I welcome the opportunity to have this debate and I thank the members from across the chamber who have supported the motion and have stayed behind this evening to participate in or to listen to the debate.
It would be useful to set out why I became interested in the issue. In January this year, I was contacted by a worried parent, Mr McLevy, whose son Aiden suffers from Down’s syndrome. I had the pleasure of meeting Aiden and Mr McLevy in my office. Aiden is an energetic child and is full of enthusiasm. He might have done a bit of damage to the office that day, but he is forgiven. They were there on a serious matter, which was that Aiden’s blue badge, which allowed his parents to park easily and conveniently, has been withdrawn, which means that they have to park some distance away from places such as the local supermarket, the doctor’s office and the family centre. As a consequence—as we all realise—they have to struggle with the day-to-day activities that most of us take for granted.
Due to Aiden’s condition, he has a lack of safety awareness and can be unpredictable in a way that can pose a danger to himself in a busy car park, and to his parents, who have to chase after him. He also has a lack of co-ordination and can trip easily. As a result, getting from the car to the entrance of a venue can be a daunting experience for his parents.
Aiden had his badge taken away because he does not meet the new strict criteria for the scheme. First, Aiden does not receive the higher mobility rate of disability living allowance, which means he does not automatically qualify when he applies to the local authority. If a young person such as Aiden does not receive the higher mobility rate of DLA, the local authority will then conduct an assessment. However, under the new criteria, if it is to issue a blue badge, the local authority must be satisfied that the applicant is
“unable to walk or virtually unable to walk”.
It is clear from meeting and speaking to Mr McLevy that, although Aiden did not meet that criterion, having a blue badge was essential to allowing his family to go about the day-to-day activities that most of us, as I said, take for granted.
This is not an issue that affects only the McLevys in Greenock. Down’s Syndrome Scotland has informed me that it has been contacted by a number of worried parents whose children’s applications for blue badges have been rejected. It is also impacting on parents with children who have autism who, due to their condition, can be prone to running off or who have learning difficulties that make it difficult for them to appreciate danger. I will read out an extract from a submission that was made by a concerned parent to Transport Scotland’s consultation on extending the blue badge to people with mental health conditions, which was launched in September 2013.
She said:
“my son refuses to walk at any time; unpredictably he also throws tantrums if we are in a strange place with loud noise. We live in an extremely busy place and there is never any parking at the Doctor’s or at the shops. My son has irrational fears; he does not speak, so we cannot calm him by talking things through. He literally needs to be handled very physically to stop him either running away into the road or refusing to walk at all.”
I hope that those case examples convey the difference that having a blue badge would make to the lives of those families, and how difficult their lives are made without them.
As I mentioned, Transport Scotland launched a consultation two years ago to gauge views on whether the blue badge criteria should be extended to include people who have, as a result of a diagnosed mental condition, little or no awareness of traffic or its danger, and are likely to compromise their safety or the safety of others as a result. The analysis of the results was published a full year later in December 2014. There was overwhelming support for such an extension by the 30 groups, individuals and organisations that submitted their views to the consultation. They included Renfrewshire Council, Orkney Council, the National Autistic Society Scotland and Advocacy Western Isles. The list is on the public record.
I understand that the Scottish Government has this month set up a working group to consider whether the blue badge scheme should be extended. We very much welcome that development. However, we cannot ignore the fact that it has been nearly two years since the call for evidence and the consultation began. The time to act is now.
Wales, of course, has led the way on the issue. In December last year, it extended eligibility so that people who, as a result of mental disorder, are unable to follow the route of a familiar journey without the assistance of another person, will automatically receive a blue badge.
As Down’s Syndrome Scotland has said, the longer it takes to address the issue, the more families will struggle to cope with everyday activities. The issue is significantly affecting the quality of life of children and adults with Down’s syndrome and autism throughout the country, including young Aiden, who has gone nearly 10 months without his blue badge.
I hope that the Scottish Government’s working group will agree to a change in the eligibility criteria and to implementing that change as quickly as is realistically possible so that families, such as the McLevys, can go about their everyday lives more easily. I look forward to hearing what the minister has to say on the matter. I hope that he will agree that progress should be made quickly.
17:12