No, not again. I am sorry. The member can make a speech if he wants to.
The key factor is that employers should pay their employees enough to live on. There is something far wrong in someone working full time and not being able to live on that. Their wage or salary has to be topped up with tax credits or other benefits. I very much welcome the system of tax credits, which tops up wages to a level that folk can live on—obviously, that is good for the individual and the family—but they are in effect a subsidy by the state to employers that, for whatever reason, do not pay a proper wage. It also holds good, of course, that if employers paid a living wage, the state would save the money that is used for tax credits and could use it for other purposes.
As I said, there are also business benefits from paying the living wage, including a higher employee retention rate and better productivity.
My first point was that the voluntary living wage is good; my second point is about what is wrong with it. The main problem is that it is voluntary. We as a Parliament, a Government or individual MSPs can all ensure that we pay it, other parts of the public sector and the voluntary sector often pay it, and we can encourage other employers to pay it. At this stage, I mention James Kelly’s amendment to my motion, which seeks to help workers who are on public sector contracts. The Government advice is that that is not within our legal powers. I think that my colleague Nigel Don will touch on that.
If we can expand the use of the living wage, I would absolutely welcome that, but the underlying problem is still that it is voluntary and it helps only workers in the public sector or workers who are on public sector contracts. Are we just going to give up on all the other workers? What about the workers in the private sector and the voluntary sector? Do we not care about them?
Problems are also created if one employer pays the living wage and another does not. The unethical employer will be able to undercut the ethical one—I think that Mr Findlay made that point—and the public sector can be made to look artificially expensive compared with much of the private sector. The living wage is only a halfway house—a stepping stone to something better.
My third point is that the real answer is in the statutory minimum wage. To give credit where it is due, Labour did well to introduce the statutory minimum wage for the whole UK at Westminster. I remember that, before that, security staff—certainly in the east end of Glasgow—were paid £1 an hour. Even allowing for inflation, that was total exploitation.
That statutory minimum wage was a good start, but it always needed to be increased by more than just wage inflation in order to get to a decent level—that is, the living wage. Sadly, successive Labour and Conservative Governments at Westminster have failed to do that. I accept that, when the statutory minimum wage was introduced, there was a lot of scaremongering from some employers that it would lead to a huge loss of jobs. That has proved not to be the case, so the argument for the low introductory rate for the statutory minimum wage no longer exists.
What disappoints me most about James Kelly’s amendment is that it would drop from my motion the statement that the
“UK national minimum wage of £6.50 per hour is too low”.
As Mr Kelly is not here, I would be delighted to hear from any of his colleagues that a future Labour Government at Westminster would bring the statutory minimum wage up to the full £7.85 as quickly as possible. To be fair, I would also like to hear from the Scottish Government that, if the Scottish National Party were ever to support a minority UK Government, increasing the statutory minimum wage would be a priority.
I must say that I was very disappointed that paragraph 59 of the Smith commission report said that the national minimum wage should remain reserved. I hope that the power can still be devolved. I believe that there would be an appetite here from at least two parties to increase the minimum wage further than a Westminster Government might do.
We could touch on a range of other issues, including whether younger workers should get the same wage as others who do the same job and whether the living wage should be the same throughout the country. I will not go into those matters today. However, I hope that I have made clear my fundamental point: although having a voluntary living wage is a good thing, it will always be second best, and the answer must be a proper statutory minimum wage.
12:40