Peatlands are a vital part of Scotland’s natural capital and provide some of our best open landscapes. They are important for biodiversity, carbon and water, for our cultural identity, and as historical archives. Globally and nationally, there are major commitments to the conservation and restoration of peatlands. As species champion for the rusty bog moss, which is one of the emblems of the health of peat bogs, I have a particular interest in my constituency in the issue.
One of the threats to peatlands is from the commercial mining of peat for the garden retail and the professional horticulture industry. In a chapter entitled “Peat as a manure”, a book called “Peat and its Products”, published in 1905, provides the testimony of
“A well-known horticulturist, Mr. James Kennedy, of the Nursery, Greenbrae, Dumfries”.
Writing to “The Scottish Peat Industries” in 1904, Mr Kennedy said:
“Considering the fact that it was on July 17th that the plants were potted, the photo taken on October 19th proves the success of the experiment, also that a good crop of tomatoes can be grown on peat in little over three months.”
He went on to say:
“I am so satisfied with the results already obtained that I intend to test peat as a good material for growing other plants as well as tomatoes and have every confidence of recommending it to other growers.”
That was more than a century ago, and the use of peat is a practice that has expanded over many decades.
At the same time, advances in the development of alternatives, including recycled materials, mean that Scotland could develop a long-term viable industry to provide sustainable soil conditioners and growing materials for amateur and professional gardeners. Clear Scottish targets for ending commercial peat extraction are needed, along with fiscal measures and incentives to support a vibrant market in sustainable horticultural products.
The global importance of peatlands, particularly for biodiversity and climate change, has been well established through the International Union for Conservation of Nature commission of inquiry on peatlands. Scotland is at the forefront of international policy to protect and restore peatlands, and it has a draft national peatland plan.
Lowland peatlands in Scotland are estimated to store 64 million tonnes of carbon in the peat, which is more than 18 years’ worth of Scotland’s transport emissions. Commercial extraction involves the stripping of peat-forming vegetation, drainage and extraction, which results in the stored carbon being released to the atmosphere. In the United Kingdom, consumption of peat leads to annual carbon dioxide emissions of more than 630,000 tonnes, at a cost to society of £32.5 million, arising from the climate change impact.
Commercial extraction—or mining—of peat for use as a growing media or soil conditioner has developed over the past 100 years, and peat has replaced traditional loam and leaf-mould-based composts. The industry mainly removes peat from lowland raised bogs because of their deep peat layer, developed over millennia, and their relative accessibility for heavy machinery. I have some raised bogs in my constituency, as will many other members.
No up-to-date records are kept by the Scottish Government on peat extraction planning permissions. Earlier data shows that, in 2003, there were 72 commercial extraction sites in Scotland, with 20 still active, 16 expired and 33 awaiting confirmations. Current Scottish planning policy permits commercial extraction only in areas suffering historical, significant damage as a result of human activity, and where the conservation value is low and restoration is impossible. Despite the fact that most damaged peatlands are capable of being restored, developers have continued to seek new permissions or extensions to existing permissions. A number of recent applications are currently being considered by local planning authorities.
Concerns about the impact of peat extraction on important wildlife habitats and the climate implications of removing ancient natural carbon stores have led to calls for a halt to peat extraction, which are supported by leading authorities such as the Royal Horticultural Society. There are now many alternatives to peat composts—including some high-profile brand names—which are already widely available in garden centres across the UK. Today, many peat-free composts work as effectively as peat ones. Much of the material used for peat replacement, such as commercial green compost, also contributes to recycling or uses by-products such as wood brash and other forestry waste. Advances are also being made in more technical applications such as the commercial growing of plants, with B&Q announcing a peat-free bedding plant range.
In 2010, the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs set out proposals—now adopted by the UK Government—for retail supplies in England to be peat-free by 2020 and for commercial horticulture to end peat use by 2030, although advances in commercial peat-free products should mean that that target could be brought forward. Unfortunately, UK Government figures for 2012 show that 57 per cent of compost sold in the UK is still peat based and that there has been little reduction in peat use.
I ask the minister to consider establishing legal, binding targets for an end to peat in retail sales of growing media, soil conditioners and commercial horticulture; introducing carbon accounting for the use of peat-based products; immediately ending the procurement of peat by Government and public bodies; introducing fiscal measures to support the development of sustainable peat-free products; ensuring that the Scottish ministers are informed of all development planning proposals for commercial peat extraction; and biannual Scottish Government reporting on progress towards targets. If we are able to do that, we will have peat-free growing conditions that are good for plants, good for our climate and good for our natural environment.
12:42