To ask the First Minister what the Scottish Government’s position is on the National Trust for Scotland, the John Muir Trust and RSPB Scotland’s view that the planning process should be wholly independent of government. (S4F-02629)
Official Report · Chamber
Planning Process
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 7
- Liz Smith Con 2
- Christine Grahame SNP 1
- Roderick Campbell SNP 1
- Elaine Smith Lab 1
- John Scott Con 1
- Kevin Stewart SNP 1
The record
14 contributionsI am not sure that Liz Smith’s representation of the views of those organisations is entirely correct. If we look at the RSPB’s website, we see that it says:
“Of course the Government must have a central role in planning and in other nationally important decision making”.
We believe that local and central Government have important and complementary roles in our planning system. In terms of an appeals process, we already have the respected and valued reporter and the directorate for planning and environmental appeals, which provide a separate process to the planning authority.
We continue to engage with stakeholders to ensure that planning remains efficient, effective and inclusive, with the majority of decisions being taken locally.
I have here the letter to The Herald in which those important bodies and some others express their deep-seated concern that the public has largely lost confidence in the planning process and that local communities that unite to conserve our most popular natural assets are frequently swept aside in an unequal battle with Government and powerful commercial interests. Does the First Minister accept that that is a serious issue that undermines the heart of local democracy and can be addressed only if an independent body is involved?
I, too, have the letter in front of me. I will be very happy for the Government to engage with the organisations that are signatories to it to discuss with them how we can further improve the planning system.
I have two points to make. First, the vast majority of planning decisions are already made locally by those who are best placed to consider in what circumstances planning consent should or should not be granted. I think that that is right and proper. Secondly, planning benefits greatly from being part of a democratic process. It is informed at all stages by high-quality, objective and professional advice.
I am happy to discuss the points that have been raised with all the organisations concerned, but I do not think that we should take the planning system out of the democratic process. I think that that would be a mistake.
Does the First Minister share my concern that if the proposal were to become a reality, that democracy would be removed? For me, there is no greater test of democratic accountability than the ballot box. If people are unhappy about local decisions, they can take it out on their councillors or, indeed, on us.
I generally agree with that point, but that is not to say that we cannot improve the planning process further. This Government has been working to do that over the past number of years, and I am sure that there is still work to be done.
There is an important point of principle here, which is that there needs to be democratic accountability in the planning process, as there does in any other aspect of Government policy. That is the principle that we need to start with. Within that, of course we should look at where we can make further improvements.
The published letter refers rather vaguely to improvements to existing planning procedures, including
“potentially ... the creation of a body or process that is truly independent of government”,
without providing any detail on the proposal. Some of the concerns might be alleviated by the publication of an options paper on the creation of an environmental court. What is the First Minister’s position on that?
As Rod Campbell candidly and rightly says, no great detail is provided on the proposal that is made in the letter. As he will be aware, in our manifesto we committed to consulting on an environmental court, and we will publish an options paper on an environmental court or tribunal later in 2015.
We have already made significant improvements to ensure that we have the appropriate structures in place to protect our environment. Those improvements include changes to environmental regulation and planning policy, as well as the changes to the civil court system that we made through the Courts Reform (Scotland) Act 2014.
Given that the planning system is not wholly independent of government, does the First Minister agree that it is hugely important that the views of local people are taken into account by the Government when it takes final decisions on planning applications?
I think that there is a real debate to be had about whether the planning process should be entirely independent of government, because of the points that I have already made about democratic accountability. That might well be a debate that Parliament wants to have—it is a legitimate debate, but there are some big issues at stake in it.
As regards Elaine Smith’s point about the views of local people, of course I believe that local people’s views are important. That is why I think that it is right that, rather than being made by national Government, the majority of planning decisions are made locally by people who are best placed in local areas to decide in what circumstances it is right to grant planning consent for a particular project and in what circumstances it is not. We want to continue to make sure that there is that local accountability as well as the overall democratic accountability that I have spoken about.
The First Minister may well be aware of a planning decision in Ayrshire that was famously known as the plot 9 decision, in which every councillor on the regulatory panel voted against the proposal for Ayr seafront, but it was overturned by Scottish ministers. If she is looking for an example of local democracy not being allowed to have its head, she could find no finer example in holding her ministers to account.
There will be circumstances in which planning decisions are taken nationally. That does not change what I said, which was that the vast majority are taken locally. When decisions fall to be taken nationally, it is vital that they are taken in line with the proper planning considerations, which will have been the case in the circumstances that John Scott cites. That is what is required, and it will have been done in that case. I will be happy to ask the minister who is responsible for planning to discuss the circumstances of the case with John Scott directly.
There is outrage in Aberdeen about the decision to proceed with the Marischal Square development against the feelings of people of that great city. How can we ensure that people’s views are taken into account when councillors and others take decisions on planning? In this case, the people’s views are not being listened to.
I certainly think that Aberdeen City Council could do with a few lessons on taking account of the views of local people. It has appeared to be the case that it wants to ignore those views whenever possible.
As well as all the checks and balances and safeguards in the planning process that rightly exist, it is open to people when they get the opportunity at the ballot box to make their views known. Perhaps that is what people in Aberdeen should choose to do.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 5 Mar 2015 →- Guardianship Orders Questions · 4
- Raith Junction Improvement Works Questions · 4
- Childcare Commitment (Glasgow) Questions · 6
- Payday Lending and Gambling Questions · 6
- Attainment Fund Questions · 6
- Endocrine Disruptors (European Union Consultation) Questions · 4
- Economic Impact of Oil and Gas (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 4
- Register of Land Ownership Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 23
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- River Clyde (Environmental Concerns) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- NHS 24 (Recruitment and Retention) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Planning Process First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Fairtrade Fortnight 2015 Members’ business · 8
- Postage Provision Questions · 4
- School Visits (Remote and Rural Schools) Questions · 4
- Lobbying Register Questions · 7
- Protecting Public Services and Boosting Scotland’s Economy Debate · 192
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 14
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.