I am grateful for members’ contributions to the debate. Working together with the committee to scrutinise the legislation is an essential part of bringing it forward and the best way to do it.
I reiterate that we will continue to consult all the stakeholders in an extremely detailed fashion. We place on record the fact that we respect and value the work that they all do. We have changed the regulations in a number of ways—I will write to the committee to demonstrate that we have done so on a number of technical matters. We have consulted the stakeholders on the draft regulations and through three working groups. We will produce the guidance in draft, after which the stakeholders will have seven months to consider it. To me, that is the way that we should proceed, and it seems a reasonable performance in relation to fairly technical matters.
I turn to the wider issues that members have raised. I am very grateful for Mr MacKenzie’s remarks, and I am sure that Rosemary Winter-Scott will be pleased to hear them. I will make sure that she and her staff, who do an excellent job, are made aware of Mr MacKenzie’s recognition of the work that they do.
I hope that the wider sector will also acknowledge the good work that the AIB does. It is time to move forward and recognise that, as Mr MacKenzie rightly says, those public servants are doing a difficult job in highly sensitive cases in an effective way. They are also effective in relation to the financial operation of the AIB, which is an example of sound and effective public administration.
The objections have been overegged slightly by ICAS, and to some extent we are revisiting arguments that were fully debated and discussed during the passage of the legislation. I do not think that that is why we are here today; I do not think that it serves any purpose. Be that as it may, we will continue to listen carefully to what ICAS says and to respond as appropriate.
Over the referendum period, I had the opportunity to have fairly detailed meetings with citizens advice bureaux, and I am hugely impressed with their work to help the people who have the least in society. The problems in relation to benefits are appalling, and the delays in administering benefits, particularly applications for benefits related to disability—delays that are not a result of any failure on the part of public officials in Scotland—are utterly scandalous and causative of very real hardship.
Therefore, these matters are not just words on a page or technical matters; they are extremely important matters for people who face enormous financial hardship, the like of which none of us in this room, I suspect, are familiar with. I am seriously concerned about the administration of benefits payments in Scotland—seriously concerned. It is frankly shambolic and the UK Government must take steps to deal with the situation. I make that point because it is directly related to the issue of debt, and it should be mentioned.
In relation to the purpose of the regulations and the 2014 act, I point out that we want to have a financial health service in Scotland. That is why we are getting on with this work. We want a financial health service so that young people in Scotland can increasingly be more effectively educated about how to manage their money. Then they will not fall prey to the sharks involved in some of the excessive interest that is charged on money-lending activities and payday loans, which for far too long were left almost entirely unregulated.
That is despite the fact that the very first members’ business debate that I responded to in this job in 2011 was on payday loans, when Margaret Burgess brought her enormous experience to bear on the topic. It took three years for the obvious steps to be taken, a delay which has seriously exacerbated the problems that money advisers and citizens advice bureaux face. They deal at the sharp end with hugely difficult cases. Many human tragedies underlie all the statistics, so I am very pleased that we are doing something good today. I hope that members will support the regulations.