link
To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02365)
Official Report · Chamber
First Minister’s Question Time
link
To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02365)
Later today, I will visit the Scottish Institute of Sport to meet the athletes and coaches who played a vital role in this summer’s Commonwealth games. The games in Glasgow were an outstanding success in terms of their organisation and the way in which hundreds of thousands of people were engaged in the biggest event that Scotland has ever hosted.
I am delighted to announce to the chamber that, in addition to being the greatest Commonwealth games in history, the event has come in almost £25 million under budget, making it one of the few major sporting events in history that have managed to achieve that accolade. It is certainly the only one that has both been the greatest games and come in under budget.
link
I associate myself with much of what the First Minister has said, particularly the view that our athletes did us proud. I have a suggestion for how he can spend the savings.
Can the First Minister tell us whether the number of teachers in Scotland has gone up or down since 2007?
As Jackie Baillie should know, we have managed to hold to the pupil teacher ratio that was outlined in the agreements that we made with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities. That is a considerable achievement in the face of Westminster austerity cuts. I know that Labour councils were the most enthusiastic in responding to the Scottish Government’s urgings about maintaining the number of teachers.
link
That sounded like three excuses in one. I suppose that that falls into the same category as the First Minister’s most accurate answer that
“anybody has given in any Parliament”,—[Official Report, 15 November 2012; c 13513.]
and, of course, we know what nonsense that was.
The First Minister knows that I am a kind and helpful person, so he will let me help him out here. Between 2007 and 2013, the number of teachers in Scotland dropped by 4,000. That is 4,000 fewer teachers in our classrooms, teaching our children. It is the poorest kids and those who need the most support who will suffer. The experts are worried. They do not agree that the drop in numbers is because of falling school rolls. On Tuesday, the Educational Institute of Scotland told Parliament that, every week, pupils are sent home because of a lack of teachers, and the national parent forum of Scotland said that the poorest pupils will be worse off and will get less support because of the cuts.
The First Minister will not tell us the truth about the drop in teacher numbers. Perhaps he can be more forthcoming about another issue. Can he tell us whether the total number of people going to college in Scotland has gone up or down since 2007?
The number of teachers employed by local authorities in Scotland in 2011 was 51,212. In 2012, the number was 51,100. In 2013, it was 50,932. That means that COSLA and Labour and Scottish National Party councils across Scotland have kept to the agreement of maintaining the teacher pupil ratio at the 2011 level of 13.5. That is a considerable success against a background of the austerity cuts that Scotland has suffered from Westminster. Given that that is part of an agreement that encompassed the leaders of councils across Scotland and the Scottish Government, I would have thought that Jackie Baillie would acknowledge that her party has played a part in the success of maintaining teacher numbers and the teacher pupil ratio in those circumstances.
I hope that Jackie Baillie is prepared to celebrate the huge and substantial successes of Scottish education, such as the record exam results and the hugely promising and effective introduction of curriculum for excellence. The concentration of our colleges on courses that give people full-time qualifications is one of the reasons why we are seeing such hopeful signs as the huge and substantial decline in youth unemployment—because, of course, full-time college courses have been maintained, in terms of full-time equivalents, as we promised in our manifesto. Those are substantial achievements not just of the Government but of the teachers, the lecturers, the pupils and the students across Scotland.
link
The First Minister should not hide behind the professionals involved, because they are the ones making the complaints about his education system. If I was a teacher, the First Minister’s report card would be marked “Lacks attention. Could try harder. Can’t even grasp the basics.”
Let me tell the First Minister about the college experience. The reality is that the number of college students in Scotland has been cut by 140,000 since 2007. That is 140,000 fewer people going to college and making a better life for themselves and their families. He knows that there is a cut, I know that there is a cut and the people watching at home know that there is a cut.
The First Minister dodged my first two questions. How about we go for third time lucky? Can he tell us whether the number of Scottish students going to university from the poorest areas of the country has gone up or down in recent years?
There have been substantial improvements in exactly that ratio thanks to a number of initiatives that the Government has taken, particularly our maintenance of the educational maintenance payments. Those payments have been abolished in England but have been maintained here in Scotland and are helping the poorest students in the country.
The Labour Party’s chequered track record of failing to support such initiatives that help students from deprived families is a matter of record in this Parliament. The Government is rightfully proud of the achievements of Scottish education against the significant pressure of funding cuts from Westminster. In allocating the credit to the teachers of Scotland for the successful introduction of curriculum for excellence against that background, I am allocating the credit where it is undoubtedly due. The Government can, however, take some credit for the successful introduction, maintenance and expansion of the schools for the future school building programme. [Interruption.]
Order.
It is not so long ago that Jackie Baillie was the health spokesperson and her colleagues were questioning us about education, saying that we were not building any schools in Scotland. We now have the figures for the first seven years of SNP government. Against the background of austerity, 463 school building projects have been completed since 2007, which is 135 more than the 328 that were completed in eight years of Labour-Liberal administration. [Interruption.]
Order.
I know that Jackie Baillie does not want to celebrate those new schools across Scotland and the conditions in which our pupils are now being taught, but will she at least acknowledge that, if we wind the clock back to when some members on the Labour back benches were on the front benches—that is really winding the clock back when I look at some of the Labour members—the Labour Party claimed that we were not building a single school yet, in fact, we have built substantially more in seven years than the Labour Party built in its entire time in office?
link
Even by the First Minister’s usual standards, that was truly woeful. That goes for all his responses. I say to him that he is not in the playground any more and cannot say that a big boy did it and ran away. Education is fully devolved and it is his responsibility. The First Minister’s Government celebrates percentages, but we talk about real people. [Interruption.]
Order. Let us hear Ms Baillie.
link
Here are the facts. The First Minister knows that the number of Scottish students going to university is down by 12,000. The figure for those from the poorest background is down by over 3,000. Bursaries have been cut by 35 per cent and student debt is up by 69 per cent. Despite the First Minister’s assertions, the reality is that he is failing Scotland’s future. The truth is that there are fewer teachers giving our children the education that they need, there are fewer college places for people who are trying to get on in life and the poorest people are less likely to go on to university under the SNP Government. He should be ashamed. When the First Minister leaves Bute house for the last time, should he not perhaps consider taking the education secretary with him?
Over this term of office, there has been a record number of students going into full-time courses in colleges and universities in Scotland. That is a huge achievement, in contrast to what is happening south of the border. Thanks to the initiative that this Government has taken, we have seen a closing in the gap in terms of access to our universities and colleges by students from underprivileged backgrounds. That has been the point of maintaining the education maintenance allowance. That has proved possible because education is free in Scotland, since we abolished the back-end tuition fees introduced by the Labour Party and restored education on the basis of merit and achievement, not the size of your cheque book. I know that, whichever candidate is successful for the leadership of the Labour Party, one of the first things on their agenda will be the reintroduction of student tuition fees. I say to Jackie Baillie that that will not be tolerated or accepted by the people of Scotland.
However, I thought that the point of peak absurdity in the line of Jackie Baillie’s questioning was when she said that the Labour Party celebrates percentages—[Interruption.]
Order.
Is it celebrating the 23 per cent of people currently voting for the Labour Party?
I heard on the radio this morning that there are scientists at the University of Glasgow who are researching the expanding nature of the universe. There are political scientists all over Scotland researching the contracting nature of the Scottish Labour Party—from big bang to black hole, from expansion of the universe to the disappearance of the Labour Party in Scotland.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.