To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02936)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 9
- Kezia Dugdale Lab 6
- Tricia Marwick 5
- Dr Richard Simpson Lab 1
- Paul Martin Lab 1
The record
22 contributionsEngagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
On Tuesday, something very unusual happened in this Parliament: the Scottish National Party lost a vote
Every year, more than 20,000 children in Scotland have to deal with a parent going to prison. We do not know exactly how many, because we do not bother to count them. Mary Fee, supported by Barnardo’s, the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children and Families Outside, amended the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill to put that right. Those charities know that, if we can find those children, we can support them and help them to achieve their potential rather than any predetermined destiny.
The amendment was agreed to in the committee against the will of the First Minister’s MSPs. Of course, she can use the full force of her majority to remove that amendment—that progress—at stage 3. Will she respect the committee and promise not to do that?
I assure the Parliament that we will give full consideration to the amendment that was agreed to, and we will consider whether it best meets our objective of helping the children of those who are sent to prison.
I hope that Kezia Dugdale will recognise the sincerity and determination of the Government to ensure that we are not sending people to prison who do not need to be in prison. I also hope that she will acknowledge the change of direction that was instituted by Michael Matheson around the plans for a women’s prison, because we recognise that having women in particular in prison affects children. All of us want to make sure that we are identifying, and ensuring support for, all children whose mothers or fathers have to serve prison sentences.
As, I hope, the Parliament would expect us to do, we will give full consideration to that amendment, and to other amendments that have been discussed in relation to the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill.
The First Minister and I both talk a lot about closing the attainment gap. The children who are affected by parental imprisonment are about as far on the wrong side of that gap as it is possible to be. They are three times more likely than average to have severe mental health problems, and the statistics tell us that, without help and support, more than 50 per cent of them will end up in jail.
The First Minister’s Minister for Children and Young People, Aileen Campbell, knows what a difference the arrangement that the amendment proposes would make. She herself proposed such an arrangement in an amendment when she was a backbencher in the previous session of Parliament.
I might be wrong, but I do not think that the plight of these children has ever been raised at First Minister’s question time before. On that basis, I will give the First Minister another chance to do the right thing. Will she instruct her MSPs to support Mary Fee’s amendment to the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill?
I am going to continue to do what I think is the right thing to do. Having had a vote two days ago in Parliament on a particular amendment, the right thing to do is for the Government to reflect on its position in light of that vote. The Government would not be doing the right thing if it did not seriously reflect on that position in light of the vote in committee. However, we also have to reflect on the view of Elish Angiolini, which I will have to paraphrase because I do not have the document before me. The issue that we are discussing is one that she considered when she carried out her considerable and respected work in this area. I think that she came to the conclusion that the social work assessment process that was already in place was right and adequate.
That is the basis on which the Government has taken the position that it has taken. However, a committee has taken another position. In the normal course of things, before we get to the next stage in the passage of the legislation, we will consider our position. Either we will come to Parliament and accept the amendment that has been agreed to at stage 2, or we will come to Parliament and give careful reasons why we consider that it would not be the right thing for that amendment to stand. That is the responsible and rational way for any Government to proceed in the wake of such a vote.
I am happy to discuss the matter with Kezia Dugdale and any other member of the Parliament who is interested in the issue so that, collectively, we can come to the right decision, as a Parliament, about how we can best support children and young people whose parents serve prison sentences. That is the right way to go about it.
It is clear that the right thing to do would be to support the amendment.
The First Minister just got an answer from her justice secretary about social work assessments. Let me tell her about social work assessments. There is no mandatory requirement to fill them in. In fact, over the past year, the number of assessment forms that have been filled in has fallen. The reality of the situation is that those assessments are about the parents, not the kids. This is about giving those kids a chance.
If the First Minister will not do anything for children who are affected by a parent being in prison—[Interruption.]
Order.
I will ask her about children whose lives are blighted by homelessness. Yesterday, we debated the housing crisis. Homelessness is at the extreme end of that, and the children of homeless families are the most vulnerable. Can the First Minister tell the chamber how many children in Scotland are sleeping in temporary accommodation and whether the number is going up or down?
This Government—supported, I think, by members across the Parliament—has done a great deal to tackle temporary accommodation for those who are homeless.
So is it going down?
Order.
We are also on track to meet our target for building new homes in order that we can continue to provide the homes that those who are homeless and people who require different or bigger accommodation need. Iain Gray, who is sitting next to Kezia Dugdale, once said that Labour passed world-leading housing legislation but just did not bother to do anything about building the houses to support that world-leading legislation. This Government is making sure that we have the right legislation in place but also that we are making the right investment to build the houses that are needed to support that legislation, and that is what we will continue to do.
The issue of children whose parents serve prison sentences is very important, and I am happy to seek to build consensus. Kezia Dugdale said that it is absolutely clear what the right thing to do is, but I am not sure that I am yet in a position to say with clarity what the right thing to do is. We have had work done, which the Government has based its position on, and a parliamentary committee has taken a different position. It is incumbent on me, as the First Minister, and the justice secretary to consider all of that carefully before we come to a conclusion, because it is so important that we give the right support to children who are in those circumstances. I will continue to give the matter the attention that it deserves and we will continue to treat it as seriously as we should. I give a commitment to Kezia Dugdale and members across the chamber that we will consult them—we are happy to discuss the matter further with them—and try to proceed in a way that commands support across the parliamentary chamber.
The First Minister has had eight years to know what the right thing to do for those children is.
I asked her specifically about children in temporary accommodation, so let me give her the answer. The answer is that 4,555 children live in temporary accommodation, without a home of their own. That figure has gone up by 402 children in the past year alone. After eight years in government, the First Minister is presiding over a rise in the number of children who are sleeping in temporary housing. She is resisting helping children who are affected by a parent being in prison, and we have not even started to talk about the 16,000 rejections in child and adolescent mental health services. Those children are waiting for us to help them; we cannot wait any longer to act. If the First Minister is really serious about closing the gap, surely she will commit today to producing an action plan for Scotland’s most vulnerable children.
Everything that my Government does will be intended to help the most vulnerable in our society, particularly the most vulnerable children. That is something that we should seek to agree on, not to divide on.
What about CAMHS?
Order.
Let me run through some of the issues that Kezia Dugdale has raised. We are investing heavily in child and adolescent mental health services—we are seeing an increase in the number of staff who are working in CAMHS—in order that we can target waiting times, which have been too long, and reduce them to the target time. In fact, I specifically mentioned CAMHS in my statement on the programme for government just last week.
This Government is also making sure that we have the right legislative framework and the right investment in place to tackle, reduce and eliminate homelessness.
Surely Kezia Dugdale cannot stand here in this chamber today and deny the impact of welfare cuts on, for example, homelessness and poverty in our country? [Interruption.]
Order.
Of course, this time last year Kezia Dugdale was arguing vigorously for the Tories to remain in charge of welfare issues. Therefore, her credibility on the issue might be a little bit stretched. [Interruption.]
Order.
For our part, we are spending £104 million this year to mitigate the impact of welfare reform, in addition to what we are doing on legislation and our investment in housing. That £104 million will help to mitigate the impact of welfare reform. It would be better if Kezia Dugdale got behind us on some of those actions, stopped arguing for the Tories to remain in charge of these things and equipped this Parliament to do them even better.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 10 Sep 2015 →- Registered Sex Offenders (GPS Tracking) Questions · 6
- Planning System (Review) Questions · 7
- NHS Lanarkshire (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Employment (Fraserburgh) Questions · 6
- Alcohol Misuse (Deaths) Questions · 6
- Carers (Central Scotland) Questions · 4
- Red Meat Levy Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 22
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Film and Television Production First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Abortion Law First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Progress in International Reading Literacy Study and Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Edinburgh Airport Flight Path Trial Members’ business · 25
- Internationalising Scottish Business Debate · 40
- Freight Transport Debate · 33
- Decision Time Decision time · 2
- Correction Procedure · 1
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.