I thank all the members who supported the motion in my name. The motion attracted support from all the political parties in the Parliament with the exception of the Conservatives. [Interruption.] I note that from a sedentary position Alex Johnstone has made a gesture towards me, but I do not know whether it means that the Conservatives now support the motion. Perhaps he can make that clear during his speech. I hope that, after a constructive debate this evening, we can take forward the issue of rent-tied pub tenants in a cross-party manner.
Many of us have various experiences of pubs—some have more than others—but the thrust of the debate is about the contractual arrangements that tied pubs find themselves in. It is estimated that there are more than 4,600 pubs in Scotland and that more than 20 per cent of them are tied pubs owned by pub companies. I am sure that over the years we have all received representations on the challenging economic climate for those pubs and, for that matter, many pubs across Scotland, particularly because of laws that have been passed in Westminster and in the Scottish Parliament. We owe it to hard-working pub tenants not to put further obstacles in their way in dealing with the challenges that they will face over the coming years. We support many of the legislative changes that have been made, but that makes it all the more important to take forward this debate at the same time.
All the evidence that I have seen has recognised that the tied model is wide open to abuse; many tenants find themselves trapped in bleak financial situations and forced to buy products at an inflated rate from the pubcos, which allows them to save little and invest little in their business. Last year, CGA Strategy surveyed Scottish tied-pub tenants for the Campaign for Real Ale, and its findings were shocking. I will highlight a number of them. It found that 66 per cent of the respondents earned less than £15,000 per annum, and 10 per cent of them earned less than £10,000 per annum; that 74 per cent of respondents considered themselves worse off as a result of the tied model; and that 3 per cent had a very positive sentiment for the tied-pub arrangement that they have with the pubcos. In taking the issue forward, we should also recognise that 99 per cent of respondents felt that the Scottish Government should take action now to protect pub tenants north of the border.
The tied-pub model has been scrutinised over a number of years, particularly at Westminster, and the United Kingdom Government received a great deal of evidence on the subject in 2013. I will highlight examples of the pubcos’ activities, and I am sure that members will highlight others. Practices include pubcos informing tenants about large rent rises without giving them any justification for the increases and pubcos providing tenants with misleading estimates of potential sales.
I met a publican who advised me that, if he invested in his premises, the works would be done by the pubco’s contractors at an inflated rate, to ensure that the pubco received its cut from the work. I think that most of us would find such practices unacceptable. They certainly do not support small businesses across Scotland.
For far too long, tied-pub tenants have been squeezed by the pubcos, which behave like payday lenders. That is unacceptable, and I call on the Government to take specific action. Last year, MPs considered what became the Small Business, Enterprise and Employment Act 2015 for England and Wales to ensure that no tied-pub tenant is worse off than a free-of-tie pub tenant. The act introduces a statutory code of practice and an independent adjudicator to govern the relationship between tenants and pubcos, and it was amended to include a market-rent-only option for pub tenants. The bill provided options to ensure parity in the relationship between pubcos and tenants.
For many years, there has been a constitutional discussion about this grey area. There have been a number of constitutional discussions over the years, and that has been one of them. As a result, Scottish publicans will not benefit from the new laws that have been passed at Westminster. Today, I call on the Scottish Government to introduce an independent adjudicator, a statutory code of conduct and a market-rent-only option, which will make the position in Scotland similar to that in England and Wales. That would let every tenant choose between a tied and a free-of-tie arrangement, which would allow the market to decide which is best, and it would allow tenants a fair, reasonable and transparent review of the true rental value of their property.
For once, legislation has been passed at Westminster that we agree with. I am surprised that the Scottish Government finds itself in the position that we have to debate the issue, given that we have received cross-party support, including support from Scottish National Party members. I say that in a constructive tone, because I want to take the matter forward and ensure that publicans and small businesses throughout Scotland benefit.
We should recognise the importance of these businesses. I think that members will be surprised to hear that pubs directly employ more than 43,000 people in Scotland. They are an important part of our industry and they provide employment opportunities for people in Scotland.
I call on the Scottish Government to give clarity today on how we can move forward. I ask the minister—I will intervene on him if he does not confirm this—to give us a commitment that there will be a similar consultation exercise to the one that was carried out at Westminster, and that the Scottish Government will look to legislate before the Scottish Parliament elections next year.
I call on the Parliament to support the sentiments of my motion.
17:14