I, too, thank Mike MacKenzie for bringing this significant debate to the chamber today, and for the comprehensive briefing that he and his office provided. I recognise the contribution of the Scottish community energy coalition in community energy fortnight 2015.
The development of community energy is a climate-justice issue, as Alison Johnstone said, not only globally in the lead-up to the Paris summit but here in Scotland itself, as I have stressed on a number of occasions.
From rural to urban areas, there are many different models for community energy to enable power and warm homes for our people.
The Friends of the Earth briefing, “Community Power—building on success” draws attention to the
“recent European Energy Package which talks about putting citizens at the heart of the energy transition.”
As a member of the Scottish Parliament’s Co-operative group of MSPs I want to start by highlighting the value of co-operative models in this context. Energy4All, one of the coalition members, has been a key player in this regard. In my region, the Spirit of Lanarkshire Wind Energy Co-operative is now fully up and running. I was at its launch with the former MP Tom Greatrex, who was also supportive of it. Having raised £2.7 million in 2013, both its developments—Nutberry near Coalburn and West Browncastle near Strathaven—are now fully on stream. Despite relatively poor wind speeds in some cases and some technical issues, the 906 members of the co-operative have just enjoyed a return of 7.63 per cent for the period up to March 2015. The board of the co-op is now looking for ways to use some of the profits to support local communities in the coming years.
In an urban context, the Edinburgh Community Solar Co-operative launch will take place at the end of this month. In commending the co-operative model, I wish that group well, too.
Some of the co-operative models are for part of a larger multinational wind farm development and others are working in their communities in their own right.
I want to take a step back and look at the potential of the Land Reform (Scotland) Bill in relation to community energy. In the past, I have visited Dumfries house, which along with Douglas & Angus Estates, and a number of estates throughout Scotland, has installed biomass boilers, from which tenants get benefit. In its submission to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee, the Druidaig estate points out that “I am about to sell”—I am so sorry. If only it said that. It says:
“I am about to let three areas of ground to a company who plan to install mini hydro schemes to generate electricity. This will not just benefit us at Druidaig Lodge but the residents of Letterfearn as well.
My view of the proposed Land Reform Bill is that it will be of no advantage to Scotland to remove certain land from Landlords for it to be managed by the local community.”
NHS Health Scotland sets out a different view in its 2012-17 corporate strategy, “A Fairer Healthier Scotland”, which says:
“Our vision is a Scotland in which all of our people and communities have a fairer share of the opportunities, resources and confidence to live longer, healthier lives.”
In its submission to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee, it said that
“several case studies, where Scottish land has transferred to community ownership, have highlighted a number of potential benefits. For example, community ownership of land in rural areas has enabled investment in local resources”
such as
“social housing and renewable energy schemes, which in turn have helped to increase population and school numbers.”
I add that such things also bring local jobs.
Part 5 of the Land Reform (Scotland) Bill sets out the right to buy land to further sustainable development. I am clear that that should include looking favourably on community purchase of land for community energy use. The Scottish community energy coalition believes that community energy can and should, among other things,
“Encourage people to act cooperatively to create sustainable communities and give everyone an equal opportunity to own and control shared assets democratically.”
I hope that the Land Reform (Scotland) Bill will take that vision into account.