Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 26 June 2014 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 14 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

14 contributions
Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

Let me offer another quotation from Brian Keighley, from the same “GMS” interview. Johann Lamont does not want to accept this, but he said:

“Clearly my target is not the current Cabinet Secretary, my target is the political classes in Scotland.”

The point that he was making was that health resources are under pressure because of rising demand. He accepted that we have done everything that we can, under the constraints of the Barnett formula, to protect the national health service.

I think that we are entitled to ask whether that would have been done if the Labour Party had been in power over the past seven years. We know that it would not have been done in 2007, because Jack McConnell said that the NHS would just have to cut its coat to suit its cloth and would not have access to the Barnett consequentials. We doubt that it would have been done in 2011, either, because the Labour Party refused to commit to the resources in real terms.

If we want evidence of the Labour Party in power, we should just look to Wales, which is suffering the same stresses as Scotland under the Barnett formula but is, on every measurement, turning in a worse health performance.

Does Johann Lamont accept the connection between the resources that are available to us under the Barnett formula and the ability to fund the national health service to the degree that Brian Keighley and all of us would want? Is not that an argument for our having access to Scotland’s resources, so that we can deliver that desirable outcome? [Applause.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

The problem for the First Minister is that he wants to make this a cheap political debate between him and me. I can deal with that—that is not a problem. [Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

Of course, under the First Minister’s prescription for Scotland we would have less money to spend on public services. While his friends on the back benches applaud his oft-heard script, he should reflect on the fact that that script, which he trots out every time the NHS is mentioned, sounds very much like complacency to staff and patients who live in the real world and who deal with the problems daily.

We have been warning the First Minister about the mounting problems in our NHS for the past two years, but every time we do so we get the same old script. The First Minister cannot keep ignoring the reality. Brian Keighley, the leader of Scotland’s doctors, said:

“We have a crisis of out-of-hours health provision that sees huge and unacceptable queues at A&E Departments. We see reports of geriatric provision coming under increasing criticism through inadequate care packages and increasing bed blocking, and at the same time GPs coping with a 20 per cent increase in workload.”

He continued:

“We see vital cancer treatments delayed because of unsustainable cost and we see cracks emerging in hospital food, cleanliness, staff shortages and vacancies within both the consultant body and GP trainees.”

He finished by asking:

“And how has Scottish Government responded? It talks of 7-day provision at a time when we have an inadequate 5-day service.”

Those are the problems that our NHS staff face every day. What is the First Minister’s plan for the NHS?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

Our plan is to continue to fund the NHS in Scotland to the maximum degree, which is something that the Labour Party—neither in Scotland nor in Wales—would not commit to doing. Our plan is to get access to the resources of Scotland so that we can move beyond austerity and have a proper, responsible and reasonable increase in public spending, as John Swinney has outlined.

We know that Brian Keighley accepts that we are doing everything that we can within the Barnett formula. That is a reason to break free of the Barnett formula and to have access to the resources of Scotland.

I do not accept Johann Lamont’s description of accident and emergency and cancer waiting lists. We are acting to improve performance in accident and emergency and, as Alex Neil announced this week, we are acting to improve performance on our cancer targets. We are particularly concerned that we have moved below the 62-day target. However, the Labour Party never—not once—achieved the 62-day cancer target when it was in office.

Yes—we believe that 93 per cent of people being seen within four hours in accident and emergency is not good enough, but when the Labour Party was in power and Johann Lamont was a minister, Labour claimed that 87 per cent represented excellent performance.

Given that public satisfaction with the national health service is rising, as the social attitudes survey demonstrates; given that we committed to protecting the national health service budget in real terms, which Labour would not do; and given that our performance, under pressure though the NHS undoubtedly is, is better than when the Labour Party was in power, what possible credibility does a minister from a previous Government have in complaining about the situation when public finances are under pressure, when that party could not run Scotland when public money was plentiful?

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02209)

Tricia Marwick The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Order. Settle down! [Interruption.] Ms Grahame!

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

I have engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

That is not a problem. We can do that, but we let the people of Scotland down every time we settle for that on the big issues, or say that the only solution is independence. It is not just me raising the questions; they are being raised by the head of the BMA, nurses, patients and people in our constituencies who every day are being let down by a Government whose members are not interested in the NHS or in anything but the obsession that took them into politics in the first place.

Every time that I, on behalf of the people of Scotland, have asked the First Minister about blanket shortages, unacceptable waiting times in accident and emergency units, lack of access to cancer drugs, cancer waiting times, elderly people left on trolleys for hours, older people getting 15-minute care visits, doctor shortages and anything else about the NHS, the First Minister has told me—we have heard it again today—that people are happy with our health service, that it is getting privatised in England, and that it would be worse if we were Welsh. Those are inadequate answers to serious questions. The First Minister has told us that this is a really serious issue for the people of Scotland, so it deserves better than that.

The First Minister has told us that he has a plan A, B, C, D, E and F for a currency in an independent Scotland. Does he not realise that what Scotland wants and what our hard-working doctors and nurses are demanding from him is any kind of plan for the NHS today?

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

Thank you. On Tuesday, the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing, Alex Neil, said that

“Satisfaction with our NHS has increased by 20 per cent over the last seven years”

and that

“nearly two thirds of people in Scotland claim to be satisfied with our health service”.

On the same day, the outgoing head of the British Medical Association Scotland, Dr Brian Keighley, said:

“What I have seen over the past five years is the continuing crisis management of the longest car crash in my memory—and it is time for our politicians to face up to some very hard questions.”

I agree with Brian Keighley, who speaks for national health service staff all over the country. Can the First Minister tell the people of Scotland why the leader of Scotland’s doctors is wrong?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

I see that Johann Lamont does not think it important that the NHS in Scotland is being kept in public hands and is not being subjected to disintegration. That is very interesting, because Brian Keighley did not say that in his speech this week to BMA Scotland. He said:

“What is totally clear is that the NHS that we have in Scotland is fundamentally different from that in England in terms of philosophy and organisation. North of the border we have been spared the spectacle of a huge organisation being thrown in the air, with only speculation as a guide to where the pieces might land. We have avoided wholesale reorganisation, NHS managers’ games of musical chairs and the worst excesses of the use of the NHS as a party political football. And for that we must be thankful.”

If Brian Keighley, whom Johann Lamont has cited, thinks that that is important, why does the Labour Party not think it important? Is it perhaps because Andy Burnham has talked about having a common health service across the UK and about leaving the health service in Scotland to the tender mercies of the privatisation agenda that is being pursued at Westminster?

Johann Lamont does not want to talk about what the public thinks of the national health service. The increase in national health service performance in terms of accident and emergency and cancer care is reflected in the 21 per cent increase in public satisfaction. Eighty-five per cent of Scottish in-patients have said that overall care and treatment was good or excellent; 87 per cent rated the performance of their general practitioner surgery as good or excellent; and 84 per cent of social care users rated their overall care and support as good or excellent. Those are real people in the real world, who understand the commitment and strength of the people in the national health service, and who understand that those people are supported by a Government that has funded the service in real terms and which would be able to do a great deal more in an independent Scotland.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

I will deal first with the question of the public’s satisfaction with the national health service. That information was not from an opinion poll or some snap survey, but from the social attitudes survey for Scotland, which is the most detailed assessment of social attitudes in the country. It demonstrated that satisfaction with the national health service has risen to 61 per cent. By way of comparison, when Johann Lamont was a minister in 2006 it was at 45 per cent. Johann Lamont started by saying that that was a claim by Alex Neil, but it is actually from that survey, which is the most detailed assessment of public attitudes. We can compare directly the level of satisfaction with our national health service today with the level of satisfaction that existed when Labour was in power, and there is now a strongly rising trend.

Brian Keighley wants more funds for the national health service, and he makes the entirely reasonable point that, despite the fact that the national health service has had its budget protected in real terms, it is under sustained pressure because of the rising demand for health services. How do I know that? I know because Brian Keighley said on “Good Morning Scotland” on 24 June:

“I accept that the SNP has done as much with the Barnett Formula and resources that are available to them”.

When Johann Lamont says that Brian Keighley says that the NHS is under pressure, as indeed he did, we must remember that he also said—and accepted—that we are doing everything that we can within the resources that are available to us to provide for our national health service. That may be one reason why satisfaction with the national health service is on a rising trend.

The other reason, of course, will be that the people of Scotland understand the work and performance of our people in the national health service who are delivering such an excellent result, even under pressure.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

Dr Brian Keighley is a member of staff in the health service, so the First Minister ought to listen to what he is saying. He should not pick only one thing that Brian Keighley has said, but should reflect on everything that he says.

With accident and emergency targets missed, cancer targets missed and care for the elderly in crisis, the man who represents Scotland’s doctors—Brian Keighley—said:

“The current service is teetering on the edge of collapse.”

The leader of Scotland’s doctors also said:

“My main regret is that I have not been able to do more than act as a deckchair attendant on the good ship NHS Titanic.”

Can the First Minister tell the people of Scotland why the leader of Scotland’s doctors is wrong and he is right?

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. National Health Service (Complaints) Questions · 10
  2. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
  3. Your GP Cares Campaign Debate · 20
  4. Budget Outturn 2013-14 Debate · 27
  5. Polypropylene Mesh Devices Debate · 31
  6. City of Edinburgh Council (Portobello Park) Bill: Final Stage Bill debate · 20
  7. Homophobic Hate Crimes Questions · 5
  8. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
  9. “Transitioning to a new Scottish state” First Minister’s Questions · 8
  10. Medical Certificate of Cause of Death Questions · 4
  11. “Management Information Year End 2013/14” First Minister’s Questions · 6
  12. Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
  13. British-Irish Council (Meetings) Questions · 4
  14. Fisheries (Sanctions on Faroe Islands) Questions · 4
  15. Fixed-odds Betting Terminals and Payday Lenders First Minister’s Questions · 4
  16. “Empowering Scotland’s Island Communities” Questions · 4
  17. Decision Time Decision time · 3
  18. Commonwealth Games (Disruption in Dalmarnock) Questions · 4
  19. Emergency Patients (Movement) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  20. Affordable Housing Supply Programme Questions · 5

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.