I very much welcome the opportunity to discuss palliative and end-of-life care. I particularly welcome Marie Curie’s latest report, on changing the conversation on terminal illness, together with the important research on access to palliative care that has been carried out on behalf of the charity by the London School of Economics. I am also grateful to colleagues across the political divide who have enabled the debate to take place.
Defined as the active, holistic care of people with advanced, progressive illness, involving the management of pain and other symptoms and the provision of psychological, social and spiritual support, palliative care would clearly benefit very many people as they approach the end of their lives, not just those with terminal cancer, which is the condition that is most commonly diagnosed in those who actually receive that form of care. However, many people in the United Kingdom who would derive benefit from palliative care are either not offered it or receive it for only a very short time before they die.
The current facts are stark and indicate why positive action needs to be taken to support people who are living with a terminal illness, and their families, if they are to be sure of getting the care that they need as their condition progresses. Of the 54,000 people who die in Scotland each year, it is estimated that between 35,000 and 40,000 should have some palliative care. However, the LSE study for Marie Curie found that nearly 11,000 people who need such care are not receiving it and that only one in five people with a non-cancer diagnosis is identified for palliative care. The research further identified that carers across the UK claim that seven out of every 10 people with a terminal illness do not get all the care and support that they need and that a quarter of cancer patients are not receiving palliative care.
The specific groups of people who are less likely to be considered for palliative care are those aged over 85, those who live alone, those from black, Asian and minority ethnic communities and those who live in areas of deprivation. That is simply not good enough and indicates significant inequity of provision—a problem that will undoubtedly get worse as our population ages unless action is taken urgently to address the situation.
At present, a third of the patients in Scottish hospitals are in their last year of life and half of Scotland’s deaths occur in hospital, even though most people’s preference is to die at home or in a homely setting; we are already well short of providing the end-of-life care that most people seek. Given the predicted 13 per cent increase in deaths over the next 25 years and the fact that many of us who live well into advanced old age will have multiple and complex health problems such as dementia, heart failure, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease or the complications of diabetes or long-term obesity, there is a clear and urgent need for the conversation about terminal care that is recommended by Marie Curie.
We should acknowledge that people with all types of terminal disease, not just those with cancer, can benefit from palliative care, which, ideally, should be planned for from the point of diagnosis of the terminal nature of the illness so that an appropriate care pathway is in place as the condition progresses and that care can be delivered within the community, in a hospice or, when necessary, in hospital.
A significant amount of work remains to be done if we are to achieve a gold standard of palliative care for the maximum number of patients who require it. There has to be a conversation among policy makers, health and social care professionals, service planners and communities about the sort of care and support that we want to give people with terminal illness when their needs are becoming more complex, are often not being met and are likely to grow in number.
At the outset, health and social care professionals should be prepared to speak openly and honestly to patients and their families and carers about the terminal nature of their illness, and to help them to plan their care pathway by letting them know what services will be available to them and enabling them to make decisions that will help them as their condition progresses. Many health professionals and many families are uncomfortable about having conversations that acknowledge that death for their patient or relative is inevitable sooner rather than later although, depending on the condition and treatment, terminally ill people may live for days, weeks, months or even years after the diagnosis is made.
We need to try to change the culture in Scotland and to encourage more open discussion about death. People seem to be happy enough to make a will and there is growing discussion about organ donation, but there is still a barrier when it comes to acknowledging impending death. Professionals need to be given training and support to ensure that they can give high-quality, person-focused care to people with terminal illness, and better links need to be developed between generalists and specialists such as cardiologists, neurologists and those who specialise in palliative care.
As integrated health and social care develops, the new integrated boards should look to have palliative care at the heart of their strategic plans, because ineffective co-ordination of care between services such as health and social care or general and out-of-hours practice, and between different organisations, can lead to unnecessary delays in care and support. Despite the shortcomings in gaining access to it, palliative care in Scotland is recognised as being of a high standard, but we need to make more progress in achieving equitable access to good-quality terminal care for all patients who require it.
Marie Curie has several suggestions for the Government that it thinks will move things forward. It recommends that a reference to terminal illness, dying and death should be included in the Government’s planned revision of its 2020 vision document for Scotland; that palliative care should be an early priority for integration, as I have just described; that, in the new strategic framework for action on palliative and end-of-life care, which is due to be published later on this year, there should be a clear commitment to ensuring that everyone with a need for palliative care has access to it by 2020; that robust data is collected to measure progress and the experience of patients and their families; that training and support are given to health and social care professionals to deliver effective care for people who are terminally ill; and that a clear resource commitment is made to achieve the aims and objectives of the strategy.
We live in a time when more and more people are living into healthy and active old age, thanks largely to modern developments in medical techniques and pharmaceutical products, but all of us are mortal and, sooner or later, many of us will require palliative or end-of-life care. Some will require it earlier in life if they suffer from a congenital or degenerative neurological or other chronic condition or malignancy, while others will need it much later as a result of diseases that I have already mentioned. I would like to think that, in the foreseeable future, we can achieve a high standard of such care for everyone who needs it, whatever their personal circumstances and wherever they live in Scotland. As well as being desirable, that should be cost-effective. The Nuffield Trust estimates that savings of £500 per person could potentially be made by enabling people at the end of life to be cared for at home or in the community.
I look forward to the debate and to the minister’s response, and I hope that everyone agrees that high-quality, accessible palliative care is what we all wish to achieve and what we should be striving for.
17:09