Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

National Parks Strategy (PE1556)

Tuesday 28 April 2015 Public Petitions Committee About 10:00–10:30 Petitions 50 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

50 contributions
John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Good morning, everyone, and welcome to the ninth meeting in 2015 of the Public Petitions Committee. I remind everyone to switch off their mobile phones and other electronic devices as they might interfere with the sound system.

We have received apologies from David Torrance.

Item 1 is consideration of three new petitions. The committee will hear from each petitioner. Unfortunately, the first petitioner has been delayed, so we will move to PE1556, by John Mayhew, on behalf of the Scottish Campaign for National Parks and the Association for the Protection of Rural Scotland, on a national parks strategy for Scotland. Members have a note by the clerk and the Scottish Parliament information centre briefing.

I welcome the petitioner, John Mayhew. He is accompanied by John Thomson from the SCNP and Charles Millar from the APRS. I invite Mr Mayhew to speak to his petition for up to five minutes, and we will then move on to questions.

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

Thank you for inviting us to give evidence today. As you say, convener, I am joined by Charles Millar, the chairman of APRS, and John Thomson, the honorary secretary of SCNP. They represent each of the organisations that form the partnership that has lodged the petition.

I will give the committee a quick recap of the historical background to show how we arrived at where we are today. Our two organisations campaigned for many decades to have national parks in Scotland, and we were successful with the passing of the National Parks (Scotland) Act 2000 and the establishment of the first two national parks in 2002 and 2003. Since then, we have argued for more.

We started a more formal joint project in 2010, which culminated in our report “Unfinished Business: A National Parks Strategy for Scotland”, which I think all members have just been handed a copy of; I have certainly given copies to the clerk for you. The report sets out our case in full.

If I were to summarise our case, I would say that it comes back to Scotland’s landscapes, which are among the best in the world. Despite that, we have only two national parks. National park status is recognised across the world as the best way of protecting and designating our best landscapes. The first two national parks have achieved a great deal in their first decade. They inspire pride and passion among local people and visitors. However, other outstanding landscapes in Scotland are also worthy of national park designation and there is local and national public support for that. Having more national parks would bring additional resources to those areas, strengthen Scotland’s international standing in environmental protection and support our crucial tourism industry.

We have made some good progress, but we feel that Scotland is now lagging behind other parts of the United Kingdom in national park designation. For example, 7 per cent of Scotland is covered by national parks compared with 20 per cent of Wales. We feel that we are missing out on the benefits and opportunities that more national parks could bring, which is why the Scottish Government should prepare a strategy to designate more national parks.

As the note that the committee has been given observes, debates on the subject were held in Parliament in 2008, 2009 and 2013. Many members of the Scottish Parliament praised the work of the two existing national parks and some MSPs called for more to be designated.

We also have local support. We are pleased to note that many of the 1,000 or so people who signed our petition are residents of the areas that we have identified as being suitable for national park status, and many of them made supportive comments. In 2008, a clear majority of the residents of Harris voted for national park status in a referendum, but it has not come to pass.

We are in touch with local supporters in several areas who are keen to work with us. We feel that consideration of more national parks could support the current efforts by the Parliament and the Government to promote community empowerment.

We feel that national parks bring real benefits to Scotland. Obviously, there are environmental benefits through the protection of landscapes and habitats, but there are also socioeconomic benefits such as job creation and benefits for the tourism industry. We have been working a bit more on the socioeconomic benefits and we recently published a report called “The Socio-economic Benefits of New National Park Designations in Scotland”, which I can leave with the committee. It sets out what we think the benefits are in rather more detail.

Our proposals are widely supported by other organisations including, for example, the National Trust for Scotland and the Scottish Wildlife Trust, so although we are leading the campaign, plenty of others agree with us.

Turning to possible action, I note your clerks’ suggestion that you might consider writing to the Scottish Government and to Scottish Natural Heritage about the issue. If you felt that that was appropriate, we would certainly support it, as that would help to generate the sort of debate that we seek on the issue.

That is all that I have to say for now. We are all very happy to answer any questions.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Thank you very much, Mr Mayhew. I will start the questions. Which areas would you highlight as candidates for national parks and what arguments are there in favour of those areas?

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

If members have the “Unfinished Business” report in front of them, they will see that, on page 28, there is a map that summarises that most clearly. When we wrote the report, we were really setting out the principal argument that there should be more national parks and that it is the Government’s place to carry out an assessment and prepare a strategy on where those places might be and in which order they should be designated. However, we also felt that we needed to put our cards on the table and say where we thought the national parks should be. Therefore, after long discussions in our organisations, we highlighted seven possible areas that we feel all have fantastic habitats and wildlife and that would benefit from the additional input and integrated management that national park status can bring.

Those are our seven proposed areas, and we would be delighted if any of them was designated as a national park. However, we are non-Government organisations, and that is merely our proposal, so the map has no official status at all; it is simply born out of long experience and knowledge of the areas concerned.

Hanzala Malik Lab Glasgow
link

I have three small questions. First, who funded the publication?

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

The funders are listed on the inside front cover. It was a range of charitable trusts. We carried out some fundraising beforehand. As well as funding the report, that funded the research and consultancy work that led up to it.

Hanzala Malik Lab Glasgow
link

My second question is about the Isle of Harris. You said that you have not been able to convince the Scottish Government on that. What was the Scottish Government’s reaction to that particular proposal?

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

My memory of what happened at the time is that the local people of Harris set up a group called the Isle of Harris national park study group, which commissioned research, carried out a feasibility study and organised a referendum, which, as I said, ended up with a clear majority of people voting and a clear majority in favour. The group then sought the support of its local authority—Western Isles Council—to help its case. The council carried out quite a bit of research, including seeking evidence and carrying out site visits. Ultimately, the debate that took place in the full council was inconclusive, so the council agreed neither to support nor oppose the proposal, but to pass the decision to the Scottish Government.

The Scottish Government at the time was not willing to proceed without local authority support. However, the National Parks (Scotland) Act 2000 does not say that a proposal has to have local authority support. Obviously, it is preferable if it has that, but there is no legal requirement for it.

I ask John Thomson whether I have remembered that correctly.

John Thomson Scottish Campaign for National Parks
link

Yes, that is certainly my recollection of the matter. I will make one further comment on local authorities. I think that there is only one case in the UK of the creation of a national park having been favoured by the local authority. Interestingly, that was the Loch Lomond and the Trossachs national park, which had a history as a regional park that had been set up by the local authorities in the first place. Local authorities’ opposition to the establishment of national parks is a well-established tradition.

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

During the debate on the Western Isles proposal, some Western Isles councillors were not in favour of the designation because they felt that it would prevent development. In our view, they were wrong—we feel that national parks support sustainable and appropriate development and do not prevent development, but that was their perception. Other councillors queried why the proposal was limited to Harris and suggested that Lewis or the whole of the Western Isles should be included. There were boundary issues as well as issues of principle. That is a very brief summary of my memory of that debate.

Hanzala Malik Lab Glasgow
link

My third question is about the commitment in the SNP’s manifesto. In the report, you have gone as far as 2013, but we are in 2015. Has there been any progress or do you feel that the Government is sitting on its hands on the issue?

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

As far as I am aware, there has not been any progress on implementing that manifesto commitment, which is quoted in the report. It states that the SNP will

“work with communities to explore the creation of new national parks.”

We welcomed that commitment, as we thought that it was entirely appropriate for the Government to “work with communities” rather than say that it would create more national parks. However, as far as I am aware, there has not been any progress on that. That is disappointing for us, and we will ask all the political parties to put a commitment to more national parks in their manifestos for the election in a year’s time.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Why do you think local authorities are opposed to national parks? Is it because they might prevent future development in the areas?

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

I will answer first and will then ask my colleagues whether they have anything to add. It is not so much what you suggest. Local authorities sometimes fear loss of power, control or influence, particularly over planning. Although national parks are not just about planning, a lot of the controversial debates that take place in national parks—as in other parts of Scotland—are to do with planning applications and proposed developments. Local authorities are used to being the planning authorities for their areas, and when a national park is set up, those planning powers can be transferred to the national park authority or can stay with the local authority. The 2000 act is commendable in that it is flexible and provides different governance models.

In the Loch Lomond and the Trossachs national park, there is a full planning authority that makes the forward plans and also determines planning applications. The situation is different in the Cairngorms national park, where the local authorities have retained planning powers. That was negotiated at the time of the park’s creation, when the local authorities were unwilling to give up—as they saw it—those planning powers. Nevertheless, the national park authority has a right to call in for its own determination any applications that it feels are concerned with the special qualities of the national park. Small householder extensions to individual dwellings would clearly be the province of the local authorities, but an application for a major housing development, hotel or recreational development would clearly be relevant to the national park authority and it would call that application in.

The concerns revolve around planning, but there are ways in which local authorities can still be involved in planning in the national parks. Indeed, under the legislation, the majority of the board members are either representatives of the local authorities or directly elected local people, as is right. Therefore, even if planning powers are transferred, the people who hold those powers are predominantly local residents.

I will just check with my colleagues whether I have missed anything.

Charles Millar Association for the Protection of Rural Scotland
link

No, you have captured the situation.

John Thomson Scottish Campaign for National Parks
link

I would just add that, as we mention in the report, there is a distinction to be drawn between national parks that lie wholly within the territory of a single local authority—that was the case with the proposed Harris national park—and those that straddle the boundaries of more than one local authority, as the two existing national parks do. Although straddling boundaries can give rise to some problems, one can see the justification for a separate national park authority more readily where that applies than where the national park lies within the territory of a single local authority.

We address that issue in the report and make the point, which is important in the Scottish context, that there is flexibility in the legislation to enable the precise governance arrangements to be tailored to the circumstances of a particular area. We therefore see the arrangements for somewhere such as Harris as being rather different from those that apply in Loch Lomond and the Trossachs.

10:15

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I want to explore two themes, the first of which touches on the issue that you highlighted in your previous response; indeed, you might well have covered it already. As you have said, we have been slower to evolve national parks in Scotland. Because they have evolved elsewhere and internationally, there might be an expectation in the public mind of what a national park is. Might the wholly variable and flexible arrangement that you referred to be, in fact, an obstacle, in that it could create complications and variations and raise expectations in people’s minds with regard to what is meant by the term “national park”, only for their support and will to be lost along the way when the arrangement turns out to be complicated to implement?

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

The term means different things to different people across the world, but the crucial advantage of what I suppose we would call the brand is that it is recognised worldwide. It is the only designation that everyone in the world has heard of. If I went on holiday to, say, Italy, I would seek out the national parks to visit because, in my experience, they are likely to be spectacular places with wonderful wildlife and, crucially, they will have a system for warmly welcoming visitors and helping them to get the most out of their visit. The same applies to visitors to Scotland. When people come to Scotland, they ask, “Where are the national parks?” and then they head for the Cairngorms and Loch Lomond and the Trossachs. That is wonderful, but we would like the benefits to be spread to other places that merit them.

We have to remember the basic concept of a national park: it is a special area and should be managed in a special way. It is worthy of extra national resources, and all the complexities of managing it are subsidiary to the basic idea that it is an internationally famous place that Scotland can be proud of, that we are really trying our best to look after it and the people who live there and that we welcome visitors to it.

People have different expectations and understandings of the term “national park” across the world, but there are reasons for that. It is important that we remember the basic principle.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

So the interpretation of the term varies a lot. If I needed, say, a keyhole gall bladder operation, I would probably get the same thing all over the world, but a national park can be different, depending on the circumstances.

What financial model underpins national parks, particularly the two that we already have? By extension, have the national parks and the model that they operate under been successful? What financial model ought to underpin national parks, and is it politically controversial and an obstacle to their establishment?

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

The national parks in Scotland are 100 per cent funded by the Scottish Government in recognition of their national importance. I like to say that they are nationally funded but locally controlled.

The majority of the authority that runs the national park, takes the decisions and approves the national park plan is, as I said, made up of local councillors and directly elected local people, but there are also national appointees to represent the national funding and the national interest. I therefore do not think that the model is an obstacle, but the provision of the money might well be, because the proposal would involve additional expenditure. That is a matter for the Scottish Government to determine amongst its other priorities.

We would say that this is relatively good value for money. The joint budget for the two existing national parks is approximately £13 million a year—

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

It has been broadly consistent, but I should point out that the national park authorities are also very good at adopting what they call shovel-ready projects. They always have, say, a visitor centre that they would like to build or a village hall that they would like to do up, and, in my experience, if the Government finds some extra money towards the end of the financial year or from some unspent pot, the national park authorities are the first to put up their hands and say, “We can spend that money to benefit our local area.”

I stress the point that John Thomson made, which is that future national parks are more likely to be wholly within one local authority area and to be smaller in scale and expenditure than the two existing ones, which are quite large and complex and involved arrangements among three or five local authorities to bring them together. The ones that we propose would either be wholly within an existing local authority area or, at the most, shared between two local authorities. They would generally be smaller in area and population, so their budgets would probably be substantially lower than those for the existing national parks.

For example, a feasibility study that was done in 2008 for a Harris national park reckoned that it could be run for approximately £1 million a year. Please do not think that, just because the two existing national parks cost about £13 million a year to run—although we think that that is good value—additional expenditure of that order would be required for every other national park.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Thank you, Mr Mayhew, for the copy of your report. Unfortunately, it arrived in front of us just as we sat down. It will be useful to have a good read through it. I would also be interested in getting a copy of the socioeconomic report that you have produced in relation to national parks, to see the benefits that it suggests.

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

We will send you a copy.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Jackson Carlaw asked about Scottish Government funding for the existing national parks. During your opening remarks, you referred to additional resources coming into the designated areas. Are you talking about additional resources coming solely from the Scottish Government or from other areas? It would be useful to understand whether a designation would rely solely on Scottish Government funding being made available.

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

Again, I will give you a quick answer and invite comments from my colleagues.

Predominantly, I mean additional Scottish Government resources coming in to the areas in recognition of their national importance for wildlife, landscape, recreation, tourism and so on. However, national park authorities in Scotland and elsewhere have proved themselves adroit at putting together project funding proposals that lever in funding from elsewhere—for example, from the Heritage Lottery Fund or the European Union. They are quite good at doing that. National funding from the Scottish Government could act as seedcorn funding to bring in other funding. Obtaining funding in that way is not unique to national parks. I acknowledge that local authorities and other agencies can do it as well, but it is something that national park authorities have shown that they are able to do.

My colleagues might want to add to those comments.

John Thomson Scottish Campaign for National Parks
link

I will add a point on why national parks are able to do that. What a national park has that a lot of other designations—for example, the geoparks that we have in some parts of the Highlands—do not have is dedicated staff who are employed, in effect, on a permanent basis. That means that there are people there who are in a position not only to get to know the area, its needs and the opportunities there but to go out and seek the additional funding that we are talking about. That is critical, because if there is short-term funding for the staff themselves, as there is in quite a lot of the other designations, they spend most of their time looking for money to support the continuation of their posts beyond the two or three years for which they have been appointed in the first instance. Having a small body of core staff with a reasonable degree of permanence is critical to being able to generate a lot of wider benefits.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Thank you for that response, Mr Thomson. One of the reasons the Scottish Government has given for not creating more national parks is the financial issue of revenue and capital funding in the context of the reduction in the Scottish budget since 2008. It would be useful to know whether there have been any discussions with the Scottish Government about the provision of what Mr Mayhew described as seedcorn funding to allow national parks to be created and to allow new national park authorities to seek resources from elsewhere. A number of charitable organisations such as the Big Lottery Fund might be prepared to invest in and fund projects if an area was designated as a national park, which could reduce the financial burden on the Scottish Government and allow us to achieve what you seek to achieve through your petition.

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

That is a positive proposal. The things that cost money from revenue and capital funding are the creation of the national park authority, the employment of staff and the finding and running of premises. At this stage, we are calling for the preparation of a strategy on whether we should have more national parks and, if so, where they should be. I am not so naive as to believe that that would cost nothing, but the work would cost comparatively little because it would be carried out broadly by officials within existing staff time.

We see that as a priority. It is up to the Scottish Government to assess the proposal against its other priorities, but the preparation of a strategy, which is what we seek, could be done at relatively low cost and could feed into the sort of model that you propose.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

You have already done some work for the report that you produced. If the Government took that forward, it would greatly assist it in coming to some conclusions about the best way forward for the creation of more national parks.

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

Yes. We very much hope that our report will be considered as a positive contribution to any future debate.

Charles Millar Association for the Protection of Rural Scotland
link

That also applies to the report that we produced on the socioeconomic benefits and further reports on the theme that we have in the pipeline.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Will you tell us about those other reports? We have “Unfinished Business: A National Parks Strategy for Scotland”, but you mentioned a socioeconomic report. What other reports are in the pipeline that might be of interest to the committee and the Parliament and might help to influence the Scottish Government to move on the matter?

From the Ramsay report in 1945 right through to the present day, including the example of Harris, there has been a clear indication by the general public that people would like more national parks to be created, but there seems to be a reluctance to move the agenda forward in Scotland. I am talking not just about the present Government but about previous Governments. It would be useful to know what other reports you intend to commission and take forward that will help with the wider debate and with getting national parks established.

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

Indeed. We stand by “Unfinished Business: A National Parks Strategy for Scotland” as our principal report and the main summary of our case. Since it was published, we have been thinking about what I could call subsidiary topic papers or issues papers on specific aspects of the debate. The paper on socioeconomic benefits is the first of those, and I will make that available to all of you. The other two papers that we are considering publishing are on governance models and the importance of national parks to the tourism industry.

In the governance report, we try to unpick to a certain extent something that we have talked about this morning—possible models for national parks. A national park in Scotland does not need a £10 million budget, 50 staff and a board of 23 people; it could have a £1 million budget, five staff and a board that is a sub-committee of a local authority. It would still be a national park under the 2000 act because that legislation is so flexible. We are going to propose that, and we are particularly keen to stress the tourism benefits that national parks bring. As well as bringing job creation and financial benefits to an area, they have benefits in providing a service to visitors to Scotland.

John Thomson Scottish Campaign for National Parks
link

Although we do not have a firm plan for doing so at present, another area that we might wish to cover is the role of national parks in planning, based on the experience of existing national parks both in Scotland and elsewhere. There is a perception that the chances of getting permission for a development are significantly lower in a national park than elsewhere, but that is not borne out by the experience, which suggests that the success rate is pretty much the same and possibly even a bit higher in a national park. However, that does not necessarily mean that someone will get permission for quite what they would get permission for elsewhere, because there is a role for the national park in guiding people who have developments in mind to ensure that those developments are, in quality and character, appropriate to the park.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh Eastern
link

It has flippantly been suggested that almost all of Scotland could be a national park. You have suggested an additional seven national parks. Is there an optimum or maximum number of national parks? Do you see any detriment to areas that are adjacent to national parks or to areas that may be equally scenic but are not, or would not be, classified as such?

10:30

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

We feel that anything up to seven would be the right number, which is why we suggested that, although even one more national park would be wonderful.

It could be argued that the place that always comes up in the expert reports but that has not yet been designated is the Ben Nevis-Glencoe-Black Mount area. It could also be argued that there is a strong case for having a national park in the south of Scotland, because this is not just a Highlands and Islands issue. That would point towards Galloway or the Cheviots. It could be argued that the place where there is clear and proven local support is Harris and that, therefore, that should be the next national park. I could make a case for any one of the seven areas.

Regarding the maximum number, there would come a point at which the benefits that we have described would cease to apply. We feel that additional benefits could be brought to those places with more national parks, but the argument against designating the whole of Scotland or the whole of the north-west as a national park is that it would dilute those benefits so much that it would not be worth doing. We have said that there should be at least seven new national parks. We would not rule out any more, but that is heading towards the maximum number for the reason that I have set out.

The issue of the areas around national parks is crucial. For example, if a national park excludes certain types of development that it considers inappropriate, it is possible to imagine that those developments are more likely to take place in the areas around the national park. It could equally be argued—studies in the north of England have shown this—that national parks bring benefits to areas that are just outside them, as people who are engaged in fishing, cycling, golf or whatever in the national park might stay in towns and villages that are outside the national park. That brings benefits not just to the area within the boundary but also to what might be called the gateway communities. Once you start designating an area for anything, you immediately come up with boundary issues. However, if you accept—as our society has—that some places are more special than others, for reasons to do with the landscape, wildlife or cultural heritage, it is more important to designate those areas and to manage them positively than it is to worry about the boundary effects.

The boundary effects have to be tackled, and the existing national park authorities have been working with communities just outwith their boundaries to ensure that the disadvantages are minimised. In any case, I think that the advantages outweigh any disadvantages.

John Thomson Scottish Campaign for National Parks
link

On the issue of whether there is a ceiling on how many national parks there should be, I think that it is better to think in terms not of the number of parks but of the proportion of the land area of the country. That goes back to something that John Mayhew said in his introductory remarks.

It is generally recognised that the landscapes in Scotland are, by international standards, of a very high quality. Therefore, people would expect the proportion of national parks in Scotland to be at least equal to what it is in Wales. If we put the national parks in Wales together with the areas of outstanding national beauty, which are of similar landscape quality although they have slightly different arrangements for management, we are talking about roughly 25 per cent of the country. Funnily enough, the proportion is roughly similar in England. It is not unreasonable to say that we might be talking about something like a quarter of the land in Scotland.

My second point concerns what John Mayhew said about the surrounding areas. If our national parks are dotted quite widely around the country, people will have to travel through lots of other parts of the country to reach them and, when they do that, they will realise just how good those other parts are. Having magnets dotted around like that would be a way of promoting the rest of the country as well.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

You mentioned the management structures in Wales. Did you say that the national park management structures in Wales are different from those in Scotland?

John Thomson Scottish Campaign for National Parks
link

No. There are marginal differences, but they are essentially the same. I was talking about the management structures of the areas of outstanding natural beauty, which are more like our national scenic areas. They have different arrangements. They are more clearly local government controlled, but they have real management structures that we do not have for the national scenic areas in Scotland, with the exception of the three in Dumfries and Galloway. We are currently being quite heavily criticised for that by some of the international organisations that are concerned with these issues.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

The Scottish Government has said that it has no current plans to designate further national parks in Scotland. Is that because you have been unable to convince it that national parks should be seen as opportunities rather than obstacles? Might you have some other work to do?

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

I really wish that I knew why the Scottish Government does not want to designate more national parks. Obviously, we are committed to and passionate about the subject, but we have not convinced the Government. However, we will carry on trying to do so, because that is what campaigning organisations do. It would be worth hearing from the Government why it has not agreed to do that.

The reasons that we were given most recently are, I think, mentioned in the committee’s papers. One is to do with concerns about financial commitments. That is a matter for Government spending priorities and we think that national parks are a priority. The other reason is that the Government does not wish to raise expectations in wider areas about a process whereby not everywhere will end up being a national park. However, we feel that it is good for a Government to raise expectations of something positive happening. Most people understand that, if expectations are raised about something happening, it might not happen in every area.

We do not think that either of those reasons is a good reason for failing to move forward, but we clearly have work to do in continuing to try to persuade the Government. That is why we submitted the petition and sought support for it and it is why we are pleased to be able to discuss it with the committee.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

In connection with the previous question, it might be worth pointing out that, in the most recent debate in the Parliament on the issue, which was in May last year, the Scottish Government suggested that it would be preferable to concentrate on the two existing national parks, given the current financial climate. However, it did not rule out a further designation in the future.

I have been skimming through the “Unfinished Business” document. Section 6 states:

“In 2009 the Scottish Government announced that it would establish a ministerially chaired National Parks Strategy Group”,

which has not materialised yet. Have you had an indication from the Scottish Government of why that has not happened yet?

John Mayhew Scottish National Parks Strategy Project
link

I am sorry, but we have not. All that we know is what is in one of the papers that the clerk has helpfully provided to the committee. The paper quotes the minister’s reply, in 2010, that the group’s establishment had been delayed

“until after the next spending review.”—Written Answers, 23 June 2010; S3W-34567.

We have not heard anything since then.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

As there are no further questions, I ask members what action they seek to take on the petition.

Hanzala Malik Lab Glasgow
link

I am keen to ascertain why the Scottish Government has not taken any action despite a manifesto commitment and, more important, what is preventing the Scottish Government from participating. I do not want to criticise the Scottish Government, but the issue is important so we need to try to find ways of moving forward. If the Scottish Government has an issue with resourcing, perhaps we can explore possibilities of finding the resource elsewhere and allow volunteer groups to assist the Government in identifying resources so that we can physically move forward. To drag our feet for such a long time is unhelpful at best.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

I agree that we should write to the Scottish Government to find out what is happening. In particular, we should ask what happened to the national parks strategy group that was part of the recommendations from 2009. We are now six years on and it would be useful to find out where the Scottish Government is on that.

We should ask the Scottish Government about the sustainability of the existing national parks. If there is an issue about revenue and capital funding, it would be useful to get an indication of the Government’s views on sustainable development and the sustainable future of the national park authorities in Scotland. We have heard evidence today that a national park could be set up for £1 million—that was Mr Mayhew’s figure—which is a lot less than the £13 million that is being spent on the national parks at present.

We should also write to a number of organisations that might be interested and that could assist us in taking forward the debate. I declare an interest in a couple of them. They are the Scottish Wildlife Trust, the John Muir Trust, RSPB Scotland, NFU Scotland and the Scottish landowners association. They all have a role, as do many others, in trying to determine the best areas to be designated as national parks. That goes back to my earlier point that a number of organisations can bring resources with them. Additional resources, over and above what the Scottish Government might contribute, would help to deliver more national parks in Scotland.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

I agree that we should write on the points that have been raised. We should also write to SNH, the Scottish Campaign for National Parks and the Association for the Protection of Rural Scotland. I also suggest that we write to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee, just to keep it advised and informed about the petition.

Do members agree to the suggestions?

Members indicated agreement.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

I thank Mr Mayhew, Mr Thomson and Mr Millar for attending.

I suspend the meeting for a couple of minutes to allow a changeover of witnesses.

10:41 Meeting suspended.

10:43 On resuming—

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 50
  2. 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 35
  3. 11:15 New Petitions Petitions · 57
  4. 11:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  5. 11:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
  6. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 20
  7. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  8. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  9. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  10. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.