I agree with the view that it has been useful to have this debate; it is very sensible for the committee to have done so. This is, of course, a matter for the committee, and far be it from me, as a member of the Government, to say what the committee should do, but I think it is a very sensible suggestion that the committee continues to examine these matters.
The change that we are discussing has been driven by factors beyond the levy to the PSA but, taking that as a starting point, it should be pointed out that this Parliament has already agreed the changes for funding the PSA. I understand that the instrument that set out those changes came before the committee on 23 February.
This discussion goes beyond that particular issue. The HCPC has a need to upgrade its systems and to ensure that they are up to speed so that it can properly regulate the profession for which it has responsibility. I am not unsympathetic to the concerns that have been expressed. How could anyone be? No one wants to have to pay more.
It is important to place the rise in fees in some context, as Mr Doris and Mr MacKenzie have sought to do. I know that there was an exchange about this earlier. In comparison with the other professional regulatory bodies, the HCPC, even with the fee increase, comes in significantly at the bottom of the league. It has by far and away the lowest of any fee among the UK professional regulatory bodies.
The increase has been described as 12.5 per cent; I cannot say that that is incorrect, but I also think it important to put the increase in its proper context. In that light, it turns out to be £10 a year—and less when we take into account the fact that some of it can be recouped through tax payments.
There has also been some discussion about the fee in the other context of pay policy. It is important to recognise that not everyone who is regulated by this body is covered by public sector pay policy; some work in the private sector. However, if you look at Scottish public sector pay policy, you will see that the NHS staff who come under agenda for change and are covered by this body—and to whom, therefore, the increase will apply—are expected to be in at least band 4 or, as is perhaps more likely, band 5. Last year and this year, we have implemented the NHS pay review body recommendations for an uplift to all scale points while maintaining progression, and this year band 4 staff who have still to reach the top of their scale will have received an increase of about 4 per cent ahead of the 1 per cent that has been referred to. That will more than make up for the amount by which the HCPC is increasing the levy.
We have contacted the HCPC as a body, and it has set out its commitment to us as an Administration that, as has been mentioned, it wants to move to a system of monthly payments, which I think will make things easier for those who have to pay the levy. I also point out the commitment not to increase the fees again in the foreseeable future. I hear what has been said about that, but we need to take that commitment at face value; indeed, I do not see how we can operate fairly on any other basis.
The annulment—if the committee were to agree to it, which I sincerely hope will not be the case—would impact on the HCPC’s ability to regulate the professions for which it has responsibility. I also presume that it would not be able to upgrade its systems in the way that it wants to, and my understanding is that, without this increase, its funds could quickly end up in deficit. That would impact on public safety, which, after all, is ultimately what regulation is all about. On that basis, I strongly urge the committee not to annul the order.