Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 23 April 2015 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 14 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

14 contributions
Kezia Dugdale Lab Lothian
link

This is my first opportunity in the chamber to pay tribute to Tom McCabe, who made such a contribution to the Parliament and to Scotland. I know that I speak for the whole chamber when I say that he will be sorely missed by members of all parties.

To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02736)

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

I, too, take the opportunity on behalf of my colleagues to pay tribute to the late Tom McCabe. He was the first member to be elected to this Parliament in 1999. He was a distinguished member and minister. Above all else, he was a fantastic human being. He will be missed across the chamber, not least by his Labour Party colleagues. He will be particularly missed by his family. Our thoughts and condolences are with them at this time.

Later today, I have engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Kezia Dugdale Lab Lothian
link

Today’s Edinburgh Evening News exposes the Scottish National Party’s parliamentary candidate for Edinburgh South, Neil Hay, as an anonymous troll who described the majority of Scots as traitors. I am sure that the First Minister will rightly condemn that. I note that Mr Hay has apologised, but that is not enough. Will the First Minister sack Neil Hay as the SNP’s candidate?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

First, Kezia Dugdale is right: I condemn the language used and the comments made, as I always do when anyone steps out of line on Twitter, Facebook or any other medium. Neil Hay has rightly apologised. Given that we face an election two weeks today, it is up to the voters to decide.

I wonder whether Kezia Dugdale agrees with me that it is important that we all condemn intemperate statements on Twitter, regardless of where they come from. On 4 April, a senior Labour activist described the SNP as “Fascist scum”. For completeness, will Kezia Dugdale tells us what action Labour took against that activist?

Kezia Dugdale Lab Lothian
link

If the First Minister had told me who that was, I would have been delighted to respond. [Interruption.] No, hang on a second—she has not spelled out exactly who that was. I take the matter very seriously. I will talk to her after First Minister’s questions, because it would be hypocritical of me not to react to what she says and I will do so with due consideration. I hope that she will take that seriously.

The First Minister’s condemnation of Neil Hay is welcome, but it does not go far enough. We are talking about a man who is categorically challenging the right of pensioners to vote. [Interruption.] I am afraid that he is—just look at the detail of his tweets. I encourage the SNP back benchers to take just a minute to look at what he said. He is challenging the right of pensioners to vote in the general election.

In recent weeks, the First Minister has had to apologise to victims of online abuse by her supporters. She has apologised to James Cook of the BBC, to Faisal Islam of Sky News and to a young television debate audience member who happened to say that she liked what the Labour Party had to say. Rather than simply empathising with the victims, she needs to show leadership and take on the perpetrators. That should start with the sacking of Neil Hay.

It is clear that the First Minister has a problem with words. Her candidate in Edinburgh calls more than half of Scotland’s population traitors. At the last First Minister’s questions, Nicola Sturgeon could not even bring herself to utter the words “full fiscal autonomy”. I know that she does not agree with the assessment of the Institute for Fiscal Studies—earlier this week, she described it as “academic”. Will she confirm when the SNP will publish its own costings of full fiscal autonomy for Scotland?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

Bear with me while I try to work my way through that diatribe of utter nonsense from the Labour Party.

I find myself wondering, two weeks out from polling day, whether we will ever get to a stage in the campaign when Labour tries to give the Scottish public a single positive reason for voting for it. Is it ever going to move on from “SNP bad”? Perhaps Labour should reflect on the fact that it is such conduct and behaviour that is leaving it lagging in the opinion polls.

As Kezia Dugdale outlined quite well in the first part of her rather complex question, I lead by example when it comes to calling out behaviour that I consider to be unacceptable, and I will always do that, regardless of who that unacceptable behaviour comes from. In the case of Neil Hay, I am doing it today. He has apologised and the voters get the chance to cast their verdict two weeks today.

In direct response to Kezia Dugdale’s question, the senior Labour activist to whom I was referring is Ian Smart. He appears regularly on television for Labour, putting across the Labour case. He described us as

“The heirs of Arthur Donaldson ... Fascist scum then. Fascist scum forever.”

That was on 4 April. It was not the first time that he has made such remarks. Again, before Kezia Dugdale lectures me on what she expects me to do about SNP members, I politely suggest to her that she puts her own house in order.

On Kezia Dugdale’s point about full fiscal autonomy—there, I have said it—Scotland’s fiscal position, when we become fiscally autonomous, will depend on a number of things. It will depend on our economic performance between now and then. It will depend on the detail of a fiscal framework that will be agreed to determine Scotland’s contributions to continued reserved responsibilities. It will depend on the treatment of taxes that, under a devolved settlement, cannot be devolved, such as VAT and excise duties. However, as I go round the country talking to voters, that is not what they are asking me about. They are asking what is going to happen now, this year, next year and the year after, and I am able to tell them that I want real-terms spending increases in every year of the next Parliament. Labour is boasting that it will make cuts, so perhaps Kezia Dugdale will take the opportunity to tell us today how many cuts, how many billions and where the axe is going to fall under Labour.

Kezia Dugdale Lab Lothian
link

The difference is that Neil Hay passed the SNP’s vetting procedure. Neil Hay is on the ballot paper. [Interruption.]

Kezia Dugdale Lab Lothian
link

I take what the First Minister has said about Ian Smart very seriously indeed, but Neil Hay is on the ballot paper, and I will not take any lectures from the First Minister about the conduct and behaviour of SNP activists.

On the issue of full fiscal autonomy, it is quite clear that the First Minister did not like the question, but she owes the people of Scotland an honest answer, because we know that the SNP’s plans to cut Scotland off from United Kingdom-wide taxes would mean an end to the UK state pension for Scotland. Here is the thing. On page 5 of the SNP’s manifesto, it claims to back UK-wide taxes such as the mansion tax, yet on page 11 it supports ending UK-wide taxes. It beggars belief.

We know that the SNP’s plans for full fiscal autonomy would mean massive austerity, but we know that the plan for UK-wide spending would mean the same, because this morning the impartial experts at the IFS said that the SNP will impose austerity for longer than any other party and that, under the SNP, the block grant for Scotland will be cut. Can the First Minister tell us why she wants to keep austerity going?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

It is genuinely quite difficult to take Labour or Kezia Dugdale seriously when they come to the chamber and utter phrases such as, “The SNP wants to end the state pension.” That is not just insulting the SNP; that is insulting the intelligence of every person in the country. If anybody wants a reason, crystallised in a nutshell, why Scottish Labour is dying before our very eyes, there it is.

I will continue to campaign in this election on a clear, consistent position. I do not want to see cuts over the next Parliament. I want what it says in the summary of the IFS report that was published this morning—increases in real terms in spending in each and every year. That is my position.

Since this Parliament last met, we have seen Labour trying to pretend that it did not want cuts in Scotland, only to be slapped down by its bosses from Westminster, who said, “No, there will be cuts.” Does Kezia Dugdale want to take this opportunity to come clean and tell us how much the cuts will amount to under Labour and where the axe is going to fall? Those are the questions that we are still waiting on an answer to.

Kezia Dugdale Lab Lothian
link

The First Minister swiftly passed over this morning’s news from the IFS, but it is very serious news indeed for the SNP. It says that the SNP is offering to spend less than Labour, and that it wants austerity to last longer than any other party does. That is what it says. She needs to read the detail of the report.

The truth is that the First Minister can dismiss some of the experts some of the time—[Interruption.]

Tricia Marwick The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Mr Bibby, Mr Smith.

Kezia Dugdale Lab Lothian
link

—but she cannot dismiss all of the experts all of the time. The IFS says that the SNP’s rhetoric does not match the reality of its plans for continued austerity.

The truth is that, whatever the First Minister is calling it, full fiscal autonomy is a bad deal for Scotland. It is not autonomous, it is not responsible and, after this morning, we know that it simply is not credible. The SNP can change the name of its policy, but it cannot change the facts. Does she still think that billions of pounds of cuts to Scotland’s schools and hospitals really are just “academic”?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

What a total and utter ramble that was.

I have said repeatedly—I will say it again today—that I want to take longer to eliminate the deficit than other parties do. That is because I want us to have the ability to invest more in our economy, in our public services and in lifting people out of poverty. That is a clear difference between my party and the other parties that are represented in the chamber.

The IFS report that was published this morning is full of assumptions and speculations. I will give members three points on which it gets the SNP’s plans wrong. First, it gives no credit for any increases in revenue from the tax rises that we are proposing. Secondly, it gives no credit for the increased revenue that we would receive from cracking down on tax avoidance—ironically, the report credits the SNP with being the only party not to simply make up figures on tax avoidance, but, unfortunately, it then credits the other parties with their made-up figures.

The fundamental misassumption at the heart of the IFS report is this: it assumes that the SNP would cut borrowing by 2019-20 to 1.4 per cent of gross domestic product. That is not our plan. Our plan is for borrowing in that year to be 1.6 per cent of gross domestic product.

Those are the misassumptions in the IFS report. However, one of the first pages in the summary of the IFA’s report states that the SNP

“would increase total spending in real terms in each year”.

That is our position. We know from Labour—we know it from Ed Miliband, we know it from Ed Balls and we now even know it from Jim Murphy—that Labour would impose additional cuts. That is the choice that people in Scotland have to make. They can have spending increases with the SNP or cuts with Labour, and the polls are beginning to suggest which one they would prefer.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. UK Visas and Immigration Questions · 6
  2. Defibrillators (Funding) Questions · 4
  3. Nursing at the Edge Questions · 5
  4. Rolls-Royce (East Kilbride) Questions · 6
  5. NHS Fife (Meetings) Questions · 4
  6. South Lanarkshire Council (Meetings) Questions · 6
  7. Ayrshire College (Student Support Funding) Questions · 6
  8. Charter for Budget Responsibility Questions · 4
  9. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
  10. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  11. Unemployment First Minister’s Questions · 8
  12. Child Sexual Exploitation First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. Crime Statistics (Recording) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  14. Food Banks First Minister’s Questions · 5
  15. DG Food and Drink Members’ business · 8
  16. Air Weapons and Licensing (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 55
  17. Air Weapons and Licensing (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 2
  18. Decision Time Decision time · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.