To ask the Scottish Government how it plans to address the attainment gap between children from the poorest and wealthiest homes. (S4O-03206)
Official Report · Chamber
Attainment Gap
Portfolio Question Time Education and Lifelong Learning
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael Russell SNP 3
- John Lamont Con 2
- Kezia Dugdale Lab 1
The record
6 contributionsThe Joseph Rowntree Foundation’s report on closing the attainment gap in Scottish education, which was published last week, confirms that the attainment gap between children from high and low-income households has begun to narrow. The report also recognises the potential of key Scottish Government policies such as curriculum for excellence and the early years collaborative to make a significant impact on further reducing the gap.
I whole-heartedly agree with the report’s conclusions, but there is still much to be done. The reasons for the attainment gap are complex and include, as the report notes, factors in a child’s home background, and they will require partnership working over a range of policy areas. We and our partners are strongly committed to tackling this and we are supporting a range of activities at national and local level that will make a difference and help to make Scotland the best place to go to school.
However, I am sure that the member will allow me to say that closing the attainment gap also needs to involve tackling the root causes of poverty, which only independence will give us the economic powers to do.
I thank the cabinet secretary for his response, but I question whether the Government is doing enough. Figures that were obtained by the Scottish Conservatives last month revealed that, in 2013, 2.9 per cent of children from Scotland’s most deprived homes achieved three As at higher compared with 20.3 per cent of children from the most affluent. That gap is a vicious circle that prevents children from realising their full potential. Although the cabinet secretary is fully aware of that fact, he seems very reluctant to consider any fundamental changes to our system of schooling to resolve the problem. Surely in the name of equality of opportunity we need a much bolder agenda that empowers headteachers, increases autonomy and gives parents and pupils a real choice when it comes to schooling.
I certainly agree with the member that we need to take every possible action to improve the situation in Scotland, and that is what the Government is attempting to do. It does not mean tinkering with the system in the way that the leader of the member’s party has suggested; what it means is fundamental and radical change to society. That comes about, for example, by ensuring that the powers to set taxation and to deal with welfare and labour market regulation lie with this Parliament, which would make a significant difference. What it also means is that we do not do things to make the situation worse and that we do not, for example, create welfare policies that, according to the Child Poverty Action Group, mean that 100,000 more children will be in poverty by 2020. The biggest contribution that the Tories could make would be to understand that and to stop penalising the poor in Scotland.
Has the cabinet secretary seen “Mind the Gap: Tackling Educational Inequality in Scotland”, Labour’s social justice sounding board paper on tackling educational inequality? Is he aware that there are 12 recommendations in the report that do not require independence? Has he read the report and is he willing to do some cross-party work in that area?
I did read that report and I am delighted to say that that work is already under way. If the Labour Party wants to support that work, I am thrilled. I read the report with a little curiosity, because it is not a manifesto, a set of pledges or even a pre-manifesto—it is apparently a paper to inform the debate before the pre-manifesto process. I am not entirely sure how that works. However, the first recommendation refers to
“preventative spending on the crucial early years”,
which I absolutely agree with. We need to do that and more. The second recommendation refers to
“Building relationships between families, schools and communities”,
which I would have said is axiomatic and which is being done. The third recommendation refers to
“engendering a positive and welcoming atmosphere in preschool and school settings.”
I go to lots of schools and pre-schools and can say that they have a positive and welcoming atmosphere. I am glad that that is now recognised by Labour. The fourth recommendation refers to
“high quality, flexible and affordable childcare”.
That requires, in the end, the full powers of independence. I could go on.
We are doing a great deal. I would be delighted to do it cross-party. If we could do it cross-party, then we would do everything that we could do but there would still be a gap to close: the gap of poverty. That gap gets closed once this Parliament has the powers of a normal, independent Parliament.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 14 May 2014 →- Education and Lifelong Learning Questions · 1
- Attainment Gap Questions · 6
- Mental Health Problems (School Pupils) Questions · 6
- Additional Support Needs (Increase) Questions · 6
- Horizon 2020 (Universities) Questions · 4
- Gaelic-medium Schools (Speech and Language Therapy) Questions · 4
- University Estate (Investment Plans) Questions · 4
- Curriculum for Excellence (Scots) Questions · 4
- Independence (Universities) Questions · 6
- Rural Schools (Supply Teachers) Questions · 4
- Childcare Support (Parents Returning to Education, Training or Employment) Questions · 9
- Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics Studies (Impact of Decreasing Numeracy) Questions · 9
- Independence (University Research Funding) Questions · 8
- European Union Membership (Benefits to Education Sector) Questions · 4
- Erasmus+ Questions · 4
- Independence (Research Councils UK Network) Questions · 12
- Educational Attainment Gap Questions · 6
- “Time to Shine” Youth Arts Strategy Debate · 51
- Business Motions Business motions · 2
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 3
- Loneliness (Impact on Physical and Mental Health) Members’ business · 7
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.