To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00461)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 5
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Tricia Marwick 1
The record
11 contributionsLater today, I will be speaking to the chief executive officer of Scottish wind turbine manufacturer Gaia-Wind, who has today announced the signing of a £5 million contract to provide up to 200 small turbines for installation in England and Wales. I am sure that the whole chamber will wish to welcome a successful company agreeing contracts and enhancing its reputation as a leading manufacturer of small wind turbines across these islands.
Indeed we do.
The new Forth crossing is the most expensive public project in Scottish history and is central to attempts to sustain and grow Scottish businesses and to create much-needed jobs. The project should have a legacy that goes beyond a bridge; people understand that. So why did the First Minister sign away the contracts—and the Scottish jobs—to Spain, Poland and China?
In reality, 118 out of 155 subcontracts for the project have been awarded to Scottish companies, which represents 76 per cent of the total. As for supply orders, for 870 out of 1,041—[Interruption] That is 83.5 per cent, Ms Baillie, the principal contract for which has been awarded to Scottish companies, which is a very substantial percentage. That means that the Forth replacement crossing project will support 1,200 Scottish jobs and secure an additional 3,000. Every year, construction will deliver 45 vocational training positions, 21 places on professional bodies and 46 positions for the long-term unemployed, and it will maximise the number of modern apprenticeship opportunities. All in all, it looks to me like Scotland is getting a substantially good deal from the Forth replacement crossing.
I am stunned by the limit of the ambition that the First Minister shows. This contract was to be a legacy for the people of this country and for the economy but, on his own minister’s account, it is worth £20 million out of a contract worth £1.5 billion. The First Minister has no excuses. In Wales, a Labour Government had the political will to ensure that Welsh companies had equal access to public contracts, thereby saving businesses and creating jobs, but rather than look to our neighbours, Alex Salmond went to China and pulled off a master deal—the Chinese got an £800 million steel contract and we got two pandas. If Wales can deliver for Welsh businesses, what is stopping the Scottish First Minister delivering for Scottish businesses and Scottish families?
The total value of the principal contract for the Forth replacement crossing is £790 million, of which the steel component represents 5 to 10 per cent. I am not sure whether Johann Lamont knows this, but we do not have manufacturing facilities for steel fabrication in Scotland thanks to the depredations of past Westminster Governments, and so no firms that submitted tenders for the steel fabrication subcontracts were Scottish. Perhaps a quarter to a half of the 5 to 10 per cent of the £790 million is for steel plating, which we do produce in Scotland. Johann Lamont says that there is an £800 million contract, but steel represents only 5 to 10 per cent of that, of which 25 to 50 per cent is the sort of steel that we produce in Scotland. I know that this is not the script that she wanted to hear, but having 76 per cent of all the subcontracts awarded to Scottish companies not only represents a good deal for Scottish companies but is amazingly better than anything that happened when the Labour Party was in power in Scotland. [Interruption.]
Order. Ms Baillie, could you please keep quiet?
The First Minister thinks that this is a game. The script that the people of Scotland want to hear is not one in which he says, “Oh, it’s not £1.5 billion; it’s £20 million out of £790 million, so that makes it okay.” That is a tiny proportion of the money.
The reality is that the biggest contract in Scotland for a generation is creating jobs in Spain, in Poland and in China. Alex Salmond is spending £800 million on steel—[Interruption]—and from that contract not a single job is being created in Scotland, at a time when 200 people are losing their jobs every day. Even the London Olympics have benefited Scottish companies to the tune of £100 million—five times more than the benefit from the Forth replacement crossing contract.
How can it be value for money in the long term to send abroad the profits, business creation, research and development and high-quality jobs that such big contracts generate? How can that make sense?
There is a great disadvantage in reading from a script. Occasionally a person reads a wrong line; but it also means that they do not listen to the answers.
In my previous answer, I pointed out that the total value of the contract is £790 million, of which 5 to 10 per cent is for the steel contract. We do not do fabricated steel in Scotland. Of the fabricated steel contract, perhaps a quarter to a half is steel plate, which we do in Scotland.
Now that Johann Lamont realises that the £800 million figure that she was given in her script is not the actual figure, which is a small fraction of that, will she revise her opinion of the total impact of what the Scottish Government is doing?
I agree with Johann Lamont that we must do our absolute best to ensure that contracts come to Scottish companies. Johann Lamont would have been in the chamber at the time, so I wonder if she remembers Jack McConnell, at First Minister’s question time on 16 June 2005, saying, “restricted I am by the rules of procurement”, and having to explain why a fisheries protection vessel was going to a Polish shipyard instead of Ferguson Shipbuilders at Port Glasgow. What a contrast with Alex Neil’s announcement in November of a £20 million contract for a new ferry for Ferguson’s in Scotland.
And he accuses me of not being able to read my script. [Laughter.] I am sure that it was well worth it for civil servants to do the research to find that quotation.
Can we deal with what people in this country are saying now? They include Community trade union workers, who are concerned about their jobs, and all the businesses and people—beyond steel—who thought that the contract would bring work to their communities.
A fortnight ago, in response to the shocking unemployment figures, the First Minister claimed that his Government puts the greatest emphasis on job creation; yet here we are in a situation in which Scottish trade unionists from the Dalzell steelworks have written to David Cameron—I cannot believe that I am saying this, but I have the letter here—to ask a Tory Prime Minister to protect them from the actions of a Scottish First Minister. [Interruption.] I know, I cannot believe it either. The steelworkers and Community trade unionists in Scotland wrote:
“To date, First Minister, Alex Salmond MSP, has failed to give any satisfactory explanation why foreign suppliers were given preference over Scottish firms”.
Why is the First Minister not doing his job? Why is he not standing up for Scotland? Will he stand up for Scottish workers and instruct an immediate review of a disgraceful contract, which will have huge consequences in our communities?
Let us try four reasons. First, given that Johann Lamont did not return to the issue, I think that we are probably agreed that we are talking about not an £800 million contract but about 5 to 10 per cent of that.
Secondly, can we agree that there is no steel fabrication proposal from Scotland? No firm that submitted a tender for the steel fabrication subcontracts was Scottish. That is because we do not have steel fabrication facilities in Scotland any more, thanks to the depredations of past United Kingdom Governments—Labour and Conservative.
Thirdly, can we agree that there is substantial evidence, from the figures on subcontracts that I put forward, that 76 per cent of subcontracts have been awarded to Scottish companies?
Fourthly, can we agree, as Johann Lamont must be aware, that contracts cannot just be directed to go to Scottish companies but have to be competitively placed out? By establishing the portal for contracts, this Government has allowed tens of thousands of small and medium-sized businesses in Scotland to obtain the benefit of public procurement and purchasing. That has happened under this Administration. Under a past Administration, largely due to Labour’s fascination with the private finance initiative, there was no ability whatsoever to influence those things.
Given that Ms Lamont now knows the actual value of the contract, that she probably now knows that there are no steel fabricating facilities in Scotland, that she now knows that 76 per cent of the subcontracts have gone to Scottish companies, and that she is aware of the efforts that have been made through the portal, will she finally agree that the situation is hugely better now than it was under the Administration of her and her colleagues?
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 9 Feb 2012 →- Review of Teacher Employment Statement · 34
- Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2012 [Draft] Debate · 87
- Forth Replacement Crossing Questions · 4
- Transport Infrastructure (North East Scotland) Questions · 6
- Higher Education (European Union Students) Questions · 4
- PIP Implants (Public Inquiry) Questions · 6
- Dyslexia Questions · 4
- Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder Questions · 5
- Home Energy Efficiency Questions · 6
- Transport Priorities (Scottish Borders) Questions · 8
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Leuchars (Multirole Brigade) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Secondary Education (National Exams) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Renewables Targets (Offshore Opportunities) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Gypsy Travellers Questions · 8
- Single Scottish Police Service (Superintendent Posts) Questions · 4
- Single Scottish Police Service (Chief Constable) Questions · 8
- Single Scottish Police Service Questions · 7
- Sentencing (Offenders Released on Licence) Questions · 4
- Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill (Independent Custody Visiting) Questions · 5
- Scottish Court Service (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Prisoners (Alcohol-related Courses) Questions · 4
- Environmental Issues (Attitudinal Data) Questions · 6
- Forestry Development (Upland Grazing Interests) Questions · 9
- Environmental Policy (2011 Interim Performance Targets) Questions · 4
- Air Quality (Glasgow) Questions · 7
- Dairy Farmers (Support) Questions · 6
- Scottish Environment Protection Agency (Enforcement Powers) Questions · 4
- Zero Waste Plan Questions · 4
- Emissions Reductions (2020 Target) Questions · 4
- Youth Employment Strategy Debate · 58
- Regional Chamber of the Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe and Committee of the Regions (Membership) Debate · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 15
- Co-operatives Members’ business · 25
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.