Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Smith Agreement (Implementation)

Portfolio Question Time Finance, Constitution and Economy

Wednesday 1 April 2015 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 7 contributions · 4 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

7 contributions
Jim Eadie SNP Edinburgh Southern
link

To ask the Scottish Government what recent discussions it has had with the United Kingdom Government on the implementation of the Smith agreement. (S4O-04187)

John Swinney SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Constitution and Economy · Perthshire North
link

Since the United Kingdom Government published its draft clauses on 22 January, the Scottish Government has provided a range of detailed comments on the drafting and the scope of the clauses, with the aim of ensuring that they implement the Smith commission recommendations in full. That has been accompanied by discussions at ministerial and official level, including two meetings of the joint ministerial working group on welfare. The Scottish Government has also started work on development of the fiscal framework, which will be a critical element in implementing the Smith commission proposals. I met the Chancellor of the Exchequer on 2 March to discuss progress on that work.

Jim Eadie SNP Edinburgh Southern
link

The Deputy First Minister will be aware that academic analysis by Robert Gordon University shows that the draft clauses water down the already minimalist provisions of the Smith agreement. Does he agree that the absence of the power to create new benefits and the restrictions that are placed on the categories of people to whom benefits can be paid clearly show that the UK Government is already reneging on the implementation of the Smith agreement and that therefore the only way to deliver significant additional powers to the Scottish Parliament is to send a strong team of Scottish National Party members to Westminster to speak up and stand up for Scotland? [Interruption.]

Elaine Smith Lab The Deputy Presiding Officer · Coatbridge and Chryston
link

Order, please.

John Swinney SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Constitution and Economy · Perthshire North
link

The Government has raised a number of issues with the UK Government on the detailed definition of the clauses that were published on 22 January. We have shared with the Devolution (Further Powers) Committee detailed information on the matters that we believe have to be addressed. The Scottish Government has engaged constructively with the UK Government on the specifics of what we believe are deficiencies in the draft clauses, which are now subject to consultation.

I point out to Mr Eadie that his observations have been reinforced by observations from a number of stakeholders who have been involved in the dialogue on the implementation of the clauses. I hope that those issues are properly addressed by the incoming UK Government; we have made that point in our discussions.

Mr Eadie is correct to say that the best approach to safeguard Scotland’s interests will be to secure the election of a strong team of SNP members of Parliament at Westminster, who will be able to protect and promote the Scottish interest on all occasions and without reservation.

Annabel Goldie Con West Scotland
link

I note that the Scottish Government has stopped referring to vetoes being contained in the new powers, and I welcome that development. Will the cabinet secretary confirm that the two Governments working together constructively to deliver the new powers will do much more to secure Scotland’s interest than trying to undermine the process?

John Swinney SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Constitution and Economy · Perthshire North
link

I will happily restore the word “veto” in my answer if that would suit Miss Goldie better, but there is a serious point at the heart of her question. She says that there is no veto in all of this. In the Smith commission proposals, one of the commitments that Miss Goldie and I made was to secure the earliest devolution of the work programme. Last week, the UK Government vetoed the early devolution of the work programme.

During the Smith process, Miss Goldie and I were arguing for the work programme to be devolved earlier, and that position was echoed by the Labour Party. Indeed, a Labour member of the Westminster Parliament, Ian Murray, has introduced a private member’s bill to seek the earliest possible devolution—by this summer, if my memory serves me right—of the work programme. Not only has that been vetoed by the UK Government, the programme contracts have been extended against the express will of the Scottish Government.

I am all for co-operation on the substance of these issues, and I have conveyed to the UK Government a detailed list of areas in which we think the draft clauses are deficient in terms of the objectives of the Smith process. We have shared that information with the Devolution (Further Powers) Committee.

I hope that there is a willingness to engage constructively and solidly in implementing not only the letter but the spirit of the Smith commission report, which—as in the example that I cited to Miss Goldie—is about taking early action to ensure that the earliest possible devolution of the work programme is delivered.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Economy (Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley) Questions · 6
  2. Economy and Public Services Questions · 6
  3. Revenue Scotland (Information Technology) Questions · 7
  4. Smith Agreement (Implementation) Questions · 7
  5. Revenue Scotland (Vacancies) Questions · 5
  6. Further Devolution (House of Lords Report) Questions · 6
  7. Renewable Heat Target Questions · 4
  8. Economy (Mid Scotland and Fife) Questions · 8
  9. Economy (Dumfries and Galloway) Questions · 6
  10. Institute for Fiscal Studies Post-budget Briefing Questions · 6
  11. European Union Exit (Impact on Economy) Questions · 4
  12. Progressive Taxation Questions · 8
  13. Oil and Gas Industry (Support) Questions · 5
  14. Economy and Finances Debate · 142
  15. Point of Order Procedure · 2
  16. Business Motions Business motions · 3
  17. Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
  18. Decision Time Decision time · 12
  19. Autism Members’ business · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.