Thank you very much, Presiding Officer.
The petitions system is the window to our Parliament. It is etched in our history and has been echoed in Parliaments across the globe. Today’s debate is an example of how to petition effectively, and I praise the Evening Times and Kidney Research UK in Scotland for their first-class work. Caroline Wilson from the Evening Times is in the gallery, and I congratulate her on her work.
I welcome the opportunity that has been given to the Parliament this afternoon to highlight the issues in the petition and the evidence that the committee has received to date in the course of its work. The Evening Times petition, which was lodged in November 2012, has attracted more than 20,000 supporters. It calls on the Scottish Government to introduce an opt-out system of organ donation in Scotland in order to help save more lives.
On 11 December 2012, Tony Carlin, the editor of the Evening Times, told my committee:
“I could speak for hours about some of the stories that we have been told or have come across in the course of our campaign: the anguish of parents who have watched their children needlessly die of genetic conditions that could have been resolved with a transplant; the desperation of a man who flew to India in the hope of buying a kidney; and the deep satisfaction that is felt by grieving relatives who have, following the death of loved ones, consoled themselves with the knowledge that others have been given the gift of life. However, there is little point in detailing those stories, because each of you knows or has read of people in the same position—waiting for the phone call that may never come while living a life of increasing misery, fear and despair.”—[Official Report, Public Petitions Committee, 11 December 2012; c 939.]
The UK currently has an opt-in system, although next year opt-out legislation will come into force in Wales. However, for now, I or any other person can actively decide to donate organs or tissue by joining the organ donor register; in other words, we are required to actively opt in. An opt-out system requires an individual to explicitly make it known, while they are alive, that they are not in favour of their organs being used for transplant when they die. The key difference is that an opt-in system involves people expressly stating a wish that their organs and tissue can be used for transplant on their death, while an opt-out system assumes that organs and tissue are available for transplant unless there is a specific instruction to the contrary. The petitioner and others argue that moving to an opt-out system will increase the availability of organs for transplant.
The decisions that we in Scotland and indeed any other country need to make involve ethical, legal, medical, organisational and societal components, and the important balance to be struck is between respecting the views and rights of a potential donor and obtaining organs in an efficient manner. In the United Kingdom, at present, the fundamental principle is that organs are donated actively, freely, voluntarily and unconditionally, using a soft opt-in system.
Organ donation is not a new topic for the Scottish Parliament or, indeed, for the Evening Times, which has campaigned on the matter for a number of years. The Parliament’s health committees have done work on this area, and my friend George Foulkes held a members’ business debate on presumed consent in the previous session. In early 2008, the Parliament mandated the report of the UK organ donation task force. The task force had been asked to identify barriers to organ donation and the factors that might have a bearing on donation rates across the UK. It spent two years considering the issues in detail before reaching its conclusions and recommendations. It did not recommend making any change in 2008 to the UK’s existing system, but recommended that action be taken within the existing frameworks to increase levels of organ donation by 50 per cent within five years.
The priority is to promote organ donation more widely and to raise levels of consent, improve public awareness and ensure best practice at all stages of the donation process. The task force noted that countries with an opt-out system tended to have higher organ donation rates but said:
“presumed consent alone does not explain the variation in organ donation rates between … different countries .... Many other factors affect donation rates.”
The legal and ethical implications of introducing an opt-out system were considered in detail by the task force, and it did not identify any barriers to the introduction of a soft opt-out system, as long as sufficient safeguards were built in. In 2008, the position of the task force, which was accepted by the Scottish Government, was that, although a move to an opt-out system would bring real benefits, there were risks.
The task force made 14 recommendations for increasing organ donation throughout the UK without moving to an opt-out system. It recommended that, after a period of five years, progress could be reviewed, at which point the option of an opt-out system could be considered again.
I recall that, when we debated that report and its conclusions, the then Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing said that, although the Scottish Government was not considering an opt-out system for Scotland, she had increasing sympathy with presumed consent and that the Scottish Government planned to review its position in five years’ time.
It is now six years on. Public support for change is growing, and I pay tribute to the contribution that has been made by the Evening Times with regard to keeping the issue in the spotlight and engaging and influencing the public on what can be an emotive subject.
Scotland has not been standing still on this issue since 2008. The Scottish Government has been running annual organ donation campaigns, the Scottish campaign has a website and, last year, the Scottish Government published its donation and transplantation plan covering the period from 2013 to 2020. Further, NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde has run the respect my dying wish campaign to reduce the frequency with which relatives refuse to allow the use of organs, even when the deceased person has signed up to the donor register.
It is very welcome to see that sign-ups to the donor register are high in Scotland. As of the end of March 2014, more than 2 million people living in Scotland had made their organ donation wishes known by joining the UK organ donor register—that is around 40 per cent of the Scottish population, against a UK average of 32 per cent. However, as of March this year, there were still more than 600 people in Scotland waiting for an organ to become available.
I have already mentioned that the Welsh Assembly recently legislated on the matter. In acknowledgement of that, in February, the Public Petitions Committee held a useful and thought-provoking evidence session with Mark Drakeford, the Welsh Minister for Health and Social Services. After hearing about what has been done in Wales and what was achieved with cross-party agreement, the view of the Public Petitions Committee was that it would be good to take stock of where we are in Scotland on organ donation and levels of consent and see whether there is more that we should be doing to maintain progress. Mark Drakeford told us that, last year, 35 people on the Welsh organ waiting list died. Those deaths were the main motivation for making the changes and for increasing the efforts to improve consent rates in Wales.
The debate in the Welsh Assembly began in 2008. The minister was keen to stress that deemed consent was not something that Wales moved towards quickly, but over the course of a number of years. By the time of the Welsh Assembly elections in 2011, three of the four political parties that are represented in the Assembly had included a commitment in their manifestos to legislate to create a system of deemed consent. After the elections, the discussion process continued, leading up to the legislation being passed. The legislation is due to come into force in December 2015 and there will have been a two-year lead-in to the legislation going live.