I thank all the members who signed my motion to ban the use of electronic shock collars on dogs and cats. I convey the apologies of Claudia Beamish, who very much supports a ban but cannot be at the debate. I invite those who have not signed the motion to come along to committee room 1 today and try on a collar for themselves. Members of the press, too, are welcome to take up the challenge. People’s necks will be spared, but not their wrists. If they chicken out, they are saying, “I don’t want the pain of this, but it’s okay for dogs and cats.” That does not say much for them. Of course, if members supported the motion, they are excused—otherwise, they will certainly be on my name and shame list.
Why lodge this motion? I am the chair of the cross-party group in the Scottish Parliament on animal welfare and we put our money where our mouth was and decided that we wished to have the issue debated. Along with others, including Elaine Murray and Alison Johnstone, I have lodged a sequence of parliamentary questions in pursuit of a ban and to flush out the Government’s reasons for opposing a ban. I recognise the commitment of my colleague Kenny Gibson to the issue, too.
The Scottish Government maintains its position that Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs research does not support the proposition that the effect of these devices does either long-term or significant harm to dogs’ welfare but the Government further takes the view that collars should be used “responsibly”, as stated in a parliamentary answer on 27 June last year.
Obviously, I disagree with the Scottish Government’s position, as does the Welsh Assembly, which banned the use of such collars in 2010—in Wales, usage can make people liable for quite severe penalties of up to 51 weeks’ imprisonment or a fine of up to £20,000 or both. That was done by regulation under animal welfare legislation and the same could be done here. The Welsh ministers made their decision only after receiving advice from the chief veterinary officer for Wales and based the decision on evidence from consultations and DEFRA research. That legislation was challenged by the Electronic Collar Manufacturers Association, as we would expect. It lost and the ban remains.
The mystery to me is why the Scottish Government adheres to its view, for it is not just Wales that has banned the use of electronic shock collars—count in Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Austria, Germany, Slovenia and most states in Australia, which have all banned their use.
How can sending an electronic shock through a dog’s or cat’s neck for “training” purposes possibly be defended? Shock collars can also perversely cause further behavioural problems. A dog may associate the electric shock with other events at the same time, with unintended consequences, such as perhaps attacking other dogs.
I have had pet animals for more than 40 years and would never countenance using pain to train—quite the opposite. Despite the different temperaments of my pet cats and dog over the years, I have found that kindness and patience through understanding the animals’ behaviour has allowed training to be successful. Indeed, that is a policy that has been followed by my sequence of cats, who have long since got the measure of me and, having observed my behaviour and seen what works for them, have trained me over the years without the use of a shock collar.
However, let us park personal anecdote and sentiment and go for hard facts. In its funded studies, published in 2013, DEFRA concluded that there was great variability in how shock collars were used on dogs and that owners tended either not to read or not to follow instructions, so the main conclusion was that there were significant welfare consequences for some of the dogs.
By the way, it is easy enough to buy the devices online, with prices ranging from about £20 to hundreds of pounds. Goodness knows who is buying them, whether they bother to read the manuals, and how and where the devices are being used. I suspect that if you or I saw one being applied in public, we would be appalled. Not only does 73 per cent of the public disapprove of the use of these devices, 74 per cent would support a ban.
I know of one group in which 100 per cent of people would vote against shock collars, and they put it better than me or any other politician. Here is what they said:
“In trials 1 in 4 dogs showed signs of stress”;
“It will make dogs sad”;
“If you have a shock collar you are a bad person”;
“Why shock a dog when you can train them to do good things”;
“Stop hurting my friends”;
“Imagine getting shocked for up to 30 seconds you wouldn’t like it”;
“The majority of people love pets, but some people take it way too far, yes dogs and cats can make mistakes just like us really but that doesn’t give you the right to Zap them in the neck, does it”;
and
“If I was at this debate I would vote to ban them forever”.
Those are the voices of primary 7 pupils at Mauricewood primary school in Penicuik.
I give notice to the minister that I feel a campaign coming on if the Government remains obdurate, and I have colleagues in various parties who I think would support a campaign. Such a campaign would be supported not only by colleagues in the Parliament and by the Mauricewood pupils, but—we should remember—by the vast majority of the public.
My offer remains open to members of the Parliament and their staff, the press and anyone else. If they think that a shock collar on a dog or a cat is just fine and dandy, I ask them to come and try one on themselves in committee room 1. I think that they will change their minds.
12:41