Nothing surprises me any more about the way in which the biggest players in the construction industry treat their workers. The lengths that some companies will go to in order to cut wages, erode conditions and increase profits at the expense of ordinary working people is a familiar story for too many construction workers. We see skilled tradesmen—brickies, sparks, joiners and so on—who work on some of the biggest construction projects in our country, building the houses, schools and hospitals that we all rely on, being systematically ripped off time and again.
The reality is that some things never change. At start of the previous century, Robert Tressell wrote about the very same practices in his classic book, “The Ragged-Trousered Philanthropists”. He wrote about how the bosses used greed, deceit, and intimidation to exploit and control building workers, how they kept wages down as profits soared, and how they used the threat of the sack and hunger to keep workers in their place. The classic scene where the great money trick is explained by Frank Owen has simply been reinvented by the construction bigwigs of today. History does indeed repeat itself.
In the 1970s, the lump labour scheme brought about the national building trade strike and then the case of the Shrewsbury pickets, who are still campaigning for justice.
We have had the blacklisting scandal. Still none of the companies has owned up, apologised or compensated their victims, yet, to this day, we are awarding them contracts such as those for the Victoria and Albert museum in Dundee, the Aberdeen bypass and the new Dumfries hospital.
We have had the exploitation of agency workers and bogus self-employment; now we have the umbrella companies scam. Steve Murphy, the general secretary of the Union of Construction, Allied Trades and Technicians—UCATT—calls the latest attack on workers’ rights
“the most devious and complex yet”.
That is some claim.
How does it work? Umbrella companies are a direct response by the companies to the United Kingdom Government’s decision to ban employment agencies from falsely claiming that construction workers were self-employed.
Companies and agencies pretended that workers were self-employed to avoid paying employers’ national insurance contributions. Lobbying by the construction unions and workers themselves forced the Government’s hand. What did the employers do? Did they pay their national insurance and accept that their scam had been rumbled and was over? Did they hell; they never do. They simply moved on to their next cunning plan: a 21st century version of the great money trick.
Employment agencies use a complex pay structure to pass on to workers the costs of employers’ national insurance and the processing of their pay. They are able to pass on those costs, which employers would normally meet, by putting an umbrella or composite company between them and the staff they recruit. By using those companies as middle men to pay workers, the agencies engineer a situation in which the amount that a construction worker receives in their pay packet is often a lot less than the rate that was agreed when he or she took the job. In some cases, people who expect £13, £14 or £15 per hour actually receive the minimum wage plus whatever amount the umbrella company sees fit to pay on top.
The agencies also encourage workers to submit bogus or exaggerated travel and food expenses claims to boost their wages and make up the money that the umbrella company takes from them. One pay slip that a worker recently passed to me shows basic pay of £277 and expenses of £389. If the worker gets caught claiming false expenses, Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs takes them, not the agency or contractor, to task.
In this great money trick, everyone gains except the person who does the graft. The agencies gain from saving the cost of employers’ national insurance. The umbrella company gains from making a profit by charging the workers a fee for processing pay and producing a payslip that is often so bamboozling that the employee cannot fathom out what they should or should not be paid. The contractor benefits in the long term from lower staff costs.
The arrangement is spreading like wildfire throughout construction and other sectors. I attended a lobby of the Parliament by Unite, UCATT and the GMB prior to Christmas. There, I heard of workers from the Denny power station whom it had happened to. Workers on the new university accommodation that is round the corner from the Parliament building—run by the arch-blacklisters Balfour Beatty—are subject to payment via umbrella companies. I am advised by Unite that umbrella companies are being used by contractors on the Ineos site at Grangemouth and at the fabrication yard at Methil. We also suspect that they are being used on the Forth bridge contract and many others.
Of course, it is not just the workers but the Government and the taxpayer who lose out. An analysis by UCATT has revealed that the Government receives significantly less tax when a worker is employed via the scam. That is because, when an umbrella company pays a worker less than the rate that he or she agreed, there is less income tax and national insurance to pay, and the expenses that it uses to top up pay are entirely exempt from tax and national insurance. Therefore, someone who earns £500 a week via an umbrella company pays £3,800 a year less in tax and national insurance than they otherwise would have paid. There is also an impact on pension arrangements and holiday pay. On top of that, pernicious zero-hours contracting is being brought in.
What should happen? I recognise that some of this requires action at a UK level, but as always there are things that the Scottish Government should and could do. Trade unions are calling for employment agencies and other employers to be obliged to employ workers directly and not via umbrella companies. The hourly rate that is agreed between a worker and an employer, including an employment agency, should be the rate that the worker is paid. There should be a legal duty to make payment arrangements transparent and easy for the worker to understand. It should be obligatory for employers to reimburse travel and other expenses in addition to a worker’s hourly rate, and holiday pay should never be rolled up into a worker’s weekly pay. All forms of bogus self-employment should be abolished.
A lot of that could be achieved via public procurement guidance and in tender specification and scoring, but that requires political will. Only last week, writing in the Morning Star, Richard Leonard of the GMB exposed the Government’s duplicity on blacklisting at the V&A in Dundee. On Friday, we heard that the Government has delayed the procurement guidance on the living wage until after the general election. It does not have a good record on these issues.
I welcome the offer from the cabinet secretary, Roseanna Cunningham, of a meeting on the issue and I thank her for that, but I hope that, 104 years after Tressell’s death, we can get some action to end such Victorian practices.
17:11