My starting position was that what was in place previously was very imperfect. There were some very good prison visiting committees and some pretty poor ones, as we know from evidence that we had before the proposals were redrafted. I had concerns about the rota system, but I am content with the explanation that we have had. The rota system will provide a context, or a backcloth. Such a system is very distinct from an inspection. By visiting a place regularly, it is possible to get a sense of the changes that are taking place. That will not impede ad hoc inspections by IPMs, so I am content with that.
Now that I have heard further evidence, I am also more content with the complaints process. I was concerned that if prisoners had to go through the formal process in the place about which they were complaining, although that might be appropriate, it might also be the last thing that they would want to do, if they had difficulty in writing or putting down their words, but I was pleased when I heard that it will still be possible to make complaints through the IPM directly to the governor and to bypass the formal process if that is appropriate. That is a lot better. Having the SHRC on the advisory group has made a big difference.
The order is not perfect, but I have yet to see a piece of legislation that is. Some of the legislation over the years has been terrible—I will not name names, but it has happened under various Scottish Executives and the Scottish Government. The order that is before us is a darn sight better, and my position is that we should suck it and see. Enough markers have been put down in evidence to the committee, and if the order turns out to be flawed we will be the first—I will be, at least; I cannot speak for anyone else on the committee—to jump on it.
Given all that, and some caveats about how the order will operate, all the matters that we have discussed have now been put in position, and I am content to support the order. I am happy to hear further words from the cabinet secretary about my colleagues’ concerns.