I am grateful for the opportunity to discuss strategic planning in the Lothians this evening, and I extend my thanks to those members who added their support to the motion and allowed this issue to be debated.
I realise that strategic planning is not exactly a subject that sets the heather alight; indeed, I have seen eyes roll when I have mentioned it to my colleagues. However, when we begin to understand the planning system and the significance of the strategic city-based plans within that, the importance of strategic planning is obvious. It profoundly affects how our communities and towns, including Edinburgh, will physically grow in future.
When I discuss planning with people, I come back to the point that was well made at the Local Government and Regeneration Committee by John Wilson, who noted that most people view the planning system through the prism of their own individual experience with it. Specifically, they become aware of the wider planning system when a development is proposed in their community. The questions that they invariably ask themselves are about who planned the development and who approved it. That is the crux of the planning system, because those questions must be answered relatively straightforwardly and that requires a transparent planning system in which those who make the key decisions can be held to account.
The importance of the strategic plan is that it answers many of those questions, although perhaps not in a straightforward or transparent manner, along with those for our local development plans, which it also shapes. The housing developments, retail parks and other changes to our communities have their origins rooted in those documents, so their importance can hardly be overstated.
As we have just finished the consultation exercise on the main issues that will be contained in SESpIan 2 and many local authorities are in the midst of drawing up a new local plan, now would be an opportune moment to review how strategic planning is working. As my motion suggests, the bedrock of a healthy system is community and grass-roots participation in the process. We cannot encourage enough our community councils and other representative bodies to come forward and make themselves heard. However, that in itself is not enough.
I have introduced today’s debate to air some of the issues and, frankly, the frustrations that I have heard repeatedly from community councils and local authority councillors across the Lothians and further afield. One of those strikes at the heart of the transparency and accountability agenda, namely the development of the housing land requirement by the strategic planning authority and the use of the housing needs and demand assessment.
The most recent supplementary guidance has seen a reduction in the housing required for Edinburgh in the short term. Furthermore, I note with interest that reviewed guidance for the conduct of the HNDA was issued earlier this month. However, for many communities that is a small step, given that persistent doubts have been raised about the integrity of the assessment and that people have myriad questions about the process. That is a huge cause of controversy because of the significant pressure that it places on our greenfield sites and, indeed, the green belt. With brownfield sites in the Lothians that were identified in previous local development plans still lying undeveloped and with a significantly lower population than estimated, leading to reduced local government and health board funding in the area, it is easy to see where the frustration and doubts come from.
I understand that, only last week, representatives from the highly regarded Cockburn Association, which was established to promote conservation in Edinburgh, called into question some of the figures with planners from the City of Edinburgh Council. Those planners appeared to concede that the figures might be awry.
We must have full confidence in the demand for housing land supply, particularly as communities are being asked to give up valuable green space. I ask the minister to commit this evening to reviewing the targets and their methodology and—above all—to ensuring that the process is transparent. He has until only tomorrow to comment on the updated land supply guidance and he should take the opportunity to demand improvements.
One site that is threatened is Curriemuirend park; almost 500 people have objected to the proposed development there. Plans to invest in facilities for locals have been shelved in anticipation of the site’s development for housing.
That raises the question of who locals hold responsible for housing supply figures. They are struggling to find anyone who will take responsibility. When councillors are challenged about the decisions in the local development plan, they point to the Government. When the public raise the matter with their MSP, they are told that the fault lies with the all-powerful strategic plan. I suggest that there is a strong feeling that such plans allow politicians to avoid responsibility for tough decisions.
It is perhaps time for such significant decisions, particularly on housing, to be formally debated in the Parliament, so that we are clear about where we all stand on them and so that the public can see who is taking the decisions and—above all—hold those people to account accordingly. To put it simply, we must stop the blame game and stop politicians running away from their responsibilities.
That brings me to approval of our local plans. In Edinburgh, serious concerns about the infrastructure implications of several housing developments have been raised. Anyone who knows the level of congestion in the west of the city will understand the plight of residents in Cammo, who have taken the extraordinary step of threatening legal action against the city council.
More extraordinary still is the response of the city’s planning convener, Councillor Ian Perry, who suggests that any delay to the development plan would put in danger all of Edinburgh’s green belt and greenfield sites, which is plainly nonsense. The residents of Cammo and Edinburgh overall deserve a better choice than either a dud plan or uncontrolled and unfettered development of the green belt.
There are profound questions about the suitability of the local development plan’s implications for infrastructure. Given that, we should have time to step back and reflect on whether it can be improved but, instead, we face the prospect of its being forced through despite the concerns. I ask the minister to clarify whether he thinks that such advice is appropriate in the circumstances.
Accountability and transparency are the key aspects of an effective planning system. In the development of SESpIan 2, those two areas must be improved. In the more immediate term, urgent action is needed. I ask the minister again to undertake to reject the housing land supplementary guidance until we have confidence in its figures. I look forward to his comments on the situation in Edinburgh and I hope that he will agree that forcing through approval of a local development plan in such circumstances is in no way appropriate.
17:13