Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Independence (Forestry)

Portfolio Question Time Rural Affairs and the Environment

Wednesday 5 March 2014 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 8 contributions · 4 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Joan McAlpine SNP South Scotland
link

To ask the Scottish Government what benefits independence could bring to the forestry industry. (S4O-02961)

Paul Wheelhouse SNP The Minister for Environment and Climate Change · South Scotland
link

Joan McAlpine will know that this Scottish Government has always sought to put the best interests of the forestry industry at the very forefront of our decisions. It is committed to planting a further 100,000 hectares of new woodland over the period from 2012 to 2022. Our commitment is demonstrated by the fact that woodland expansion in Scotland in 2011-12 was nearly three times as much as it was in the rest of the United Kingdom.

As is highlighted in the white paper, with independence the Scottish Government will, in the next common agricultural policy negotiation, seek to correct the failings of the UK Government and to negotiate an uplift in pillar 2 funding for the Scotland rural development programme, thereby moving from our current position, in which the UK has negotiated Scotland to the bottom of the European Union league table for such funding. If we had a similar pillar 2 budget to Ireland, for example, we would have a budget that was more than four times the size of our current allocation, which would open up the possibility of increasing support for each area that is funded under the SRDP, including forestry.

Joan McAlpine SNP South Scotland
link

Over the past decade, the forestry industry has become more centralised. The minister is aware of the Scottish Woodlot Association in our region, South Scotland, which believes that decentralised local tenure brings resilience to the industry, encourages more young people to get involved and connects the industry to local people. Will the minister outline how we could encourage more initiatives such as woodlots and bring about a more decentralised forestry industry?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP The Minister for Environment and Climate Change · South Scotland
link

I accept that, to a degree, the forestry industry has become more centralised over the past decade. In my closing address during the parliamentary debate on woodlots in October last year, I welcomed the pioneering initiative that the Scottish Woodlot Association has created, which aims to create a greater connection between people and Scotland’s land and forests. Key elements of that are encouragement of wider forms of management and ownership, and ensuring that a range of opportunities exist, such as in the national forest land scheme, which offers an opportunity to promote woodland crofts and hutting.

I hope that Joan McAlpine will be pleased to hear that the Scottish Government is providing financial support to help the woodlots initiative to establish a network of demonstration sites throughout the country. It is also working to establish a hutting pilot on the national forest estate. Given the time constraints, I would be pleased to write to the member with further details of that work.

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Is not it wonderful that devolution allows the Scottish Government to deliver what the minister has just pointed out?

The main concern of people in the forestry sector to whom I speak is not independence or otherwise, but the lack of planting of the commercial timber crop that is required to keep the sector active in the future. Will the minister consider reviewing the percentage of commercial tree planting that must take place as part of any planting scheme?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP The Minister for Environment and Climate Change · South Scotland
link

I recognise the point that has been made by many stakeholders in the forestry sector about the need to promote more productive forestry planting. That is why we have indicated that in the next SRDP we will try to promote an approximately 60:40 split in favour of productive planting. That is something that we have identified and will work hard to address. The consultation on the SRDP considers the intervention rates in terms of funding for planting projects.

On Mr Fergusson’s opening remarks, pillar 2 is crucial to our aspirations in forestry. Although we may have our differences about Scotland’s constitutional future, I hope that we both agree that if we had more pillar 2 funding, we could do a lot more with forestry. We might have different views of how we might achieve that, but I believe that independence is the route to a fairer allocation for Scotland.

Cara Hilton Lab N/A · Dunfermline
link

The Forestry Commission throughout the UK benefits from cross-border co-operation. There are fears, particularly in Silvan house in Edinburgh, that separation will impact on that work. I therefore ask the minister what representation he has had from the United Kingdom Government regarding research that was carried out by the Forestry Commission, and whether that would continue to the same extent if in September Scotland were to vote for separation?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP The Minister for Environment and Climate Change · South Scotland
link

I have huge respect for Forest Research and the work of the Forestry Commission in relation to the number of disease threats that Scotland faces. The commission is doing important work on developing its knowledge of ecosystem services as a concept, and on our national forest estate.

We have a good relationship with Forest Research. It is currently funded by the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs—it is a reserved budget—but we look closely at what we would do in the future. If Scotland gains independence—as we hope it will—we will work closely across these islands to ensure that we have research collaboration. Obviously, we would have discussions with the UK Government about how we would facilitate that. The people who work in Forest Research have nothing to fear from independence.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Rural Affairs and the Environment Questions · 1
  2. Environmental Legislation and Guidelines Questions · 4
  3. Scottish Dairy Review (Recommendations) Questions · 6
  4. National Marine Plan Questions · 6
  5. Independence (Forestry) Questions · 8
  6. Flooding (Rivers) Questions · 4
  7. Air Pollution (Glasgow) Questions · 4
  8. Flooding Questions · 7
  9. Tenement Housing (Recycling) Questions · 4
  10. Justice and the Law Officers Questions · 1
  11. Taxis and Private Hires (Regulation) Questions · 4
  12. Police Scotland Facilities (Fife) Questions · 4
  13. Police Scotland (Public Counter Services) Questions · 4
  14. Crime Figures (Offensive Weapons) Questions · 5
  15. Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 Questions · 4
  16. Unlawful Eviction Questions · 5
  17. Honorary Sheriffs (Abolition) Questions · 4
  18. NHS Scotland (2020 Vision) Debate · 37
  19. Business Motion Business motions · 1
  20. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
  21. Decision Time Decision time · 6
  22. Marie Curie Cancer Care Members’ business · 18

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.