I begin by thanking my party for allowing me to bring forward this debate on the continuing provision of orthopaedic trauma services at Ayr hospital. I hope that the Parliament, having survived the trauma of the collapse of the voting and sound system on 27 October, which was largely reinstated and restored yesterday, will welcome and take note of this debate.
I also thank the Parliament for its power and influence because, since the motion was lodged, NHS Ayrshire and Arran has withdrawn its proposal to move trauma orthopaedics from Ayr hospital, as announced recently in the local press. I should also thank the Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy for her influence and for the discussions that I know she had with NHS Ayrshire and Arran executives. I ask Parliament to take note that, once again, the wishes of the people have been respected.
Today, I want to reaffirm the need for a two-centre approach to hospital care and, particularly, accident and emergency services in Ayrshire, of which trauma orthopaedics is an integral part. I know that that view is shared by other colleagues such as Adam Ingram and Chic Brodie.
Centralisation of services has been a long-term agenda of NHS Ayrshire and Arran and, although we have stopped the process with trauma orthopaedics, it comes as no surprise that the intention existed following the desire of NHS Ayrshire and Arran and the then Labour Government to close the A and E department at Ayr hospital—a plan first disclosed to me in August 2005 at the NHS Ayrshire and Arran annual review, presided over by the then Labour minister Andy Kerr. Perhaps that is why no Labour members are taking part in this debate.
As members will recall, that plan provoked outrage in southern Ayrshire, with 55,000 people signing a petition against the proposals and 5,000 marching through the streets of Ayr in February 2006 in protest. I put on record my thanks to all those who helped in the campaign between 2005 and 2007. It is worth noting how correct that campaign was: the A and E units at Ayr and Crosshouse are both now busier than they have ever been. Attendances at Ayr hospital are peaking at 140 to 150 per day. On average, 30 medical patients, 11 of whom require surgery, are admitted daily.
In 2007, the need for a two-centre approach to be taken to A and E services because of Ayrshire’s geography was pointed out to NHS Ayrshire and Arran, as it has been since. The argument was, and still is, driven by the need to be within an hour’s distance of an A and E unit by ambulance or car.
That need will remain and grow with the ageing profile of Ayrshire’s community and the increase in admissions of elderly people, particularly those suffering from falls and, as a result, broken limbs. The growing incidence of osteoporosis, osteoporotic fractures and heart attacks demands that as little time as possible be spent in ambulances on Ayrshire’s far-from-perfect road surfaces.
The same arguments apply for trauma and orthopaedics. That is why I and others were so opposed to the most recent proposals.
It is self-evident that I am not a doctor, but doctors have advised me that the proposals to locate trauma and orthopaedics on one site at Crosshouse would have led to a loss of capacity and capability in the A and E department at Ayr hospital and may ultimately have posed a threat to the long-term viability of the A and E services there. That is why, once again, I found myself taking issue with NHS Ayrshire and Arran’s centralising agenda.
Where time is not of the essence for the treatment and survivability of an illness, there is a place for concentrating resources on one site. Over the years, services such as maternity and paediatric care have moved to one site at Crosshouse. On the other hand, urology and ophthalmology are located at Ayr. I welcome the fact that the new cardioverter defibrillator fitting service, which was previously provided in Glasgow, was located at Ayr hospital in July this year.
However, I am also aware that the centralisation of patient records at Crosshouse has not been a huge success thus far. Medical staff have expressed to me concerns about faults that have emerged in the TrakCare system, which is apparently being rolled out across Scotland before those faults have been fully ironed out. Perhaps, in his closing speech, the Minister for Public Health might make the Parliament aware of what is being done to make that system work better.
Again, I thank those who helped to see off the latest threat to A and E services at Ayr. However, I note that elected members of all parties will need to remain vigilant and protective of the facility if it is not to be placed under threat in future. After all, as Benjamin Franklin noted more than 200 years ago:
“A man convinced against his will is of the same opinion still.”
That applies to the decision makers at NHS Ayrshire and Arran, who were convinced against their will to adopt a two-centre approach to the provision of A and E services in Ayrshire following the election in 2007. I, and others, remain unconvinced that their view has changed, notwithstanding the clear instruction of the Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy. For as long as there is a breath in my body, I will watch to see that two centres are maintained in Ayrshire, and the minister and the cabinet secretary will have my absolute support in that regard.
12:38