I make the obvious point that responsible dog ownership means that people get their own bags and look after their own dogs’ fouling on our streets and in our communities. I find it appalling that nowadays, when we go out into the countryside, we find little doggy bags on fence posts. They should be taken home and disposed of appropriately by dog owners. I hope that that message gets across in the future.
Another point that we agree on is that the total cost of littering is unacceptable to society. As members said, it is £78 million a year. At least £53 million of that is the direct clear-up costs and the other £25 million relates to its effect on a range of other issues such as crime, health and reduced property values. Over and above that, there is a further cost to the marine environment of £16.8 million each and every year, and that in turn impacts on our environment, wildlife, industry and tourism.
As Jamie McGrigor said, marine litter is not just about the impact on marine wildlife. It is also a significant issue for the fishing industry. Vessels participating in the fishing for litter initiative landed more than 374 tonnes of litter between 2011 and 2014, and it is estimated that the problem costs every vessel in the Scottish fleet as much as £17,000 a year. That is a considerable sum. All that cash could be better spent on other things.
We should also consider that the discarded plastic bottles, aluminium cans and other materials that we see would have been worth an estimated £1.2 million if they were recycled. If we reuse the resources that are dumped on our pavements, in our communities or at sea, we could get millions of pounds back, given the value of the materials.
In addressing the litter problem, the national litter strategy and the marine litter counterpart strategy, which were launched last summer, also seek to boost our economy. The priority, of course, remains prevention: there is a focused strategy for which all of us should take responsibility over the next four years, supported by our delivery partner, Zero Waste Scotland, which has already made £500,000 available to Keep Scotland Beautiful’s clean up Scotland campaign. Keep Scotland Beautiful has many challenges to deal with, not the least of which is cleaning up the mess that is left by litter louts. Quite rightly, it relies on local action being taken by individuals, groups, business and councils.
I am particularly pleased that clean up Scotland is celebrating local champions such as young Bronagh Dallas from Elgin in my constituency, who picks up litter every day on her way to and from school. The Northern Scot reported that
“the first thing she does when she gets home, before she does her homework, is go on a litter pick of the streets around her home”.
The article goes on to say that she
“even drags her mum and other family members out on litter picks after school and at weekends.”
Bronagh is an inspiration to her generation and to the rest of us, and is a worthy local champion, as are the many people who have been mentioned by other members.
I should also mention Pete Miners from my constituency. He patrols the River Lossie, and has done for many years, picking up marine litter. He posts on Facebook the pictures of what he finds; it is absolutely phenomenal to see the piles of marine and other litter that he collects on his daily walks along the banks of the Lossie.
With about half a million volunteer clean-ups taking place across Scotland, tens of thousands of tonnes of litter have been removed, so we owe a huge debt to the many hundreds of thousands of volunteers across the country. That is a great achievement, but we still have a situation in which one in five adults admits to littering, so the problem persists.
We must remember that Keep Scotland Beautiful and our local authorities are not the only organisations with interests and responsibilities in the area. It is something that we all have to be part of—organisations, individuals and the private sector. I recently visited a McDonald’s restaurant in Elgin which undertakes activities around the restaurant and in neighbouring streets to collect litter. It is really important that the private sector continues to play its part as well.
In summary, the strategy that the Government has launched has three routes for dealing with the problem of litter. First, there is communication—highlighting what to do and explaining that litter is unacceptable. Secondly, we must ensure that the appropriate infrastructure is available for people to deposit their litter. Thirdly, there is enforcement as a deterrent to make people stop and think. We have already introduced higher fixed penalties—£80 for littering and £200 for fly tipping—to strengthen the deterrent, and we now have the carrier bag charge, which we hope will keep bags from being discarded in our streets, because people will be using bags for life and there will be fewer bags circulating. We also had a national marketing campaign in 2014, and there are on-going communications to keep the issue in the public eye. Finally, we are rolling out recycle-on-the-go points across some of Scotland’s busiest places.
I welcome this debate on a really important issue for Scotland. I hope that we can continue to work and collaborate across society to make littering socially unacceptable. As many members have said, it is socially unacceptable and it is a vandalism of Scotland’s environment and communities, so we have to deal with it. Let us keep working together, as Bruce Crawford says, to keep Scotland beautiful.
Meeting closed at 17:48.