Like others, I welcome the opportunity to discuss the motion, and I congratulate Ron Beaty on his campaigning efforts over many years. Often, it takes an impassioned constituent to raise issues in the Public Petitions Committee, and it is a mark of the success of this Parliament that such issues can go from that committee through to the chamber. I also thank Stewart Stevenson for bringing the issue for debate.
It was in October 2005 that petition PE892 was lodged in Parliament by Mr Beaty, who was calling on the then Scottish Executive to set down minimum safety standards for school bus provision. As Stewart Stevenson was speaking, I was reminded of a friend of mine in Hillside primary school in Montrose, many years ago, who ran out from behind a school bus and was killed. The petition moved from the Public Petitions Committee to the then Education Committee, and there have been reports on the issue in 2010 and 2013. However, today, we are still in a position in which, as the motion suggests, more has to be done on school bus safety.
The Transport Scotland report in 2010 identified 10 ways to improve school transport safety, some of which were mentioned by Stewart Stevenson. Those include reducing speeds on school routes and around schools, encouraging motorists to reduce their speeds when passing stationary school buses, setting minimum safety standards in school transport contracts, and risk assessing school drop-off and pick-up areas. In his foreword to the document, the Minister for Transport and Veterans said:
“I believe that this guide will be invaluable for local authorities and operators as a reference point for their responsibilities in terms of school transport and will provide local authorities with a toolkit of measures that they could consider seeking to implement best practice.”
Unfortunately, three years on, when Transport Scotland reviewed the success of the document, its conclusions were disappointing. Some council respondents who were spoken to had never even heard of the 2010 study, let alone its recommendations. Some councils said that because responsibility for school transport could lie with the education, transport or engineering department, there was often confusion within councils about who should take the lead. That is exacerbated when there is a shared responsibility, which diffuses responsibility even further.
As I said, one of the most critical conclusions was that some local authorities had never even seen the 2010 report. That is not to say that school bus safety is not considered an important issue in those council areas, but surely bus safety should be the same in Shetland, Shettleston, Elgin and Edinburgh. The 2010 report and Mr Beaty’s petition both sought a consistent approach throughout Scotland.
There are recommendations of best practice and advice on how to optimise school transport safety, so it is disappointing that so little progress has been made since Ron Beaty began his campaign almost a decade ago. I looked at the transport policies of each of the councils in the Highlands and Islands region. It is quite difficult to decipher whether those councils have implemented all, or even some, of the recommendations of the 2010 report.
I hope that, in summing up, the transport minister can reflect on his comments in the 2010 report, which we welcome, and suggest how the Scottish Government and local councils can work together to improve safety on school buses further in order, as others have said, to ensure the safety of school pupils throughout Scotland.
17:37