To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02614)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 8
- Kezia Dugdale Lab 6
- Tricia Marwick 4
The record
18 contributionsEngagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
The people who work in our national health service perform heroics every single day, but they are under pressure like never before. Earlier this week, Dr Martin McKechnie, Scottish vice-president of the Royal College of Emergency Medicine, said that the NHS in Scotland is suffering from
“a hospital and medical service crisis.”
He said:
“We are doing the damn best we can. But it is awful for patients and families and awful for staff.”
Does the First Minister think that Dr McKechnie is wrong?
No. The Government listens very carefully to Dr McKechnie. We are taking his advice. He is assisting us with the work that we are doing to try to improve conditions in our accident and emergency departments and on unscheduled care generally. Of course, Dr McKechnie said:
“what the SNP Government have done, to their credit, is help us with the number of consultants, which has gone from 120 to 190.”
That was a quote from the Daily Record earlier this week.
When our NHS faces challenges, as it undoubtedly does, it is the role, job and responsibility of the Government—of me as First Minister and of the health secretary—to work with our front-line health staff and with health boards to equip and support them as they face up to those challenges.
However, waiting times are down significantly under this Government. That is a fact. The NHS is performing now much better against tougher targets and in the face of rising demand than it was when the previous Labour Administration left office. For Labour to deny that does not do a disservice to the Government; it does an enormous disservice to the thousands of front-line staff who have worked so hard in our NHS to deliver these improvements. We have work still to do, but let us all acknowledge the progress that has been made in our NHS since the Government took office.
I have come to the chamber many times now and told the First Minister that she cannot rely on things that Labour did eight years ago as an excuse to get out of the problem that she is in today. If she does not listen to me, she should have a read of Iain Macwhirter, writing in today’s Herald, who says:
“When politicians blame the previous administration, you know there’s a problem.
When they blame an administration that left office eight years ago, you suspect there could be a crisis.”
That is from Iain Macwhirter, who is no friend of the Labour Party.
We have an NHS at breaking point. The usual Scottish National Party solution of sticking a plaster over the wounds will not do—serious treatment is required. On Tuesday, the SNP Government’s own figures showed that Scots are waiting longer for treatment than they were promised by the First Minister, with more than 10,000 people waiting over four months for treatment. Thousands of Scots with a legal right to treatment are not getting it in the time that they were promised. Only in the world of the First Minister is the SNP doing a good job of running the NHS.
Colin Howie, president of the British Orthopaedic Association and a leading surgeon, said:
“We no longer have a short winter bed crisis. Surgical cancellations happen throughout the year because of the lack of facility. It is a bed crisis.”
Does the First Minister think that Colin Howie is wrong?
I listen, and will always listen, carefully to NHS professionals, but I am quite staggered to listen to a representative of the Labour Party talk about declining acute bed numbers, when acute bed numbers declined in every single year of the last Labour Administration.
Acute medical beds—[Interruption.]
Order.
Acute medical beds, on the other hand, have slightly increased over the past year.
I will say very firmly that it is not about seeking to blame anybody when we record and acknowledge—[Interruption.]
Order.
—the significant progress that our NHS staff have made over the past number of years.
Kezia Dugdale mentioned the esteemed journalist Iain Macwhirter. In his column this morning, Iain Macwhirter mentioned delayed discharge. We have a challenge in delayed discharge, but let me illustrate my point about the progress that has been made. In October 2006, 908 patients were delayed more than four weeks; in October 2014—the latest stats that we have available—that was down to 321 patients, or down by two thirds. Let us look at something else: the average length of delay—it has come down from 69 days in October 2006 to 30 days in October 2014. Yes, we have work to do, but progress has been made and to deny that progress is to deny the achievement of our NHS staff.
On in-patient waiting times, our NHS provided more than 1.5 million in-patient and day-case treatments in the past year. Of those who were covered by the treatment time guarantee over the past year, 9,000 patients waited longer than 12 weeks—that is less than 3 per cent. By contrast, in the last year of the Labour-led Administration—[Interruption.]
Order.
—if we look at all planned in-patient, diagnostic and day cases, more than 129,000 patients waited more than 12 weeks. I will continue to discharge the obligation and the responsibility that my Government has to support the NHS so that it can make progress, but I will not stand here and allow Labour to trash the achievements of our NHS staff.
That was dire and there was not a word of comfort in it—not a crumb of comfort—for a pensioner lying on a trolley in an A and E ward last night. [Interruption.]
Order.
We learned this week that some of the most vulnerable Scots are being let down by the SNP Government. Young Scots with mental health problems are waiting more than six months to get the treatment that they so desperately need. Whether someone is visiting A and E, waiting to get a hospital bed or planning for an operation, there are problems all across our NHS.
Suzanne Hunter, a dedicated nurse from Clackmannanshire, said:
“This winter the NHS reached breaking point because we simply don’t have the resources. Our NHS needs real help now.”
Does the First Minister, like other nationalists, think that Suzanne Hunter is wrong?
For the avoidance of doubt, I do not think that any healthcare professional is wrong when they talk about the health service; I think that Labour politicians are wrong when they talk about the health service.
Let us look at the issue of resources. There is still work to do, of course, but all the improvements that I have outlined that our NHS staff have delivered over the past number of years have been possible because of the resources that we are making available to our health service. Three billion pounds a year more is being spent on our health service than when we took office. The health service budget is now more than £12 billion for the first time. Next year alone, there will be £383 million more in the health budget than there is this year. There are nearly 10,000 more people working in our NHS today than there were when Labour left office.
I will continue to discharge my responsibility and my Government’s responsibility to improve the health service further. I am not standing here and saying that there are no challenges in our health service and that there is not more work to be done. However, I will defend the achievements of our health service staff, because those achievements are considerable. Against tougher targets and in the face of rising demand, our NHS is performing better today than it was under Labour so, instead of trying to trash that performance, we should thank our health service staff for what they are doing.
It is NHS staff who are telling the First Minister that they do not have the resources that they need to do their job.
This week, the First Minister will mark 100 days in office, but she has been at the heart of the Government for more than 3,000 days. The SNP might see that as a landmark and a chance for a lap of honour, but what exactly is the First Minister’s record on the NHS? It is targets missed, an A and E crisis, fewer beds, thousands of patients waiting months on end for the treatment that they need, and dedicated NHS staff warning of chaos.
We have expert staff and patients on one side who are exposing the crisis in our NHS, and on the other side we have the SNP Government refusing to take responsibility. With our NHS on life support, when will the First Minister listen to the experts and start to take the crisis seriously?
Kezia Dugdale does not do a disservice to me or my Government with language like that. She does a disservice to the hard-working men and women in our NHS, who every single day of the week work hard to treat the vast overwhelming majority of patients within the tougher treatment time guarantees that this Government has introduced.
What is the Government’s record on health? It is lower in-patient waiting times, lower out-patient waiting times and fewer delayed discharge patients than under the previous Labour Government. There is much, much more to do, but considerable progress has been made. When Labour was in office, not only did it not meet its less stringent waiting times, it privatised an entire NHS hospital, which this Government brought back into the NHS. I think that the people of Scotland and the staff of our national health service will choose to continue moving forward with the SNP Government rather than going backwards with Labour.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 26 Feb 2015 →- Winchburgh Tunnel (Closure) Questions · 4
- Medical Records (Access) Questions · 4
- National Museums Scotland (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Tax Avoidance Questions · 6
- Malawi (Scottish Government Support) Questions · 6
- Burntisland Fabrications (Jobs) Questions · 4
- Scottish Business Development Bank Questions · 4
- PFI and PPP Costs (Edinburgh Western) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 18
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Stop and Search (Research) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Educational Attainment First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Communications (Monitoring and Interception) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Parental Imprisonment Members’ business · 15
- New Psychoactive Substances Statement · 31
- Commission on Local Tax Reform Debate · 94
- Decision Time Decision time · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.