I am delighted to lead this debate tonight about how we can recognise the historical significance of Whithorn as the first known Christian site in Scotland and the cradle of Christianity in Scotland, and how Whithorn can become the destination for a number of long-distance walking routes—the St Ninian ways—which in my opinion would make an ideal candidate for European cultural route status. I thank colleagues across the chamber for signing my motion and enabling tonight’s debate to take place.
I also thank a number of people who have worked on developing the concept of a European cultural trail and on promoting Whithorn more widely, particularly James Cormack Brown, who I am very pleased has been able to join us tonight with his wife Susi; Julia Muir-Watt of the Royal Burgh of Whithorn and District Business Association; and Janet Butterworth and all the trustees of the Whithorn Trust. A special mention must go to my colleague Councillor Alistair Geddes, a tireless champion of Whithorn, who first introduced me to the concept of Whithorn as the cradle of Scottish Christianity and a place of modern pilgrimage.
The royal burgh of Whithorn in the Machars of Galloway has a very long history as a pilgrimage centre. In fact, as far as anyone can tell, it was AD 397 when St Ninian established his church at Whithorn. The year is significant because it is 150 years earlier than St Columba and lona. What began as a small stone church quickly adopted a significant degree of importance and influence in the early mediaeval world; that is supported by archaeological evidence of a flourishing relationship with the rest of Europe.
Whithorn was a destination for high-profile pilgrims, including Robert the Bruce; David II; Margaret of Denmark, who was the wife of James III and mother of James IV; King James IV, who made the journey in every year of his reign; and Mary Queen of Scots. It was also a destination for tens of thousands of unnamed pilgrims over more than a millennium. It has therefore both national and international importance.
I am conscious that that was an extremely brief outline of the significance of Whithorn, but I hope that it establishes in some way that we have something very special to work with when explaining why a European cultural route, in particular, has so much potential for boosting the economic, cultural and historical profile of Whithorn.
European cultural routes are transnational tourist trails, determined by the Council of Europe. It is interesting and perhaps encouraging that the first and most successful of the routes was another pilgrim route: the Camino de Santiago de Compostela. Such routes must be based on one or more themes. According to the criteria for selection, the route
“must be meaningful in terms of European memory, history and cultural heritage ... must lend itself to cultural and educational exchanges for ... young people”
and
“must allow for ... exemplary and innovating initiatives and projects in the field of cultural tourism and sustainable development.”
It therefore makes sense for the St Ninian ways proposal to focus on the related themes of pilgrimage and Scottish migration in Europe.
At present, Scotland has limited involvement in the European cultural routes, with only Shetland, Aberdeen and the abbeys of Paisley and Crossraguel featuring on any of the 26 current routes. The creation of the St Ninian ways and their acceptance by the Council of Europe as a cultural route would significantly redress the balance, and it would also dramatically enhance Whithorn’s status since, as the route’s destination, it would become a focal point of international recognition.
Although I have focused on Whithorn, the benefits of the route would be felt along its length as it would bring greater prominence to many other sites that deserve wider recognition. An example is Glenluce abbey—a Cistercian monastery that was founded around 1190 by Roland or Lochlann, Lord of Galloway and Constable of Scotland—which the Cabinet Secretary for Culture and External Affairs and I visited two years ago.
To be considered as a candidate for funding to develop a European cultural route, the bid must be made by at least five member states together, so the more countries that encompass the route, the better. Of course, the United Kingdom is only one member state, so in order just to get started, a degree of international recognition and support must be secured. In my view, no part of that process can do anything other than enhance Whithorn’s profile in a positive way.
The St Ninian ways will involve more than one route, in the same way that the St James’s way to Santiago de Compostela has many physical routes. A route that has already been examined in detail is the Ayrshire pilgrim trail from Glasgow via Paisley abbey and Crossraguel, both of which are already recognised in the European network of Cluniac sites. Its status gives us something to build on and helps to plug Scotland and the potential St Ninian ways into existing European cultural routes. Additionally, many other countries have strong cultural and heritage links to the themes of the St Ninian ways, such as Austria, Denmark, Belgium, Ireland, Lithuania, Poland, Norway, Germany, France and Italy, to name but a few.
In common with Santiago de Compostela, Whithorn is a current place of pilgrimage, so it is perfectly reasonable to suggest that a significant increase in visitors is achievable. In 1985, only 690 people received the certificate of completion at Santiago de Compostela, but last year the number was more than 215,000. We cannot possibly say what numbers we might realise for the St Ninian ways, but we can safely expect them to increase, which in turn can only be good for a comparatively remote and fragile rural economy in the south-west of Scotland.
In considering how to take forward the proposal, I am aware that the next funding call will be issued in March. To be ready to apply for funding, a key step is to form a non-profit intergovernmental association to commission and co-ordinate the work that is necessary to present a case to the Council of Europe. Given that we are not yet at that point, a sensible initial step would perhaps be to establish a small steering group to identify possible partners and set up the association that will eventually present the bid. I hope that the cabinet secretary will be prepared to assist with that first—and probably most difficult—step, perhaps in the first instance by meeting me and other key stakeholders.
Whithorn has a unique and fascinating history and it is fortunate to have people who are looking creatively at the economic and social challenges that their community faces. The Royal Burgh of Whithorn and District Business Association’s festival last year—“All Roads Lead to Whithorn”—gave everyone who attended, including me, a flavour of what might be possible. We could actually make that title true, and in doing so place Whithorn on the international stage.
The creation of the St Ninian ways and their recognition as a European cultural route offers us a fantastic opportunity to promote Whithorn both within Scotland and on a much wider stage. That promotion, if it is done well, has every chance of attracting many more people to Whithorn, with all the economic, cultural and educational benefits that that will, in turn, bring to the local economies right along the routes. It would also give Scotland the first European cultural route with a destination and a focal point in Scotland, which is altogether different from simply being a point along the way. Locally, nationally and internationally that is a worthwhile goal, and I very much hope that it will be pursued to fruition.
17:10