To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02815)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 7
- Kezia Dugdale Lab 5
- Tricia Marwick 2
- Drew Smith Lab 1
The record
15 contributionsEngagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
For months, teachers have been telling Scottish National Party ministers about problems with the new national examinations. In February, teachers told the Parliament that there could be a catastrophe and headteachers warned of a disaster. They asked to delay the new highers, but ministers chose to ignore those warnings.
Last week, it all ended in tears—the tears of pupils trying to sit higher mathematics, which has widely been condemned as flawed and too difficult. More than 17,000 pupils and parents have signed a petition in protest. What has the First Minister done about it?
The picture that Kezia Dugdale seeks to paint of our exams is unfair. It is unfair to pupils who are studying hard right now for those exams. The annual exam diet is a tense time for students and their parents. Young people work hard throughout the year and they do not deserve that kind of characterisation of the system.
We are aware of concerns that have been expressed about the recent higher mathematics exam and we take them seriously. The Scottish Qualifications Authority is responsible for ensuring that exams are set clearly and to the correct standards. It is also responsible for ensuring that rigorous processes are in place to give candidates fair treatment every year and maintain standards. The SQA has assured us—and, more important, the people of Scotland—that no candidate will be disadvantaged if any exam paper is proven to be more demanding than it was intended to be.
That is why the processes are in place. They are in place every year and they exist to make sure that our students who work so hard get the best treatment, because that is what they deserve.
With respect, I am bringing to the chamber the concerns of teachers and parents.
The First Minister is right that the SQA has said that it will change the pass mark, but changing the pass mark can help only candidates who tried the questions. Those who were too upset to complete the exam or who spent too long trying to interpret the questions will get no benefit.
That was the SQA’s answer; I asked what the First Minister is doing about the situation. The minister
“‘is perfectly happy to sit back and allow the Scottish Qualifications Authority to attract all the accusations and criticism ...’ It was the minister who forced the authority to introduce the new examination”
and the minister
“should have been able to prevent such a ‘deplorable outcome’”. [Interruption.]
I hear that the SNP back benchers are not happy with that, but those are not my words—they are the words of Nicola Sturgeon when she was shadow education minister back in the last SQA crisis. Does the First Minister agree with Nicola Sturgeon that politicians should stop passing the buck?
Kezia Dugdale is referring to the episode under the previous Labour Government—[Interruption.]
Order.
—when there was a comprehensive failure of the administration of the exam system. What we are talking about here is the content of the exam paper for a particular subject. I am sure—at least, I hope—that Kezia Dugdale is not seriously suggesting that the First Minister or any other politician should set or mark the exams that our young people sit.
The SQA’s responsibility is to ensure that exams are set to the correct standard. It has given assurance that the live question paper for the maths exam was designed according to the course assessment specification for higher maths. It was developed by experienced teachers, and both the current and the new higher maths papers were overseen by the same principal assessor.
More important, as I said in my original answer, the SQA issued a statement last week that makes it clear that it has in place not new processes to take account of the situation but standard processes to moderate results each year if a paper proves to be unexpectedly difficult or easy. The point of that is to ensure that consistent standards are maintained year on year.
The SQA has emphasised that no candidate will be disadvantaged if this year’s exam is proven to be too difficult. It has also said, as I assume that Kezia Dugdale knows, that it will take account of the distress felt by pupils sitting the exam who thought that it was more difficult than they expected it to be.
Those are the processes that are in place to ensure that we have a consistent—and a consistently high—standard in our exam system. It is right that that is overseen by the professional SQA. I assume that that assurance is positive for Kezia Dugdale and, more important, parents and the public across the country to hear.
We are talking about the prospects of thousands of children across Scotland. In January, I alerted the First Minister to the SQA’s appeals system not being fit for purpose. Access to the system depends on a school’s ability to pay, and appeals have been replaced by reviews and re-marks, which take no account of the circumstances on exam day.
Parents in private schools are paying for a second mark of their children’s exams. They can even pay extra for a priority review—that costs just £39.75, as advertised on the SQA website. The appeals system is about to be tested to destruction by this year’s higher maths exam. It has been four months since I raised the issue. Has the First Minister done anything to fix that unfair and unjust system?
The implication that lies behind Kezia Dugdale’s question—that better-off parents can somehow buy better exam results for their children—is simply not true. The SQA introduced its new post-results service in 2014 to replace the former appeals system. The new service is the result of wide-ranging consultation among the SQA, schools, colleges and other education professionals, who all recognised that a review of the appeals service was required. The new service was introduced precisely so that a fairer and more rigorous system would be in place.
I say in all sincerity to Kezia Dugdale that the issues are important. I do not for a second deny or demur from that point. However, it is not fair to pupils around the country to come here with particular concerns such as the concern over the higher maths paper, which has been and will be addressed by the Scottish Qualifications Authority, and to suggest somehow that our entire exams system is flawed. Why is that not fair? Because it undermines the efforts—and is in danger of undermining the results—of those students who have worked so hard to achieve exam passes.
When issues are raised by pupils and parents, as was the case with the maths exam, they will be addressed and responded to. We will do that responsibly; we will do that while wishing all the students across the country who are still sitting exams the very best of success.
The First Minister questions the unfairness. Perhaps I can remind her of what Larry Flanagan said when I last brought the matter up:
“Appeals should be based upon the professional judgment of teachers rather than on the wishes of the parent and what is now happening is fundamentally wrong.”
There are serious concerns, which the First Minister should reflect on.
We heard this week that 25 per cent of medical students come from private schools. Some of the pupils who have been defeated by this unfair exam in maths, and those sitting chemistry today, might have been hoping to change that. They are afraid that their chance could be gone, and so are their parents. [Interruption.] SNP back benchers are guffawing, but here are a couple of quotes.
Chloe Thomson from Hawick said:
“I have studied very hard all year in preparation for my exams in the hope of attaining 5As in order to apply to university to study medicine, this dream now seems completely out of reach due to the awful maths exam that I endured yesterday.”
Allana McCrone from Dumfries said:
“My son studied hard for this exam, he came home devastated afterwards and this has added extra stress to him he still has exams to sit.”
The First Minister took two pages of the Daily Record this week to tell us how well she was served by the education system. Perhaps she should worry more about what is happening in our schools today.
The appeals system and the new exams need sorted out. The First Minister said that education is her “sacred responsibility”. Surely it is time for some divine intervention from the First Minister.
It is clear that Kezia Dugdale was not listening to a word that I said in my earlier answers—or perhaps she was listening but could not change her script to respond. She read out the distressed comments of somebody who sat the higher maths paper. I have huge sympathy for anybody who sits an exam and comes out of it feeling like that, but surely Kezia Dugdale’s responsibility is to relay to that young person the assurances and reassurances that the SQA has given and that I have outlined today.
Let me repeat that no young person sitting the higher maths exam will be disadvantaged if it is found that the exam was more difficult than intended. How can we say that with confidence? Because the SQA has the processes in place every single year to moderate results and take account of the fact that an exam might be found to be easier or harder than was intended. Those systems are in place precisely to protect against the understandable fears that the young person who was quoted expressed. Instead of playing up those fears, surely Kezia Dugdale’s responsibility is to join us in reassuring that young person. That would be more responsible.
In relation to—
Back to the script.
Order.
I do not think that Labour members who are shouting abuse across the chamber are remotely interested in our young people’s fortunes. As always, the top priority of Labour members is simply to hurl abuse at the SNP, and that will not be lost on anyone.
I will come on to the second substantive and important point that Kezia Dugdale raised, which was on the new system for appeals. It is important to emphasise that, as with all SQA charges, local authorities will meet the costs of requests by any public sector schools to use the service. The Association of Directors of Education in Scotland made it clear in a statement back in February that no young person will be disadvantaged under the new system.
Headteachers are clear that decisions are made on an educational basis, not on a cost basis. Ken Cunningham, general secretary of School Leaders Scotland, said:
“The decision to appeal will not be reached based on looking at the books, but on what schools feel is right for their pupils.”
Those are the kinds of assurances that are important for our young people. Instead of trying to scaremonger, Labour should be doing its bit to get those assurances out there.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 28 May 2015 →- General Question Time Questions · 1
- Teacher Recruitment (West Lothian) Questions · 5
- European Commission (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Secretary of State for Work and Pensions (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Road Safety (A92 in North East Fife) Questions · 4
- ScotRail (Club 50 Scheme) Questions · 4
- Home Ownership Questions · 6
- Emergency Eye Care (NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde) Questions · 4
- Modern Apprenticeships (Deaf People) Questions · 5
- Housing Associations (Affordable Rents) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 15
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Queen’s Speech (Scottish Government’s Response) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Land and Buildings Transaction Tax and Landfill Tax (Revenue) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Scottish Qualifications Authority (Higher Mathematics Examination) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Peat (Extraction for Horticulture) Members’ business · 9
- Historical Child Abuse Statement · 36
- Scottish Elections (Reduction of Voting Age) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 44
- Scottish Elections (Reduction of Voting Age) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 2
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 5
- Decision Time Decision time · 5
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.