First, I thank members from across the chamber for supporting my motion and allowing this important debate to go ahead. For many of my constituents, the issue is hugely important, and I am so pleased that staff, volunteers and trainees and their family members from the Engine Shed are in the public gallery to hear our debate.
For almost 25 years, the Engine Shed has provided work-based training placements for young adults with learning disabilities. Although the Engine Shed is a member of the Scottish Union of Supported Employment, its approach is slightly different: it offers transitional support, providing young people with the opportunity to access training and work experience in an integrated setting.
The Engine Shed operates a cafe, a bakery, a tofu production line and outside catering services. Trainees are taken on for up to three years, initially working full-time in the business. They then move on to a mixture of work placements with mainstream employers and further training in the Engine Shed before moving into paid employment with a variety of workplaces.
As an MSP, I have been a strong supporter of the Engine Shed’s work. I have attended graduation ceremonies and heard first hand from the trainees about the skills and confidence that they have gained from being part of the organisation. I have also heard from many family members who have spoken powerfully about the difference the Engine Shed has made to their loved ones and the opportunities that it has allowed them to pursue.
Unfortunately, in recent times, the organisation, in common with other voluntary organisations, has faced a yearly battle to secure funding. Funding from the council contributes about 40 per cent of the Engine Shed’s total income, with the remainder coming from the organisation’s social enterprise operations. The value of the Engine Shed’s council grant has dropped—it is less now than it was in 2003, so there has been a significant drop in the past decade. The organisation has been looking for ways to maximise its income from its social enterprise projects but, as the Scottish Government has acknowledged, many social enterprises struggle in today’s harsh economic climate. I understand that the Scottish Government’s third sector unit has been considering the issue, so I hope that the minister will have some positive news for us in his response to the debate.
Earlier this year, following the failure to secure funding beyond March 2015, the Engine Shed’s management team took the difficult decision to wind down the operation.
The situation has its roots in the review of employability services in Edinburgh. As part of its work, the review undertook to consider investment in services for job-seeking disabled clients. It found demand for an integrated employability service that would serve people of all disabilities, one-to-one services, greater involvement in the development and delivery of engagement with employers, and a clear desire for the service to ensure paid work opportunities with progression.
From next year, the council is moving to a supported employment model that is consistent with the Scottish Government’s supported employment framework. Services will be provided under a single contract, and four of the existing providers of employment services for disabled clients are working together to take forward a consortium for the contract.
Although it is not part of the consortium, the Engine Shed has attempted consistently to engage those involved to see whether there is an opportunity to retain the unique contribution to support for young adults in learning employment skills that the Engine Shed has provided.
The management team has been looking at alternative funding options and it has worked hard to make the operation more self-sustaining. Therefore, I was concerned at the characterisation that I have received from the council that the Engine Shed had somehow rejected an offer to be part of the process.
We are left with a difficult situation, with the Engine Shed’s work simply not able to fit in with the council’s place and support-based model. Therefore, it has become no longer financially viable.
I have spoken before in the chamber about the value and importance of supported employment opportunities. The Scottish Government urgently needs to address the fact that 46 per cent of working-age disabled people are employed, compared with 76 per cent of the general working-age population. As Inclusion Scotland notes, only 13 per cent of adults with learning disabilities of working age are in employment.
Moreover, disabled people are more than three times more likely to have been out of work for five years or more than their non-disabled counterparts. There is a real issue here that needs to be addressed. I campaigned against the closure of Edinburgh’s Blindcraft and Remploy supported workplaces because I did not want the experience that they offered people with disabilities to go.
The Scottish Government encourages all public bodies to have at least one contract with a supported business. Earlier this year, when we debated the Procurement Reform (Scotland) Bill, Labour MSPs highlighted a freedom of information request that indicated that 44 public authorities, including national health service boards, local authorities and central Government organisations, do not meet that policy aim. There is a real gap between policy objectives and policy delivery.
I whole-heartedly support the ambition of supporting people into mainstream work when that is appropriate, but we need to recognise that some people will need more support than others. The client groups who benefit most from the work of the Engine Shed would not easily be served by the supported employment model that is currently being advocated. Many in those client groups have profound learning disabilities and, at the point at which they are referred, do not have the skills that they would need to get an immediate placement with an employer, regardless of the support that was offered.
Now that the Smith commission has proposed that responsibility for the work choice programme be devolved to the Scottish Government, I ask the minister to seek to ensure that that new funding stream is devolved to local government. As the Learning Disability Alliance Scotland points out, supported employment for adults with learning disabilities has never had a clear source of funding. There is an urgent need for that to be addressed. I know constituents who have not been able to work since the closure of the Blindcraft and Remploy supported workplaces in Edinburgh.
The Engine Shed has served as an important bridge to the more traditional supported employment opportunities for people with learning disabilities. There is a real danger that, without the dignity that the Engine Shed has given them and the intense support that it has offered, they will lose out and will fall through the cracks in the system.
Let us think about a possible solution. We urgently need the Scottish Government to carry out a review to look at what the position is now, in the absence of opportunities with Remploy, Blindcraft and now the Engine Shed. That review should examine the funding opportunities that exist at a Scottish level. Given the pressure that local authorities are under, there is a real need to review the situation and to come up with an outcomes-based approach. We should not just look at our policy ambitions. We can all sign up to good policy ambitions, but this is an incredibly hard time in terms of employment for disabled people, particularly those with learning disabilities, and we in the Scottish Parliament need to do more to support them.
I look forward to the minister coming up with some new opportunities and new ideas, and perhaps announcing a review to identify where we are. That would give new hope to people who, in the aftermath of the closure of the Engine Shed, will not have opportunities.
17:48