The order that Parliament is being asked to approve has been the subject of significant consultation. It has also been examined by the Justice Committee, and I am grateful to the committee for its detailed consideration of the matter.
The order meets our obligations under OPCAT and the national preventive mechanism, which the current system of prison visiting committees does not. It establishes an independent monitoring service for Scottish prisons, ensures that all aspects of prisons will be fully and independently monitored, and provides a system in which best practice can readily be identified and improvements made in relation to conditions in prisons and the treatment of prisoners.
I believe that Parliament should approve the order for a number of critical reasons. The new system will deliver improved outcomes for prisoners and wider society. The current system of prison visiting committees is not as effective or efficient as it could be. There are significant inconsistencies across individual visiting committees, there is a lack of accountability and there is no ability to look at trends or to share findings. The new system will introduce effective leadership and governance arrangements for monitoring that will address those areas.
The independence of independent prison monitors is secured through the oversight of the chief inspector of prisons. In addition, independent prison monitors will be given powers to visit a prison without prior notice at any time, to access any part of the prison, to speak to any prisoner privately, and to investigate any matter that a prisoner brings to them.
The new system provides for visits to be undertaken in three ways. It provides for them to be arranged through a rota that will be agreed by the independent prison monitor, the prison monitoring co-ordinator and the prison governor, or to be arranged between the IPM and the PMC. It also provides for them to take place at the discretion of the IPM alone. Any concerns that wholly unannounced visits may no longer take place are totally unfounded. It is also wrong to suggest that unannounced visits will be infrequent.
The reason for allowing for visits to be agreed with the governor is that that will allow the governor to raise specific issues that may be discussed and shared with the IPM, or to highlight to prisoners the fact that an IPM will be available on a certain day. The reason for some visits being agreed with the PMC is to ensure co-ordination and the appropriate frequency of visits. A combination of announced and unannounced visits is consistent with the practice of the UN Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture and the principles of OPCAT.
A key element of the draft order is that it will require IPMs to visit each prison weekly. That will ensure that what is going on in individual establishments across the country will be monitored with regular frequency. In addition, the system will be subject to regular review.