing is not a test.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

It says that we have to stay where we are. Do I carry on trying to speak?

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

It has stopped. We have to stay where we are, so I will take that as licence to finish my point.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

I think so. We should stay here until we hear otherwise.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I reassure people in the gallery that this happens from time to time, so they should not panic.

On the issue of whether there has been any on-going review by the Scottish Government—Interruption.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

I will suspend for a couple of minutes until the notifications stop.

11:46 Meeting suspended.

11:50 On resuming—

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

I am assured that we can go ahead without further interruption, unless the security staff need to evacuate us. We should not be interrupted by an announcement, though. We go back to you, Jackson.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

Thank you, convener. I am clearly a candidate for North Korean brainwashing. All I can think at the moment is, “Attention, please. Attention, please. A fire has been reported in the building. Please stay where you are.”

Given that these issues have been raised with the Scottish Government before, it would be a bit pointless simply to write to the Government asking it about its attitude to the issue. We know that it will say that it acts on the advice of the chief medical officer and the best scientific evidence. It would be better, in exploring the issues with the Scottish Government, to try to tease out whether any review is being conducted in Scotland into the implications and experience since the vaccine was introduced. We could also ask whether the Scottish Government has received any briefing on the more recent experience that we were advised of in Ireland, Denmark, Japan and France.

Finally, we could ask to what extent the Government acts on the advice of the MHRA. As Mr Wilson said, we have had cause to be underwhelmed by that advice on a previous occasion. Indeed, the cabinet secretary herself, in the evidence session that we had when that was raised, expressed concerns about the weight that had been placed on that particular study. Until we examined the study in some detail and discovered that it was perhaps not all that it had purported to be, it had seemed to carry the day.

Those things might bring out more of the issue. I suspect, a bit like you, convener, that enthusiasm for the round-table discussion will be lacking unless a clear outcome is being sought as a consequence. Interruption.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

It is not quite North Korean brainwashing but, in Jackson Carlaw’s case, it is something that may have to be investigated.

The Scottish Parliament information centre briefing refers to the Countess of Mar’s question in the House of Lords and the response from Lord Prior of Brampton. The response contains some details of the reporting mechanism that has been taking place, which claims to be UK-wide. If we are writing to the Scottish Government, I suggest that we try to get some Scottish figures for the reporting of any adverse effects. Questions need to be raised about the figures that we have in front of us and it would be useful to get some Scottish figures.

It would also be useful to find out—given our experience in the mesh implant debate and petition that we have had before us—what advice is currently given to general practitioners about any mechanism for the reporting of adverse effects from the vaccine. One of the things that were highlighted with mesh implants is that many GPs did not know how to report or who to report to about adverse effects of the operations and procedures that were carried out.

It would also be useful to find out from the Scottish Government whether any guidance is currently provided to GPs to help them to identify what may be an adverse event arising from the HPV vaccine, because that would indicate whether there is underreporting of adverse events. It would be useful to try to get as true a figure as possible of the number of adverse events as a result of the HPV vaccine.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

That all sounds very sensible. There are a few areas that we want to investigate.

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

Mr Wilson’s point is 100 per cent correct. I always say to the families who we find now, “Have you reported through the yellow card system?” That is the system that goes direct to the MHRA, which then divides it into Ireland, Scotland, England and Wales. Very few have reported their adverse reactions to the MHRA. Not enough education is being given at the point of contact; the school nurse may not be giving the girls any information or saying, “If you feel unwell, make sure mum gets in touch.” They expect them to have seen the information that is sent out at the time of consent, which is very little. That information says that the side effects are mild. What the child or the mother does not get at that time is the patient information leaflet, which describes more serious adverse reactions, such as Guillain-Barré syndrome. That is identified on the Gardasil.

The convener mentioned the round-table discussion and someone mentioned the science. I would like to have the scientists at the round-table discussion because the committee can ask them to prove that what we are saying is not correct, for example the contamination, or the possibility that the Cervarix vaccine contains insect DNA. Where is the science from GlaxoSmithKline that shows that there is no harm to the child? DNA, no matter how miniscule, is going into the body. We asked for a round-table discussion so that such questions could be asked openly and the witnesses could be asked for that science. They will ignore us, but they would not ignore you.

On the issue of the yellow card, you are right—there is a huge rate of underreporting.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

As you have heard, we have agreed that we will write to the Scottish Government to ask for its views on holding such a round-table discussion.

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

Thank you.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Once we have received responses from the Government and others who we have agreed to contact, we will be in touch with you and take the petition forward from that point. Thank you for giving us evidence this morning.

Freda Birrell UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters
link

Thank you.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Thank you for allowing me to participate, convener.

11:57 Meeting suspended.

11:59 On resuming—

  1. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 66
  2. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 59
  3. 11:30 New Petitions Petitions · 40
  4. 12:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  5. 12:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  6. 12:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 12
  7. 12:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  8. 12:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.