I bring the motion to the Parliament because although fuel poverty occurs across all regions, housing tenures and ages of property, it is significantly higher in pre-1919 buildings and in those constructed from traditional materials. Those pre-1919 buildings are not just the byres, the bothies or our ancient castles; they are the cottages, houses and tenements that are at the centre of our cities, towns and villages. Those buildings are the heart of our built heritage. They were built to last; indeed, the ones that we are concerned about have, of course, lasted at least thus far. Unfortunately, condition surveys tell a sorry tale.
At the meeting of the cross-party group on construction that was held at lunch time, we heard from Chiara Ronchini from the international scientific committee on energy and sustainability, who spoke knowledgeably and interestingly about the situation in Edinburgh. We also heard from Jamie Baker from East Lothian Council, who reviewed work on buildings in Haddington and Tranent.
Without wanting to be in any way particular by picking statistics from particular places—that would not help—I can mention general numbers, which may come as a surprise.
Around 90 per cent of pre-1919 properties need repairs. Many problems are in roofs and walls, and 70 per cent of faults are in critical elements.
Who cares? It sounds like a daft question. Historic Scotland plainly understands the problem but it is responsible for relatively few of our pre-1919 buildings—albeit that it is responsible for many of the high-profile, big and public ones.
Public bodies are probably generally aware of the issues and are likely to be trying to do something about them; they are also quite likely to be putting off repairs, partly for obvious reasons to do with budgets but often because they are trying to get out of old buildings before the repair issues become critical.
I think that most members will have talked to their local council about its buildings while knowing that the council is trying to move out of a building and centralise. A lot of capital expenditure in the national health service, particularly on new hospitals, seems to be driven by the desire to pull out of other buildings and therefore not to have to deal with the maintenance backlog. As long as the service gets into its new building, that works, of course.
Owner-occupiers and landlords probably do not understand the problem. That is where the difficulty for the Government lies. What do owners of buildings need to understand? I am grateful to Emily Tracey of the British Geological Survey, who also spoke at the cross-party group’s lunch time meeting. She reminded us that stone deteriorates in water, so roofs and fascias need to be waterproof and gutters and downpipes need to be kept clear and leak proof, so that they work.
I think that we have not got our heads round that, in general. The evidence around us suggests that most of us do not give much thought to those aspects of our homes. That might be because the issue is out of sight and out of mind—some of what we heard about at lunch time would be out of sight even for professionals; it might be because we are tenants and it is not our problem; or it might be because the issue is just too difficult.
We are much more likely to redo the kitchen or bathroom, perhaps inspired by popular television programmes, than we are to address the issue. According to Government figures, the £600 million that is spent each year on pre-1919 buildings has not reduced levels of disrepair.
It is perhaps necessary to say that homes that are not wind and watertight will waste huge amounts of heat. That is pretty obvious to members, to people in the gallery and to interested people who are listening to the debate, but I suspect that it is not obvious to the wider population.
Given the truth of that, it follows that there is little point in spending money on insulation if the escaping heat will bypass the insulation. Loft insulation that is soggy because it has been leaked on will just make matters worse. We absolutely must reduce energy use before we find ways of using renewable heat or microgeneration.
Fuel poverty is defined by reference to people’s incomes, which can hide what is going on. That is disturbing. Chiara Ronchini showed us in her presentation what is happening in the middle of Edinburgh—right here. The statistics show significant fuel poverty around the Parliament building but give the impression that there is no fuel poverty in the new town. The buildings in the new town are not significantly better or worse than the buildings round here; the statistics reflect the higher incomes in the new town.
It is clear that fuel poverty is more likely in rural communities that are off the gas grid. In general, oil and liquefied petroleum gas-fired boilers are more than 50 per cent more expensive to run than condensing gas boilers. Electricity is significantly more expensive still.
We need to put that in the context of climate change and global warming. It is clear that we must eliminate wasted heat, especially if it is generated from fossil fuels. We also need to make our houses more thermally efficient—the welfare, health and social benefits of doing so are obvious to us.
So, what is to be done? I appreciate that the Scottish Government is consulting on the issue and the more I researched what I was going to say in the debate, the more obvious it became to me that the issue is seriously complicated. However, I will finish with a couple of very specific points.
First, we know something about the size of the task. Survey work in Glasgow tells us that that city alone would need to employ about 300 masons for the next 20 years, using about 400,000 tonnes of stone, to deal with its traditional buildings. That gives us a glimpse of the financial challenge and the skills and materials that we need. I do not, of course, lay that challenge at the Government’s door; nonetheless, that is what we are looking at.
Secondly, property owners need to understand that it is important to maintain their buildings. In that regard, we need to recognise that we are starting from a very low base.
I look forward to hearing the other speeches in the debate. I have certainly enjoyed researching the issue and I will be very interested to hear the minister’s comments because I know that the Government is doing quite a lot of work on the issue as well.
17:10