link
To ask the First Minister for what reason the Scottish Government’s budget underspends have increased over the last few years when its budgets have been reduced. (S4F-02525)
Official Report · Chamber
First Minister’s Question Time
link
To ask the First Minister for what reason the Scottish Government’s budget underspends have increased over the last few years when its budgets have been reduced. (S4F-02525)
I am glad at last to hear Jackie Baillie at least acknowledge the fact that the Scottish Government’s budgets have been reduced. In fact, over the current spending review period, we face a real-terms cut in our fiscal departmental expenditure limit budget of about 10 per cent, with our capital budget being cut by over a quarter in real terms. As we have just heard, Labour has signed up to continue with those cuts by voting for the Tory budget plans this week.
On the budget underspend, the claims that I have heard from the Labour Party go some way to explaining why Labour is no longer in charge of our public finances. In terms of the money that the Scottish Government actually has discretion over, the underspend amounts to £145 million, which is 0.5 per cent of our budget. As John Swinney told Parliament in June, every penny of that will be spent this year. By contrast, by the time that the last Labour Government left office in 2007, it had accumulated an underspend of £1.5 billion.
link
That—[Interruption.]
Order.
link
The budget underspend has risen to £444 million. That is double the amount in the previous financial year. That has happened at a time when teacher numbers are being cut, college places have been slashed and police stations have been closed the length and breadth of the country. When John Swinney said,
“Long gone are the days when hundreds of millions of pounds of government money would be underspent each year, doing nothing to help communities around the country”,
was he just indulging in wishful thinking?
Jackie Baillie has just demonstrated why the entire country should cross its fingers and hope that she is never in charge of the Scottish Government’s budget. It is obvious from her question that there is one important fact that she, as Labour’s shadow finance spokesperson, does not understand. The figure that she cites is £444 million. Does she not know that 80 per cent of that figure reflects variances in annually managed expenditure programmes and other non-cash accounting budgets? Those are underspends of money over which the Scottish Government has no discretion; we cannot decide that it is spent in any other way.
That is a pretty basic fact about Scottish Government budgeting, and I suggest that if Jackie Baillie wants to go any further in the role that she is in, she does some studying and gets herself familiar with it. The underspend of money that we control is, as I said, £145 million, which is 0.5 per cent of our budget. I think that most people would describe that as prudent budgeting. Every single penny is being spent now to protect our public services. I will take John Swinney’s prudent stewardship of our budget over Jackie Baillie’s budgetary ignorance any day.
Is it true that, last year, the Scottish Government had an underspend of millions of pounds on the youth employment Scotland programme at a time when youth unemployment was more than 15 per cent?
Any underspend in the money for which the Scottish Government is responsible carries forward into this year to be fully spent on programmes of the type that Gavin Brown is talking about. Not a single penny of that money is lost to what the Scottish Government seeks to support.
Given the Scottish Government’s record on improving the position on youth employment and unemployment—there is still much work to do—Gavin Brown should welcome the initiatives that we are taking and, into the bargain, welcome the prudent financial stewardship of John Swinney, which has allowed us to do so much to help so many people throughout the country.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.