link
To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02338)
Official Report · Chamber
First Minister’s Question Time
link
To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02338)
Engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
As this is my first parliamentary opportunity to do so, I would like to pay tribute to Johann Lamont following her stepping down as leader of the Labour Party at the weekend.
I have always found Johann Lamont to be a spirited opponent in the Scottish Parliament, strongly dedicated to her party but in particular to championing key issues such as the eradication of child poverty and providing support for carers. I have absolutely no doubt that she will continue to play an active role in Scottish public life and I wish her well for the future. [Applause.]
link
I thank the First Minister for his kind comments.
We all care passionately about our national health service and we value the work that our NHS staff do every single day, so today’s Audit Scotland report makes grim reading: progress has been slow; significant change is needed; there is little planning in evidence; services are at risk; targets are being missed; and budgets are being squeezed. Does the First Minister have a plan—any plan at all—to deal with the growing crisis in the NHS?
We should start by looking at the Audit Scotland report, and at where it identified substantial progress
“in a number of areas, including improving outcomes for people with cancer or heart disease and reducing healthcare-associated infections.”
It continues:
“Patient satisfaction with hospital inpatient services has ... increased since 2012 ... Waiting time targets have reduced over the past ten years and the length of time that people wait has decreased considerably ... Between 2003 and 2012, the death rate for all forms of heart disease fell by 38 per cent”,
and on the report goes to identify where the national health service has made substantial progress.
Of course it is true that Audit Scotland, quite rightly, draws attention to the fact that despite the success of our NHS in terms of managing its finances—success that has not been replicated elsewhere in either England or Wales—the Scottish national health service faces challenges for the future. How could it be otherwise in the current situation?
Perhaps Jackie Baillie should have paid close attention to page 32 of the Audit Scotland report, which states:
“Reductions in spending at a UK level will affect the level of funding available in Scotland. The Scottish Government will need to plan for health spending within an overall reducing budget.”
The very heart of the financial challenge facing our national health service is the retrenchment and austerity at the United Kingdom level and the financial pressures that that imposes on our national health service in Scotland.
link
The First Minister is consistent in his fondness for selective quoting, but I say to him that the report overall makes extremely grim reading. We know that the answer that we have just received is not the answer of a First Minister in control; it is the answer of a First Minister in absolute denial. Anybody watching who works in the NHS knows the pressures on the health service. They will not be convinced by his bluff and bluster.
Let us look at the reality of the NHS under the Scottish National Party: almost half a million hospital days lost to delayed discharge; one in four patients in hospital does not need to be there; 325 consultant vacancies—a figure that has gone up 60 per cent in the last year alone; and the Scottish Ambulance Service facing cuts equivalent to 433 paramedics just not being there when we need them or 70 ambulances being taken off the road. Yet the First Minister comes to the chamber today and claims that everything is fine with the NHS. Whether we are talking about his own patch or across Scotland, why is he in denial about the growing crisis in the NHS?
Every statement that I read out earlier to Jackie Baillie was from the Audit Scotland report. For that matter, I can quote Caroline Gardner from Audit Scotland, who said in a very reasonable and considered interview on Radio Scotland this morning:
“I think it’s important to say that the times that the patients are waiting on average now are much shorter than they have been in the past ... The Government has managed to protect the”
national health service
“budget, certainly the revenue budget, in real terms up until the current budget period.”
We know, of course, what happened in the current budget period. To pass on the consequentials from Westminster, the national health service would have required an additional £202 million in its revenue budget. I agree that Mr Swinney did not do that—he put forward £288 million. That means that, in the current year, we are exceeding in terms of passing on the consequentials.
All the facts that I have stated are from the Audit Scotland report, and that guarantee of an increase in real-terms funding for the national health service has helped it withstand the financial pressures that are undoubtedly there. No such guarantee was in place from the Labour Party in 2007, and no such guarantee was in place from Iain Gray in the run-up to the 2007 election.
Jackie Baillie should really try to consider this. Yes, there are, of course, pressures on our national health service. How could it be otherwise? We are in the maw of financial control from Westminster. How much greater would the pressures have been if we had had the disaster of a continuation of a Labour Administration in Scotland? We might even have had a national health service in Scotland facing the same almighty pressures that are prevalent in Wales under Labour control.
link
It is evident that the First Minister has read neither the rest of the Audit Scotland report nor Labour’s manifesto, which very clearly talked about
“protecting the NHS budget in Scotland and passing on all Barnett consequentials for health.”
After that answer, it is clear that the First Minister is, indeed, in denial. In his world, everything is wonderful and rosy. However, while we wait on answers, people in Scotland’s hospitals are waiting on trolleys, waiting for an ambulance to turn up and waiting for an NHS that Scotland needs and which people deserve.
Let us look at what the experts say. Last year, the British Medical Association warned that the situation was not sustainable. Today, the Royal College of Nursing said:
“When patient care suffers because health boards are trying to make ends meet, it’s obvious something is ... wrong.”
Moreover, this week, a paramedic said:
“We can’t keep ... up. It’s just a matter of time before something goes seriously wrong.”
Why does the First Minister think that the people who work in the NHS every single day are wrong about the cuts that are facing our health service and that only he is right?
Jackie Baillie mentioned that delayed discharges were increasing in the national health service, but they are much less than they were when the SNP came to power. She also said that there were vacancies among consultants, but the number of consultants is much greater than it was when the SNP came to power, as indeed is the number of nurses and doctors. The number of NHS staff has increased by 6.9 per cent since the SNP came to power. Those things have been achieved against the austerity from the Westminster Government.
I repeat that quote from the Audit Scotland report:
“Reductions in spending at a UK level will affect the level of funding available in Scotland. The Scottish Government will need to plan for health spending within an overall reducing budget.”
Is that not exactly the kernel of the debate that we had in the recent referendum campaign, in which Jackie Baillie and the Labour Party were in denial about the impact of Westminster funding cuts on the Scottish national health service? If we take the Audit Scotland report as a very considered and objective analysis, will Jackie Baillie accept Audit Scotland’s pointing out the reality that a 7 per cent decline in revenue budgets in Scotland will have a severe impact across the public sector? That makes it all the more laudable that the SNP in government has managed to protect our national health service.
As far as the Labour Party is concerned, it goes without argument that, in 2007, Jack McConnell said that the NHS would have to “cut its cloth” and would get no additional consequentials. As for Iain Gray, on 8 September 2010, he said on “Newsnight Scotland”:
“We wouldn’t ring fence the health budget.”
Only when Labour was on the run during the election campaign did it start to change its tune.
I would appreciate a brief question and a brief answer. We have a lot to get through today.
link
I remind the First Minister, who still remains in denial, that, from 2007 to 2010, the Labour Government at the United Kingdom level gave the Scottish Government more money for the health service than he actually applied to the health service.
We detect a pattern. Audit Scotland is wrong. The ambulance drivers are wrong. Doctors are wrong. Nurses are wrong. Everybody is wrong apart from Alex Salmond. However, the facts are clear.
The NHS is completely devolved. We make all the decisions about it in Scotland, and the SNP has been in charge for more than seven years. In that time, bed numbers have been slashed, budgets have been cut, staffing has been cut, waiting times have grown and delayed discharge has been on the rise.
Does the First Minister recognise that the people of Scotland want a long-term plan for their health service, not sticking-plaster solutions? They want a focus on the NHS, not endless discussions about the constitution. Will he deliver, or is he simply in denial?
NHS staff have increased by 6.9 per cent. That is an increase of 8,818 between September 2006 and June 2014. As we pledged to do, the Scottish National Party has protected the national health service revenue budget in real terms and has added to that this year.
Yes, of course there are pressures on our national health service. How could it be otherwise, given that we are imprisoned in UK Government austerity? However, with regard to being in denial, I point out that I quoted exactly from the Audit Scotland report about the financial pressures that are bearing down on the health service.
That was exactly the argument that took place in the referendum campaign. I took a screengrab of a picture on the BBC website that showed Jackie Baillie against a background of signs saying “SNP NHS LIES”. The caption under the picture reads:
“MSP Baillie denies Labour disunity—A Holyrood politician denies there are rifts between Labour MSPs and MPs and insists they are ‘joined at the hip’”.
Any politician with the gall to make that argument cannot be trusted on the Labour Party or, indeed, the finances of the national health service.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.