I think that I know the answer to this one. To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02718)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 8
- Kezia Dugdale Lab 6
- Tricia Marwick 4
- Dr Richard Simpson Lab 1
The record
19 contributionsEngagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland and a trip to Manchester for the general election leaders’ debate.
The First Minister has claimed that electing more Scottish National Party MPs will deliver full powers for Scotland. On Monday, her deputy said that a legislative process would need to be gone through to make that a reality. Within 100 days of taking office, a Labour Government will bring forward a home rule bill to put the Smith agreement powers, and more, into law. Will the First Minister confirm whether her MPs will table amendments to that bill to legislate for full fiscal autonomy within the United Kingdom?
First, we will be happy to support any bill that transfers powers from Westminster to the Scottish Parliament. Secondly, yes, SNP MPs will seek to strengthen any Labour bill—or, indeed, any Tory bill—to bring more powers to the Scottish Parliament. I guess that the question for Kezia Dugdale is whether Labour will support the SNP’s amendments to strengthen this Parliament even further.
That was not quite a straight answer to a simple and straight question. Full fiscal autonomy is the SNP’s central general election demand. The First Minister said earlier this week on the radio that it is what she wants, so I will give her another chance to be straight with the people of Scotland. She supports full fiscal autonomy within the UK and there will be a legislative mechanism by which it could be delivered, so will the SNP table amendments to the home rule bill to deliver it?
First of all, let us see whether Labour, if it is in government, introduces the bill, because Scotland is very used to Labour broken promises when it comes to delivering anything for Scotland.
Secondly, the SNP stands for independence—I do not think that that is any secret—and, yes, short of independence, we stand for maximum powers for this Parliament. That is what we will argue for.
Let me throw back a challenge to Kezia Dugdale. SNP MPs in the House of Commons will also argue and vote for a real alternative to the £30 billion of austerity cuts that Labour has signed up to. Will Labour MPs back that? We will also vote for an end to the grotesque proposal to spend £100 billion on renewing Trident on the Clyde. Will Labour back that?
The First Minister cannot bring herself to say the words “full fiscal autonomy”. It defies belief. It seems that the SNP is developing a bad habit of concealing its plans for imposing even more austerity on the people of Scotland. [Interruption.]
Order.
We know that the SNP’s plan for full fiscal autonomy would impose extra cuts worth £7.6 billion on Scotland. That is billions of pounds of cuts to our schools, national health service and pensions. It is also 138,000 jobs.
In this chamber on 19 March, the First Minister said of George Osborne’s budget:
“there is plenty that I would choose to reverse, starting with the austerity cuts that are going to be deeper than anything that we have seen before.”—[Official Report, 19 March 2015; c 12.]
Will the First Minister tell us by how much spending would increase in 2015-16 under the SNP’s plans compared with under the Tories’ plans?
The only cuts on the horizon—[Interruption.]
Order.
The only cuts on the horizon for Scotland are the £30 billion cuts that the Tories have proposed and Labour has signed up to. Scotland’s share of those £30 billion cuts would be £2.4 billion. That is the reality.
I have proposed an alternative to that. I have made a proposal for modest spending increases in the next Parliament that would deliver additional spending of more than £140 billion. That is the alternative to the £30 billion cuts that Labour has signed up to over the next two years. There is the choice that people face. It is very clear. They can vote for Labour, the Tories or the Liberals for more austerity cuts or they can vote SNP for a clear alternative to austerity.
We know from the SNP’s plans that it does not plan to spend a single extra penny—zero, nada, zilch—more than the Tories in 2015-16. I cannot work out what has forced such a radical change in the SNP’s economic thinking. It tells us that it is anti-austerity, but it does not plan to spend a single penny more than the Tories; it tells us that it stands for public services, but it cut education spending, which is something that even the Tories did not do; and it says that it is for full fiscal autonomy within the UK, but it will not tell us when. The SNP will not come clean because it knows that full fiscal autonomy would be a disaster for our schools, our national health service, our young, our elderly, our working families, our unemployed, our sick and every citizen in this country.
At the weekend, the First Minister talked a lot about guts and backbone. Where is the backbone to push for the full fiscal autonomy within the UK that she says she believes in? Why does she not have the guts to admit that the SNP’s plan for full fiscal autonomy would be a disaster for Scotland’s public services?
Let me set out a few facts. [Interruption.]
Order.
First, we will spend, under our existing powers and resources, an extra £600 million in the next financial year.
On Monday, I listened to Gordon Brown. I must say that, even for him, he took sleight of hand to a whole new level. He was promising to spend in the next financial year the revenue from tax increases proposed by Labour that will not take effect until the following financial year. That is some nerve, even for Gordon Brown.
Rubbish!
Order.
Of course, what Gordon Brown did not say was that the so-called extra spending for Scotland will pale into insignificance compared with the £30 billion cuts that Labour has signed up to. Labour can duck and dive, but the Scottish people have Labour’s measure. They know that Labour is proposing further austerity and they know that the SNP is the only alternative to Tory, Labour and Liberal austerity.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 2 Apr 2015 →- Methadone Programme Questions · 4
- National Health Service (Reporting Culture) Questions · 6
- Alcohol (Minimum Unit Pricing) Questions · 8
- Glasgow Colleges (Integrated City-wide Curriculum) Questions · 4
- Early Years Education Questions · 8
- Physical Education (Schools) Questions · 4
- Roads (Maintenance) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 19
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Meningitis B (Babies) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Domestic Abuse First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Broadcasters (Political Interference) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Greenock Morton Community Trust Members’ business · 10
- Prisoners (Control of Release) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 62
- Prisoners (Control of Release) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 5
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.