We do not support the Scottish statutory instrument. When the Public Services Reform (Scotland) Bill was first debated in the Parliament, Scottish Liberal Democrats raised our serious concerns about the powers that part 2 would confer. Section 10 allowed ministers to
“make any provision which ... would improve the exercise of public functions”.
That included
“modifying, conferring, abolishing, transferring, or”
delegating
“any function”.
It also included abolishing, creating or amending the constitution of public bodies.
Part 2 allowed potentially radical changes to a number of bodies to be made without any ability for Parliament to make amendments. Instead, changes were to be brought to Parliament by statutory instrument. As Jeremy Purvis said at the time,
“Parliament will have a final say, but it will not have a full say in potentially large scale changes”.—[Official Report, 25 March 2010; c 25018.]
The cabinet secretary assured the Finance Committee that the powers in part 2 of the Public Services Reform (Scotland) Act 2010 had been used in
“a relatively small number of orders ... to make important but small-scale changes.”—[Official Report, Finance Committee, 20 May 2015; c 2.]
He thought that that should “provide reassurance” that the powers should be extended for another five years. I do not agree. I do not doubt his good intentions, but I point out that scale is in the eye of the beholder.
We remain opposed to the powers as set out in part 2. They are too wide. The powers were used to bring forward an SSI to abolish prison visiting committees. To my mind, and to many prisoners and organisations, that was not a small-scale change. Visiting panels played an important role in the lives of people serving prison sentences and their families. That change should have been subject to thorough, proper parliamentary scrutiny, not made through an SSI.
Today’s SSI is about not simply how the powers have been used to date but how they could still be used. We are right to work to ensure that the Parliament has all the scrutiny and amending powers that it requires. A continuation of the order-making powers undermines our powers in Parliament. For that reason, Scottish Liberal Democrats will not support the SSI.
17:00