To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01873)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 7
- Johann Lamont Lab 5
- Tricia Marwick 3
The record
15 contributionsLater today, I will be doing one or two wee things to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
That is such a relief to me, because we know that one person’s wee things are another person’s ridiculous frippery.
On Tuesday, in what the Financial Times described as the highest-profile intervention yet from business, the chief executive of BP, Bob Dudley, said that he was against Scotland leaving the United Kingdom. He said that there is too much uncertainty, including about what currency an independent Scotland would use. In response, the First Minister told BBC Scotland that,
“of course, there are many, many chief executives who are firmly in favour of Scottish independence.”
Will the First Minister name the “many, many chief executives” of oil companies such as BP who are in favour of Scottish independence?
There are hundreds of people in Business for Scotland, who are Scottish businesses arguing for the welfare and benefit to the people of Scotland that would come from independence. The most important thing that Bob Dudley said was that the investment plans of BP—which were announced very recently, just in the past two years—would continue. That is absolutely right, because they are made on an economic basis. BP recognises that just as, over the past 40 years, it has been extremely business sensible and lucrative for it to invest in the North Sea, so that will be the case over the next 40 years.
We should look at the investment decisions that are being made and the “sparkling performance”—to quote Ernst & Young—of inward investment in Scotland. The substantial investment decisions that are being made in Scotland are what indicate confidence in Scotland’s future and are what Johann Lamont should recognise as not wee things, but very substantial things indeed.
The First Minister has got a problem with the big things, such as answering the question that he was asked. Not for the first time, the First Minister is deciding for people what they are saying. He tells the rest of the United Kingdom what is in its interests in relation to currency; he tells Europe what it thinks about what might happen to Scotland in the future; and now he is telling Bob Dudley what he thinks the future is for his company. The First Minister should listen to what Bob Dudley said, rather than assert what he said.
BP has invested £35 billion in the North Sea and is planning to invest another £10 billion by 2017. BP’s North Sea investment employs 4,000 people, and to date it has extracted more than 5 billion barrels of oil and gas. I suggest that we listen to what Bob Dudley says.
The First Minister said that “many, many chief executives” back Scottish independence. I ask again: will the First Minister name the “many, many chief executives” of companies that are comparable to BP who back independence?
As I said, Business for Scotland has hundreds of members, who are people arguing for independence for Scotland.
Johann Lamont accuses me of putting words in Bob Dudley’s mouth, so I shall quote him exactly from the Daily Express of 5 February. Talking about projects including the Greater Clair exploration scheme, he said:
“They’ll keep production ... going past 2050”.
I quote him exactly in pointing out the substantial investments that BP and other companies are making in the waters around Scotland at present.
It was not always like that—I have a range of quotes here—because investment dried up in the period under Labour Government because of the constant tax changes, and that is not to mention the 2011 Alexander-Osborne swipe at the industry, which also dried up investment. That is why production has been declining over the past few years. However, thanks to the investment that is going in, Oil & Gas UK forecasts that production could reach 2 million barrels a day by the end of the decade, up from 1.5 million barrels a day in 2013. The investment talks.
What Bob Dudley says is important, but I have been looking at what another Bob, Bob Holman, has said in The Herald today—[Interruption.] Well, he is Keir Hardie’s biographer and therefore he should be listened to with respect. He said:
“I am a member of the Labour Party, which is against Scottish independence, but I will be voting Yes in September. My decision is not because I have strong nationalistic feelings, but because I believe in democracy and equality.”
Perhaps Johann Lamont should also listen to the many Labour Party members who have been declaring for yes, such as Alex Mosson, Charles Gray, Mary Lockhart and John Mulvey; she should look at the reasons why they are declaring for yes, then perhaps even she will decide to see the arguments for justice, equality, prosperity and investment in an independent Scotland.
Sorry, but I was only taking the First Minister at his word when he said that
“there are many, many chief executives”
who support independence. As he said it, I presumed that he would be able to give us at least one name, rather than all that displacement activity.
On Tuesday, the chief executive of Sainsbury’s, Justin King, said of Scotland:
“Once it is a separate country, we and other retailers will take a view of what the cost structure is, and of course the revenue structure too. If you were to strike that today, there is no doubt Scotland is a more costly country in which to run a grocery retail business.”
Sainsbury’s says that independence has negative consequences, and so do Asda and Morrisons. Together, they employ—[Interruption.] It might not matter to SNP members, but it matters to shop workers the length and breadth of this country. The chief executives of BP, Sainsbury’s, Asda and Morrisons have all warned about the consequence of independence. The First Minister says that
“there are many, many chief executives”
who are in favour of his plan. Again, I ask him to name the “many, many chief executives” of businesses that are comparable to BP and the supermarkets who actually back him.
The supermarket argument fell flat when it was run the first time in December and it falls flat again. It is not shop workers whom Johann Lamont is quoting—[Interruption.]
Order.
That is the point of the argument about what is important to Scotland. In today’s Daily Record, Margaret Curran said:
“we need to stop talking like the political elite”.
Johann Lamont has talked about nothing else but the political elite in this question. Margaret Curran says:
“I could talk until the cows come home about currency unions ... But if you are sitting home at night watching television, that is not the language you talk in.”
That is the exact point. Let us talk the language of people. Let us talk about jobs and investment—[Interruption.]
Order.
Let us talk about the transformation of childcare, about the bedroom tax and about what this Parliament has achieved. Do not cite the elite; cite the people of Scotland, who are rallying to independence. [Applause.]
Order.
It is obvious that the First Minister’s special advisers have been on double time trying to find him words to put in a space so that he does not have to answer the question. It is precisely because we are concerned about the consequences for ordinary people that we challenge the First Minister on his obsession of the past 40 years. Is it not the case that rule number 1 in Alex Salmond’s book of communication is to assert something that is untrue and keep on repeating it often enough in the hope that people will believe it to be true, even when it is not?
The First Minister cannot explain what the currency would be in an independent Scotland, but every major supermarket—not the elite—says that the price of groceries would go up, and the chief executive of one of our biggest oil companies has recommended that Scots should reject separation. The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland says that he has failed to answer basic questions on pensions.
The First Minister’s response is to stick his fingers in his ears and carry on regardless. At what point does the First Minister acknowledge that the chief executive of BP, our supermarkets and ICAS might know what they are talking about? At what point will he accept that leaving the United Kingdom will be bad for the people of Scotland?
Let us deal with the oil industry. When commenting on the white paper, Malcolm Webb, the chief executive of Oil & Gas UK, which represents the whole industry, said:
“We are particularly encouraged with commitments to encourage exploration and measures to maximise the economic recovery of the oil and gas reserves. We also welcome reassurances on future decommissioning relief and the commitment to consult on future fiscal changes.”
In terms of Johann Lamont—[Interruption.] I am quoting about things that matter. Investment dried up during the Labour Government because of taxation changes and it dried up during 2011 after the dawn raid from Osborne and Danny Alexander. Now, investment is surging in the North Sea and the waters around Scotland; investment will take place and production will therefore increase.
Our advisers did not have to work into the wee small hours to find the quotations that I used; they came from pages 8 and 9 of the Daily Record this very morning and say exactly what Johann Lamont will not admit. This is Margaret Curran, Johann Lamont’s friend and ally. I am not talking about the Labour MPs who will not turn up at the conference because they do not like Johann Lamont’s policies; I am talking about her friend and ally Margaret Curran, who said:
“we need to stop talking like the political elite and start talking about the issues that really matter to people in the street”—
the wee things, the things that really matter. She said:
“I could talk until the cows come home about currency unions ... But if you are sitting home at night watching television, that is not the language you talk in.”
Will Johann Lamont take advice from Margaret Curran, if she will not take advice from me?
On what the Government is doing in relation to chief executives, the Financial Times this very morning reports on a senior defence executive’s comments on the use of the dark arts, saying that the Government—that is the UK Government—[Interruption.] Well, I am just quoting the Financial Times, which I am sure that Johann Lamont reads every morning, because of her friendship with all those chief executives, and which reports that the UK Government’s putting
“pressure on companies to speak out against independence suggests ... anxiety about”
the opinion polls and the referendum result.
That is what is happening at the moment, and that is exactly why the wee things, like jobs, investment, the bedroom tax and transformational childcare, will carry the day in September.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 6 Feb 2014 →- Scottish Borders Council (Garden Waste Collection) Questions · 6
- Chief Constable (Meetings) Questions · 5
- Electricity Grid Reinforcement (Orkney) Questions · 7
- Exports Questions · 4
- Police Scotland (Meetings) Questions · 3
- Canal Network (Glasgow Anniesland) Questions · 6
- Access to Justice (South Scotland) Questions · 4
- Unemployment Questions · 4
- Foster Families Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 15
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Bedroom Tax (Extra Financial Assistance) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Alcohol Misuse First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Child Poverty First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Food Banks Members’ business · 36
- Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2014 [Draft] Debate · 30
- New Psychoactive Substances Debate · 26
- Decision Time Decision time · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.